Verified Document

Old Smoke The Case Of "Old Smoke" Essay

Old Smoke The case of "Old Smoke" presents workplace issues involving cigarette smoke, perfume and body odor. The employer is responsible for upholding law and company policy, as well as using common sense and tact to deal with possibly competing employee interests while continuing to effectively meet business requirements. Though laws and company policy sometimes assist in formulating solutions, employers are also charged with creative thinking to deal with some workplace issues uncovered by law and/or policy.

Explain how you would handle this situation if you were Charles Renfold

Charles Renfold has competing problems. Darlene Lambert is an employee entitled to a safe workplace, including freedom from second-hand smoke and the scent of old smoke. Simultaneously, Renfold has a pressing deadline for a report requiring Darlene's assistance with files located in a room that strongly smells of old smoke (Shaw, 2010, p. 339). Darlene rightfully refuses to work in that environment. Renfold cannot force Darlene to work in the "unsafe" file room, yet he needs her work on the files to complete the report. Consequently, Renfold should quickly and inexpensively relocate the files to an area in which Darlene can access the files without being subjected to the bad effects of smoke. He should have the files moved to an alternate, smoke-free area in which Darlene can work. The files may be moved by either Alice and Frank -- the smokers -- or other staff who normally perform heavy lifting and moving. Since the old smoke smell permeates everything, including the files, in the file room, the files should be moved to an exceptionally airy area. After providing the files in a smoke-free area, Renfold should tell Darlene that he has done the best to accommodate her, that the report must be completed ASAP or she will risk...

After Darlene finishes her work for the report, Renfold should fulfill his promise and have all documents refiled in newer, smoke-smell-free files.
3. Describe the policy on smoking that you would recommend to Redwood Associates

The law requires provision of a smoke-free area for employees who wish to have one; simultaneously, there is no law against smoking in the workplace. In addition, banning smoking altogether could mean eliminating some very talented employees who happen to smoke. Consequently, Redwood Associates should provide a mostly-smoke-free environment while also providing an area in which people can smoke. If the smoking area is within the building, it should be distant enough from other areas so that smoke and smoke smell cannot permeate the smoke-free areas; in addition, the internal smoke area should have a separate ventilation system so the smoke and smoke smell is not ventilated into smoke-free areas. If, on the other hand, the smoke area is located outside the building, provisions should be made for shelter so that smokers can use the smoke area in all seasons and weather conditions.

4. Explain how this case would change if what bothers Darlene is not old smoke but the smell of Alice's perfume or Frank's body odor

Alice's perfume and/or Frank's body order do not have the currently visceral and legal implications of cigarette/cigar/pipe smoke. While Darlene is entitled by law to a smoke-free work area, she is not currently entitled to a scent-free work area. Nevertheless, the problematic effects of workplace scents have been discussed for decades (Winterbauer & Diamond P.L.L.C.,…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Shaw, W.H. (2010). Business ethics: A textbook with cases, 7th ed. Boston, MA: Wadsworth, Cengage Learning.

Winterbauer & Diamond P.L.L.C. (1998). Multiple chemical sensitivity and the ADA: Taking a clear picture of a blurry object. Retrieved on February 23, 2012 from Winterbauerdiamond.com Web site: http://www.winterbauerdiamond.com/inprint/Doc040629.PDF
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Old Smoke Case Study Darlene
Words: 1536 Length: 4 Document Type: Book Report

cannot control the urge, then the employee might consider seeking outside professional help with the addiction. Since a person's car is private property, however, it is unlikely that any non-smoking ban would extend to that area. However, the smoker would need to take steps to ensure that their clothing and work supplies did no retain the odor of smoke. In essence, other than in the privacy of one's own

Old Smoke- Kantainism Workplace Ban
Words: 691 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

In the case of Darlene and old smoke, we can thus say that employers need to ask themselves what they would want in this situation so strongly that they would wish it were the law. There are many courses of action available to them such as they can force Darlene to work in the main file room, they can force Frank and Alice to quit smoking complete or they

Smoke Detectors in the United
Words: 3420 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

NIST emphasized the requirement for instantaneous reaction to a trigger alarm and demonstrated that individuals trapped in a blazing fire have an average of three minutes from an alarm's first warning to flee. The 17 minutes NIST recorded in its decisive smoke alarm tests in the 1970s is in contrast to the three-minute fleeing window for blazing fires according to said Richard Bukowski, the NIST researcher who carried out

Old Nurse's Story by Elizabeth Gaskell
Words: 1943 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Old Nurse's Story Elizabeth Gaskell's "The Old Nurse's Story" uses gothic imagery and Victorian themes to elucidate the role and status of women. Online critics claim the story is filled with themes of "male domination, females' sense of powerlessness due to this dominance, and the ambiguous results of women's struggle against males in the Victorian era," ("The Damning Effects of a Patriarchal Society in "The Old Nurse's Story" and "The Yellow

Older Adult Assessment Maslow's Hierarchy
Words: 1934 Length: 4 Document Type: Interview

He is still deeply in love with his wife, as though he just met her . He expresses his love on a daily bases with his wife, with hugs, kisses, and showers her with lavish gifts . They cuddle in the evenings in the family room for an evening of relaxation watching television or reading . Although the sexual physical part of their life as slowed down, they still

Case Study and Nursing
Words: 1831 Length: 6 Document Type: Case Study

Advance Nursing Practice In order to sustain life, the human body has to have oxygen. When a person cannot breathe, or there is not enough oxygen coming into the body through the act of breathing, it is not possible for life to continue. The respiratory system is what provides the person with the opportunity to breathe and take in oxygen. Carbon dioxide is also expelled that same way. If oxygen is

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now