Verified Document

Orwell Vs. Huxley Essay

¶ … Brave New World The two books 1984 and Brave New World reflect futuristic views that are quite different and dichotomous. Indeed, 1984 reflects a world of dystopia and punitive government while the work Brave New World reflects one of more utopian conditions but is no less controlled and crafted by a master plan. The noted social critic Neil Postman postulates that Huxley's version of the world in Brave New World more closely matches that of our current actual world. However, while there is some grain of truth to that, there are some facets of Brave New World that are not in place now and the chances of that changing in the foreseeable future is practically nil in the view of the author of this report.

Analysis

First up on this report will be a compare and contrast of the two works in general terms. First off, an obvious difference between the two books is that 1984 is a dystopian view while Brave New World is utopian. In 1984, suffering and struggle is the norm and the oppressive government is in complete command and control. There is also command and control in the Brave New World system but it is manifested quite differently and is perceived much differently by the populace. The need to reproduce is not an issue as people are "hatched." People are also assigned to their life's task of work so there is not any competitiveness. However, there are some issues that would be rather macabre or immoral to some. Casual sex is the norm and the concept of family is considered obscene. While some are on board with the contraception belts and so forth, character Linda laments being treated like a walking, talking sex toy. Linda's revelation about her son and the scandal associated with the father of said child (the Director) (Orwell)(Huxley).

The view of Postman when he says that the conditions in modern society are more like A Brave New World than...

First, while the modern world of today is by no means a utopia in the eyes of many, the treatment of sex as a minor and trivial thing given the consequences it can render such as Linda's child and the perception of some that they are just sex objects rather than people is strong parallels and corollaries to today's society. Also applicable to today's society is the use of drugs (soma) and being forced into a life's path. Many people are fine with their assigned lot in life but Linda is absolutely not as she wants the aforementioned soma and her city life back. Also, the attraction of family with Linda is obvious given her birth child even if the general practice and feeling about family in society is verboten (Orwell)(Huxley).
Another test case in A Brave New World that can be compared to modern society in the United States and Europe is that of John who revels in sleeping with whichever women she wants. Also prevalent in both A Brave New World and modern society is the riot that is described in the book and a general roiling of some against the lot that they have been assigned in life. Indeed, many people in the United States (just as one example country) speak of the "death" of the middle class, the need for a living wage and racial tensions. There is significant blowback against anyone that states the slavery and racism of the "past" is over. One need only look at the LA riots in the 1990's or Ferguson, MO right not to see this in action (Orwell)(Huxley).

The "big brother" and other aspects in 1984 can be somewhat drawn to modern society but not nearly to the extent and degree presented in the book. While warfare is indeed present in several corners of the world, with much of it being in Africa and the Middle East, most of the current real world is peaceful. There is some unrest and protests in Hong…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Huxley, Aldous. Brave new world. New York: Harper Perennial Modern Classics, 2006.

Print.

Orwell, George, Thomas Pynchon, and Erich Fromm. Nineteen eighty-four: a novel.

Centennial ed. New York City: Signet, 2003. Print.
1970. Web. 9 Oct. 2014. <http://www.cnn.com/2012/08/09/politics/btn-guns-in-america/>.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Orwell & Huxley Moving Toward
Words: 1581 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

" Why is this the case? Why are some concerned about privacy and others not at all? The answer lies in the fact that society is mirroring both authors' perspectives, Orwell's and Huxley's -- one fearful and the other apathetic. Society is thus a dichotomy of two anti-utopian visions. Yet, Zittrain, like Boyd and Baym, supports the new media technology by asserting that "the Net is quite literally what we make

Orwell's Warning: 1984 George Orwell
Words: 1199 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

In 1984, this idea is demonstrated with Thought Police. It is certainly bad enough to never feel alone in one's own community but it even worse to never feel alone in one's own head. This idea is maddening, as Orwell illustrates through Winston. He says, "At home and in bed in the darkness you were safe from the telescreen so long as you kept silent" (96-7). Here we see

Huxley & G. Orwell Two
Words: 2815 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Whatever happened you vanished, and neither you nor your actions were ever heard of again" (Orwell, 1949, p.168). Capitalism Principles of mass production are very clear in the novels. Huxley for instance, applied the idea of mass production in human reproduction, since the people has abandoned the natural method of reproduction. Mass production as the conventional feature of capitalism and Huxley's novel reinforces such. He talked about the requirement of the

George Orwell 1984
Words: 454 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

Accuracy of George Orwell's Predictions George Orwell chose a specific date, 1984, for the title of his novel predicting the evolution of society by that date. However we are now 18 years past that date and his predictions have not come true. How could Orwell have been so wrong? Or was he only wrong about the exact timing and still correct about his general predictions? To understand Orwell's view of

George Orwell's Last Novel, 1984, Was Released
Words: 1191 Length: 4 Document Type: Book Review

George Orwell's last novel, 1984, was released in 1949. The world was still reeling from the effects of World War II and the Soviet Union was emerging as the next great threat to world security. That same year, the Western world watched as the Soviet Union exploded the first atomic bomb, sparking forty years of the Cold War. Supporters of capitalism and democracy quickly hailed the book as a warning

Criticism on Author Aldous Huxley
Words: 1152 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Aldous Huxley The purpose of this work is to explore Aldous Huxley's view of religion, his belief in "moderate" applicable use of mind-altering and mind-expanding drugs as well as the prediction he made for the future of mankind. This will be done through reading of his works, as well as one interview. Aldous Huxley has been described as many things such as the great "English novelist," "essayist," "iconoclast," "social prophet," and "proponent

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now