Verified Document

Nurse Practitioners And The Problem Of Discounting Term Paper

¶ … Martin, P.D. And Hutchinson, S.A (1999) "Nurse Practitioners and the problem of discounting." Journal of Advanced Nursing. 29(1), pp. 9-17. Critical evaluation of the research of the article

This article presents a critique of the current state of the health care industry, from the point-of-view of a nurse practitioner. It notes that, because of the limits of managed care, more primary care practitioners and primary care institutions are turning to nurse practitioners to provide primary care giving for patients. Although this shift has been beneficial to many patients, given that nurse practitioners are, if not equally competent, at times even more efficient than physicians in diagnosing, treating, providing patients with satisfactory treatment, and follow-up, there is the potential for the abuse of this system, from the point-of-view of the nursing practitioner. (Brown and Grimes, 1993, cited in Martin & Hutchinson, 1999, 10).

Research problem -- its purpose and question or hypothesis

Thus, the central question is, is such an evaluation of the current state of care a fair and a just one from the point-of-view of nursing as a profession? Are nursing practitioners being abused because of the current state of the health care profession? The hypothesis or tentative assumption behind the study is yes. But if so, exactly how is this occurring? Why is it occurring? And how can the system be remedied to make the current modalities of providing care more beneficial to nursing practitioners, without compromising patient care?

Review of the currently existing literature

It has been suggested in the past that despite the efficacy of NPs, quite often nurse practitioners have been subject to the practice of 'discounting,' defined by the study as the practitioners...

This results not only in hurt feelings upon the part of the practitioner. It also results in the practitioner's ability to dispense care being compromised, and the patient's resultant health being put into jeopardy needlessly.
Discounting" can include everything from the nursing practitioner being ignored to being openly, verbally abused. (Martin & Hutchinson, 1999, 12) Nurses have reported being ignored, or even their most mundane and basic care-giving activities being questioned and belittled in a degrading manner. (Martin & Hutchinson, 1999, 12)

Theoretical/conceptual framework of the study

The framework of the study was more experiential in nature than it is statistical or data based. Its theoretical framework was designed so that, through a relatively small sampling of nurses, crucial experiential data might be accrued that is of use in determining how discounting occurs 'in the field.'

Research design

Twenty-four NPs were studied from the state of Florida, twenty of who were female, and twenty-one of who were white. Two African-American women also were represented. All had master's degrees in the nursing field. (Martin & Hutchinson, 1999, 10) It was hoped that this gender balance would be representative of the nursing field, and even though the majority of the practitioners were white, the presence of non-white staff members would provide some insight into how race as well as gender functioned in the care setting.

Sampling method/data collection

Data collection techniques included in-depth, open-ended interviews with the subjects that were observed and recorded through auditory and visual means, as well…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Martin, P.D. And Hutchinson, S.A (1999) "Nurse Practitioners and the problem of discounting." Journal of Advanced Nursing. 29(1), pp. 9-17.

Article Review
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Nurse Practitioner and Health
Words: 2233 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Advance Practice Roles in Nursing The Main Roles Within Advanced Practice Nursing Nurse Practitioners They are charged with the responsibility to provide primary health care for clinics, hospitals and similar settings. They diagnose and treat common illnesses and immunize, examine the patients and deal with high blood pressure cases among others (Macdonald, Schreiber & Davis, 2005). Certified Nurse-Midwives: They are the ones that give gynecological care and prenatal attention to the normal women with

Historical Development of the Nurse Practitioner Role
Words: 671 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Np Loretta Ford was a revolutionary in her time. She took a chaotic period of social and political unrest and used it in order to spearhead new directions for modern nursing. She helped recreate the role of the NP in a much more clinical context. The clinical emphasis of the clinical field was opened up for a new generation of nurses to expand their roles and become much more powerful

Advanced Practice Nursing
Words: 2308 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

Advanced practice nursing (APN) is one of the nursing fields that plays a critical role in the promotion of the health and wellbeing of patient populations. APN is regarded as the usage of a wider scope of logical, constructive, and research-based competence relating to patients’ health and wellbeing. This field incorporates knowledge and expertise from a variety of disciplines that are critical in the healthcare sector. Given the acute nursing

Nursing Reflective Practice As Applied
Words: 3953 Length: 14 Document Type: Term Paper

In the previous section, Estabrooks raised the question of the ability of the EBP framework to provide the "best evidence" in nursing practice and the danger of excluding nurses in decision-making tasks as a result of EBP prevalence and dominance. Rolfe, while he analyzed the empirical foundations of EBP, also looked at it from a practical perspective, or how EBP is applied in the current practice of nursing. Identifying the

Community Health Nursing
Words: 1750 Length: 5 Document Type: Case Study

Community Health Nursing The contribution that a community healthcare unit can make towards enhancing population health and minimizing inequalities is strengthened by international law. Primary healthcare has demonstrated to have an independent impact on improving the status of health within the community. It also affects the reduction of health inequalities and the achievement of improved health outcomes at a relatively low cost and making the healthcare system sustainable. There is substantial

Practice Extrapolate Strategies Propose Close Theory-Practice Gap
Words: 1396 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Practice Extrapolate strategies propose close theory-practice gap nursing. Must 3 specific articles 2 choosing a total 5 references. This master's degree Nursing Theory Course. The paper 3-5 pages length APA format. The theory-practice gap in nursing: Different perspectives and strategies to close the 'gap' According to many nurses, there exists a "gap between nursing theory and practice. In order to improve the integration of theory and practice, a high standard of clinical practice

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now