¶ … Negotiation and Conflict Management to Resolve Power Struggles in Health Care Settings
Many health care organizations, especially tertiary facilities, consist of large numbers of diverse professional and support staff. Not surprisingly, as with all types of organizations, turf battles take place on a regular basis, conflicts occur, and the potential for health care workers to place their self-interest above the organization's best interests is always present. To determine how managers can best use the principles of effective negotiation and conflict management to resolve power struggles within health care settings, and what types of power struggles in health care settings are most amenable to the application of negotiation and conflict management techniques, specific ways to limit the potential abuse of power in health care organizations, as well as specific human resources strategies and transparency mechanisms that can prevent stakeholders from pursuing self-interested goals, this paper provides a review of the relevant peer-reviewed and scholarly literature, followed by a summary of the research in the conclusion.
Review and Discussion
Effective negotiation and conflict management
Effective negotiation can assume a number of forms, ranging from the highly informal to the highly structured, with the approach being used depending on the specific circumstances of the conflict that is involved. Generally speaking, effective negotiation will require a format in which the stakeholders:
1. Present a sequence of arguments to support their case;
2. State their preferences;
3. Recognize and acknowledge what the other side sees as important;
4. Try to achieve an in-depth understanding of all the issues;
5. Ascertain areas of agreement and disagreement;
6. Enter into a series of offers and bids relating to personal targets;
8. Engage in a process of mutual concession-making; and,
9. Formally agree and ratify a final deal that is acceptable to both sides, and that can be successfully implemented (Hargie & Dickson, 2004, p. 372).
Unfortunately, as anyone who has ever engaged in negotiations can readily testify, the process rarely works in this fashion or this smoothly, and people can become so frustrated and angry at their inability to persuade others that they lose sight of what they are actually seeking to accomplish. In these situations, a best alternative to negotiated agreement (BATNA) should be sought that achieves the most important aspects of the negotiations while allowing compromises that promote mutual acceptance of the outcome (Hargie & Dickson, 2004). According to Bateman (2000), a BATNA is "the standard against which any proposed agreement should be measured. That is the only standard which can protect you both from accepting terms that are too unfavorable and from rejecting terms it would be in your interests to accept" (p. 120). This means that negotiators should compare any proposal with their bottom line requirements to determine if it satisfies their best interests (Bateman, 2000).
Power struggles that are especially amenable to negotiation and conflict management
There are some enormous divisions of power in many health care settings, with physicians and administrators at the top of the hierarchy, followed by other professionals such as service directors, nurse practitioners, pharmacists, radiologists and so forth. This division of power means that people at the top of the hierarchy enjoy a tactical advantage in negotiations and conflict management efforts, but that does not mean they can wield uncompromising authority; however, it does mean that some health care professionals will have views that differ markedly…
The two parties try to resolve it by themselves in an informal approach, through negotiations. However, then an agreement cannot be reached, both parties are entitled to request the assistance of a tertiary party. The third party is neutral to the two disputants and has the obligation of resolving the matter from an objective stand point and "their role is to facilitate a settlement without any control over the
The reality is that coworkers are not always going to be able to get along in a successful and productive manner without manager intervention. A manager cannot avoid the conflict and hope that it disappears, because that runs the risk of the conflict erupting or simply spreading like a cancer throughout the entire organization. Instead, the manager must address the issue. Furthermore, while the manager cannot dictate the approaches
Negotiation and Conflict Management Third party interventions are often needed in order for conflicts to be effectively resolved. Whether or not a third party intervention is necessary depends on the severity of the conflict and whether the parties involved require outside assistance to maintain some sense of objectivity and reason while sorting through their dispute. Several skills characterize an effective third party in conflict resolution. The readings outline several helpful attributes third
However, such strategy has the outcome in compliance in absence of commitment and feelings of frustration and resentment. The fourth strategy is I lose a little, you win a little. The placate yield style represents a concern for the effects of conflict on the welfare and durability of all relationships that is entered. The hypothesis is that human relationships are so flexible that they cannot endure the trauma of working
Conflict Case StudyFunctional or Dysfunctional?Conflict is a normal and healthy part of any relationship. It provides an opportunity for growth and resolution, and can even help to strengthen the bond between two people. However, not all conflict is created equal. Functional conflict is marked by healthy communication and a mutual respect for each other�s opinions. Both parties feel safe expressing their thoughts and views, and are willing to compromise in
Conflict and NegotiationFunctional or Dysfunctional?When unequal amounts of power or resources are at stake, conflict is likely to occur. In the workplace, conflict may arise between employees or between employees and management. When a conflict erupts, management may need to intervene in order to resolve the issue. Depending on the approach taken, the conflict may be classified as functional or dysfunctional. A functional conflict is one that results in a
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now