Verified Document

New Worlds For All: Europeans, Term Paper

And even when they were not, and returned to Europe sniffing and huffing in letters and treatises about the evils of Native, pagan ways, they wielded some of their harshest critical words against Europeans who had 'gone native.' (4) These critiques are an example of how Calloway as a historian finds some portrait of how Native ways were before and after European settlers, how the settler's influence changed Native ways, and of the usefulness even of biased accounts of such early encounters between Natives and Europeans. Calloway thus deals firstly with the assumed static and polarized war of historians that have given a misleading view of Indian and European interactions, before proceeding into the more rich and complex history provided by primary sources. However, he admits that his thesis is not without precedent, for as early as 1952, one historian noted that sports, agriculture, education, government, and all other facets of American life have seen the influence of Native influence. Without the Native Americans, observed James Axtell, another secondary historical commentator in Calloway's line of thought, America would not exist as we have come to think of it, despite early efforts of Europeans at cultural recreations. (4)

Natives did not always want to adopt European ways either. But the European cargo of "germs and guns" amongst other things, meant that they had no choice but to adapt to the shift in circumstances. If one tribe attempted to live as it always had, the addition of horses, guns, and other elements of warfare naturally upset the delicate power balance between tribes. The Europeans were also political actors of influence in...

During King Philips' War the Iroquois in particular played the different European actors against one another. (146) Indians spoke Spanish and gave some of their words to the settlers, not by choice, but by simple contact. (173) Some tribes trapped and hunted native game like beavers to extinction in exchange for horses. (16) Others were decimated by illness -- and yes, some practiced active military resistance. Either way, all sides were changed in a way that resists easy categorization, Calloway points out, supporting his thesis with such specific examples of economic and linguistic impingements upon Native life that were not always resisted by the tribes.
Calloway's book is valuable not simply because of the wealth of information and specifics he uses to show the ways different cultures can combine to produce a new nation and culture. It also shows that from the beginning, there was no seamless and harmonious American identity, that America was a land founded in many cultures, in pluralities of attitude even amongst Native peoples. European culture was simply another addition to the rich cultural complexities of mixing religions, ethnicities, and identities. If Calloway's thesis occasionally leads him to down play the undoubted horrors of the illness and the massacres waged against some tribes, his view is also a refreshing relief to the idea that Indians were victims, rather than historical actors of cultural significance in their own right in the early forging of a new nation.

Works Cited

Calloway, Colin. New Worlds for All: Europeans, Indians, and the Remaking of Early America. Baltimore: Johns…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Calloway, Colin. New Worlds for All: Europeans, Indians, and the Remaking of Early America. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1998.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

European Colonization of the New World
Words: 698 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

European Colonization What issues were involved in the European colonization of the New World from 1492-1640? How significant were these issues for the future course of U.S. History? The world of Columbus, of 1492, may seem like a foreign country as well as another time, when comparing the new American nation of the 18th century to the European world of the 15th century. During the period from 1492-1640, the European powers were

New World & Black Robe Both Terrence
Words: 708 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

New World" & "Black Robe" Both Terrence Malick's "The New World" and Bruce Beresford's "Black Robe" deal with themes of Native American encounters with European settlers and how it impacted both parties. There are subtle differences in each movie, but the main themes of cultures clashing and the inevitable conflict that will occur as a result permeate both films. Both films are notable for their attention to detail and their

New World an Analytical Book
Words: 608 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Knoke is on slightly surer ground as he predicts the contraction and demise of influence of multinational central banks and other depository institutions, as the World Bank has retracted in its influence. However, when he predicts the end of gigantic corporations because of regionalization, he neglects to consider the formidable force and potential of the Internet. Of course, corporations may become smaller within the next ten years as the world

New World Order Seems to
Words: 1027 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

In the long-term, the EU's economy suffers from significant demographic challenges." (Akademie de) Consider that Germany and France are ranked 1 and 3 in regard to GDP per capita and Slovakia and Slovenia are some of the poorest nations of Europe and therefore offer much less. In Euros, Germany has a 23-012 GDP per capita of 108.7%, France has 23-915 of 113.0%, Slovakia 10-857 of 51.3% and Slovenia 15-941 of

Ceremonies of Possession in Europe's Conquest of the New World 1492-1640...
Words: 1013 Length: 3 Document Type: Book Report

Ceremonies of Possession/Differences in How America Was Settled Patricia Seed in her book, Ceremonies of Possession, assumes a novel position in regard to the settlement of the New World by the various European powers. Seed's theory is that each of the five main nations involved in the settlement of the New World: England, France, Spain, Portugal, and the Netherlands, did so in their own unique way and that these unique ways

How Explorers Saw the New World
Words: 550 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Collision of Two Worlds Christopher Columbus, Hernan Cortes and Bernal Diaz all wrote very positive and glowing reports about the New World, which seem to have been in conflict with some of the harsh realities that they certainly encountered when they came to the New World. However, the fact that their glowing reports omitted some of the harsher aspects of their "discoveries" does not imply that any of these men were

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now