Verified Document

Overprotective Parenting Research Paper

Parenting comes in al forms and ranges, just as different as individuals are. Fortunately, parents have today the possibility to get much better informed than they ever had before. Not only has child psychology made huge progress over the last few decades, but widely available information related to child rearing as well as numerous testimonies from parents themselves has made the parenting task easier, but also more complex at the same time. As people become better informed, society becomes more competitive. Parents tend to put more pressure on themselves in order to prove they are better parents, fit for this new global age of information and their children sometimes suffer the consequences. While some things have tremendously changed, especially since women have started going to work more often than they used to do before the second half of the twentieth century, some things are remained the same. This is visible in the department of overprotecting parenting.

Parenting will always be tributary first to each parent's nature and inclinations, as well as to the way the parents themselves used be raised as children. In their book: Loving Your Child Too Much: Raise Your Kids Without Overindulging ..., the authors, Tim Clinton and Gary Sibcy, are trying to make parents aware of the categories their child raising style is falling into as well as point out the means and methods to use in order to establish a healthy relationship between children and parents. Most people must have wondered at least once if there is such a thing as "healthy parent - child" relationships in the first place. One thing is certain: love is absolutely necessary and without it nothing can work. On the other side, love is far from guaranteeing the soundness of such a complicated and crucial relationship as that between children and parents.

There might be a slight misunderstanding between the question:" can there be too much love involved in parenting?" And "can a parent be too indulgent in a child-parent relationship"? Authors Dr. Henry Cloud and Dr. John Townsend talk about another interesting concept when it comes to parenting: healthy love. The title of their book, Boundaries with Kids does not leave much space for interpretation: the book will not preach about the power of endless love as the miracle it takes to build the best relationship possible with one's children, be about boundaries and, most importantly how to set them, when, where, how and why.

Authors Clinton and Sibcy describe the ways to overprotect as a list of mistakes that every parent must have done at least once in his parenting experience. The list is long and eye opening. Naturally, loving parents are reluctant to talk to their children about death, regardless if it is the case of a gold fish the child had as a pet or, and the case become much more complicated and disturbing, a relative, or someone they used to know. The authors point out that common sense is important here, as well as in most inter-human relationships, thus the parent must be aware of the level of the child's understanding and the appropriate age to talk about a particular subject. The authors stress the importance about telling one's children the truth. They also explain what "always telling the truth" involves from a common sense point-of-view: "of course, that doesn't mean that you dump the harsh realities of life on them when they are too young to understand, or when it's just too frightening. But you should truthfully answer their questions in a way that's age appropriate." (Clinton, Sibcy, 2006) So, first of all parenting has to be adapted to a child's stage of development, otherwise what could be a useful piece of information could become something completely useless or even damaging.

Cloud and Townsend further talk about perspective. Parents, especially those who tend to be overprotective, often suffer from a short sight. It is only the present that concerns and oftentimes overwhelms them: "We parent in the present without thinking about the future. We usually deal with the problems at hand."(Cloud and Townsend, 2001). This is of course, not just a problem of overprotective parents, but of all those who find themselves at their wits end after a long exhausting day. They talk about some thought every parent, except for a saint, must have had at least once in his life: "making it through an afternoon without wanting to send our children to an eight-year camp in Alaska seems like a huge accomplishment"(Clinton...

Those who are stricter inflict a heavy punishment for a less than regulation made bed." (Cloud and Townsend, 2001) In Allison's case, she acted the way she would have with anyone she built a relationship with. The effects on her childrearing were similar to those involving overprotection: by keeping her son from doing a simple thing like clearing, she was not actually helping him in the long run, she was just raising a future adult that will not be able to keep things in order in his dorm room, in college, for example and will be more likely to run into fights with the rest of his companions over his failing to do his duties, for example. The author, who happened to witness Allison as she was clearing his teenage son's room, warned her about the future, from an en even more frightening perspective: that of him expecting his wife to behave the same as his mother did and do all those chores the latter was currently performing instead of letting him deal with them.
Clinton and Sibcy draw a very interesting table in their book, a table they call Love comparison chart. The authors agree that each individual is unique, thus each parent-child relationship is unique, even in the case of the same parents, but different children, but it is also true that parents can and should learn from other parents as well as from their own passed failure or successes.

The two authors take the main categories of parenting, ranging from the much desired "normal" parenting style, over to the "overprotecting," going through the overcontrolling ," to reach the "overindulging" parenting style. There are some similarities between. There are some similarities as well as a good deal of difference between these styles, of course. What strikes one in the case of overprotective parents, is the constant presence of the word "fear." They mostly see their children as fragile, that is why they will do everything in their power to protect them, allowing them to make no mistakes. What will follow naturally will be adults that will act or better said, not act out of fear: fear of failing, fear of being rejected, fear of making mistakes, fear of being hurt, basically fear of living normally. The authors assure parents that "protecting your children from the evils of the world is a God-given responsibility."(Clinton&Sibcy) They also add the warning that "overprotecting will bruise the spirit and keep the kids from growing into strong independent adults capable of earning trust and making good decisions. "(Clinton&Sibcy) Many parents never think that, from the point-of-view of child rearing, the best time in a person's life to start exploring, trying on one's own, commit mistakes and learn from them, is when that person is in his or her childhood and teenage years. The parents or guardians will be there to offer comfort, guidance, and a helping hand when needed. Children and teenagers will get a second and third chance. As adults, they will be completely on their own and thus likely to make a fall mush harder than back when they had their parents to care for them and take some of the burden away.

Both books we have discussed so far start from the general idea that sound parenting should rely on biblical teachings. Children are taught to love themselves so that that can love the others and be loved. The source of endless love that comes from God should guide and help them find a way just as their parents are expected to love and guide them through their lives.

Parents who will never allow their children to make mistakes, will also try to keep them away from any kind of pain as long as they will be around. Clinton and Sibcy explain the notion of "necessary pain" and what role it plays in the development of the future adult. Performance involves a degree of pain, just as spiritual evolution involves a degree of pain. The Bible is their most important guide here, too: "We also rejoice in our suffering because we know that suffering produces perseverance, perseverance, character and character, hope."(Clinton & Sibcy). That does not mean, of course, that children must endure pain at all costs and regardless of its degree of necessity. It also does not mean that…

Sources used in this document:
Oftentimes, parenting styles overlap. The overprotective parent will also have tendencies of being over-controlling. For them to be able to keep their sons and daughters out of danger, they need to constantly interfere, know everything there is to know in order to make decisions for them. The chances for such children to rebel and take the wrong decision in order to escape parental despotism are high. Or, children could act up as if they are accepting their parents' terms only to lead double lives, completely opposed to what they pretend they are actually doing in front of their parents. These are only two of the dangers of overprotectiveness through over control methods. Children raised this way are likely to be miserable later in life.

Child psychologists are inclined to think now that the first years in a child life are crucial to a person's development. That is why parents are encouraged to get involved at pay attention to their children even from the very early stages in the latter's development. This does not equal, of course, excess of anxiety and over control that are likely to flood over the later stages of their children's lives. It means taking parenting as serious as it gets in order to be able to prepare one's children for living their lives the way they should, with equal opportunities of actually building healthy relationships themselves. Society will be thankful to those parents who will be able to recognize their mistakes and willing to correct them.

Cloud, Henry & Townsend John. 2001. Boundaries with Kids: How Healthy Choices Grow Healthy Children. Zondervan Clinton, Tim & Sibcy, Gary. 2006. Loving Your Child Too Much: Raise Your Kids Without Overindulging, Overprotecting or Overcontrolling. Thomas Nelson
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Overprotective Parenting As Teenagers, Children Are Very
Words: 3421 Length: 12 Document Type: Research Paper

Overprotective Parenting As teenagers, children are very dependent on their parents. They rely on parents for food and shelter, for transportation, for financial support, and so on. However, parents often take their responsibilities too far, and their concern for the child's welfare and desire to be good parents may cause them to stifle the child's growth. This kind of parenting is known as overprotective parenting. In ideal situations, parents allow for

Counseling-Children Overprotective Parenting It Is
Words: 632 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

They do not believe in the capability of the growing child to make his or her own decisions. In short, instead of parenting and mothering, they are smothering the child. As children grow up, this fear-centered thinking is imbibed into their personality, making them equally afraid of certain things and experiences. They grow up to be socially incompetent and immature individuals who do not know what to do without

Overly Protective Parent
Words: 3246 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

Overly Protective Parents All parents care about their children; about their education, food, security etc. But sometimes this concern can be transformed into something almost obsessive that compels some parents to constantly monitor every movement of their children and be over controlling. Some children of overprotective parents can end up being aggressive, but can also develop a withdrawn or anti-social personality. Such children also tend to be insecure, have low self-esteem

Sociology Parenting Neglect
Words: 1896 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Maryland couple was charged with neglect because they allowed their children -- aged 10 and 6 -- to walk one mile home from a park. The irony of this situation is that those doing the charging likely made similar walks by themselves as children, and they did it all the time. It is not strange that some parents prefer to hover over their children obsessively -- the lines of

Indulgent Parenting Vs. Authoritative Parenting
Words: 1085 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Indulgent vs. Authoritative Parenting mother and her daughter walk through the aisles at a grocery store. As they stroll through the cereal aisle, the young girl begs her mom for the newest sugar-laden breakfast treat. When her mom says no, the girl begins to whine and beg, and proceeds to throw a mini-tantrum. Her wails grow louder and other shoppers start to stare. The mother, obviously an indulgent parent, reaches

Montessori School Advantages Why Would a Parent
Words: 2498 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Montessori School Advantages Why would a parent send a child to a Montessori classroom? The answer to that question will be provided in this paper, because Montessori schools provide educational opportunities for children that are rarely if ever successfully offered elsewhere. The strategies employed by Montessori teachers are far more holistic than in traditional public school environments, and hence, Montessori has earned a sterling reputation therein. This paper provides the background

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now