Verified Document

Nullification Jury Nullification When One Article Critique

Today we do not have the reassurance that injustice as a result of jury nullifications are behind us. Racism is still a prevalent issue in our society and it is concentrated at times within communities, making it possible to have a majority within the jury carrying prejudices into the courtroom. Shamefully our courts have had to let rapists walk because "Juries have acquitted & #8230; after concluding that the victims deserved to be raped because of the way they dressed or acted" (King, 1999, p. 4). It is evident that "jurors are not in any better position than judges or prosecutors to decide which defendants should be exempted from a law's reach" (King, 1999, p. 5).

Because juries are comprised of people who may or may not be familiar with the details of the law - and are largely not lawmakers themselves - we run the risk of nullifications being haphazardly granted based on appeals to emotion, rather than through the lens of objective justice-seeking. While proponents claim that "nullification is needed for "fine-tuning" of the law," jurors are hardly qualified to handle this. The judgment of juries about the validity and necessity of a particular law is askew because they may not know the history or be cognizant of the consequences of allowing someone to walk who is clearly guilty of breaking that law. King (1999) says, "when facts are not in issue and guilt is clear, the ability of jurors to reach sound decisions about when the law should...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

5).
Even with these dangers, proponents lead us to believe that jury nullification is some kind of right that juries have under the Constitution. Several problems exist with this fallacy because in truth, " the Constitution does not support an enhanced lawmaking role for juries." Jurors swear in and are under oath while serving our courts and "have no personal constitutional right to disregard the law" (King, 1999, p. 6). The "Constitution does not protect jury nullification itself. It protects a defendant's right to fact-finding by a jury and to the finality of a verdict" (King, 1999, p. 6).

The risks of allowing jury nullifications to continue as unregulated jaunts of careless judging on the part of individuals who may or may not understand the ramifications of their actions, or the details of the law, let alone the ideals under which the trial by jury process was established are dangerous at best. If jury nullification cannot realistically be stopped, it needs to be regulated. Until this process is regulated we are rolling the dice with each and every criminal trial. Rather than respecting the law and the history that has guided our democracy into the just system we have now we are turning the courtroom into a casino and spinning the roulette wheel on justice.

References

Conrad, C.S., & King, N. (1999, May 24). Symposim. Insight on the…

Sources used in this document:
References

Conrad, C.S., & King, N. (1999, May 24). Symposim. Insight on the News. Retrieved from http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1571/is_19_15/ai_54736559/?tag=content;col1
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Jury System Is Ineffective Because
Words: 467 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

The jury system in inefficient because it relies on compulsory civil service that most people wish to avoid. Since long deliberations add to the length of jury service, jurors serving compulsory terms have a natural incentive to reach a verdict as soon as possible, which often influences the decision of minority opinion holders to join the majority irrespective of their beliefs and wholly apart from the separate issue of social

U.S. Jury System
Words: 1848 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

United States Jury System In United States courts, the jury is a system by which, in theory, defendants are given a trial that is fair and unbiased. The ideal is that twelve persons from the same peer group as the defendant will be able to deliberate without prejudice the position of the defense, and the outcome of the trial. In reality however it is often the case that jury members

Trial by Jury
Words: 953 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Trial by Jury One of the most controversial issues today in the area of criminal justice is that of the right of all defendants to a trial by jury their peers. While most arguments are for or against this right, careful consideration of specific issues and kinds of cases suggests that trial by jury should not be abolished entirely, but should not be an absolute right. The idea of trial by

Trial by Jury
Words: 1100 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Trial by Jury -- a right that must be upheld, in part One of the most controversial issues today in the area of criminal justice is that of the right of all defendants to a trial by jury of his or her peers. Often, as seen in the pairing of the essays of the noted defense attorney, media personality, and Harvard Legal scholar Alan Dershowitz against the words of Christie Davies,

Ethnicity Influences Courtroom Proceedings and Judicial Practices....
Words: 1021 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

ethnicity influences courtroom proceedings and judicial practices. The law making against racial discrimination has reduced the intensity of ethnical influences on courtroom proceedings yet the judicial practices are not free from the impurities of racist impact. Some ethnic backgrounds offer less educational facilities due to poverty that leads to criminal activities. Thus these ethnic groups are more involved in criminal judicial practices than the others. The minds of police are

Trash Covers Represent an Excellent Technique in
Words: 2042 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Trash covers represent an excellent technique in the investigation of terrorist organizations. Begin by listing those items that might typically be found in your discarded trash that would provide details regarding you personally; your interests, lifestyle, associates, family, business, income, debts etc. Be honest and be thorough in your response. Follow your response by listing items that investigators might be interested in locating in the trash of suspect terrorists and

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now