Verified Document

Negligence Of Auditors Case Study

Negligence of Auditors Policy Considerations

In the past one decade, there have been rampant cases against auditors, reflecting both on the litigious nature of a plaintiff's bar, which encourages claims against independent certified public accountants

Owing to this, there have been numerous literatures encouraging the imposition of civil liability on accountants whose actions fail to conform to professional standards. Therefore, many courts after considering the scope of an auditor's vulnerability to negligence have sought to provide some policy considerations in an attempt to protect the auditors.

Some courts have analogized the law of products liability to adopt a predictable standard, which will help them measure an accountant's liability for negligence

. In addition, another important principle, which many courts consider is the cost-benefit limitation because it works differently when compared to the financial audit. Nevertheless, prior to determining a case of negligence, the court can now measure the potential profit of the accounting firm against the possible liability exposure, in an event their reports show material errors.

Negligence Case Laws in Australia

Stone & Rolls Ltd. is a company owned and directed by Mr. Stojevic, whereas, Moore Stephens refer to the firm comprising of chartered accountants hired by Mr. Stojevic to perform audits between the year 1996 and 1998. However, the owner, Mr. Stojevic, stole the company's assets, and...

Owing to this, deceit, siphoning of the company's assets, and falsifying of accounts, the company went into liquidation
The company's creditors, wished to sue the auditors for negligence, claiming that they failed to detect the fraud. The court, in relation to this case decided that in an event, the director and shareholder of a closely managed private company deceived the auditors and fraud occurs on all the creditors (David, 2010), the law protects the auditors from potential sue based on negligence (David, 2010). The argument behind this is that where a company was identifiable with an individual, the fraud of such a company would be attributable to the company.

In above, it was not possible for the creditors to depend on its initiated illegal fraud when putting forward a negligence claim against auditors (David, 2010). Cook and Another v Green and Others Chancery Division District Registry (2008) is another case, which considered the standard of care owed by auditors. Auditors prepared a report suggesting that the decision by directors concerning company's ability to pay up debts within the following 12 months, or within 12 months, was unreasonable. The company later went into liquidation, showing that it could not pay the loan in time.

Owing to this, the company claimed auditor's negligence, stating that they had failed to provide a competent report. In response, the…

Sources used in this document:
References

David, H. (2010). Stone & Rolls Ltd. v Moore Stephens: An Unnecessary Tangle. Modern Law Review, 73 (3), 487 -- 493.

Goldwasser, L.D. (1988). Policy considerations in accountant's liability to third parties for negligence. Journal of accounting, auditing and finance,3(3), 217-231.

Kozlowski, C.J. (1996). Overview of negligence liability principles in recreation. Gmu.edu.

Retrieved 30 December 2013 from http://cehdclass.gmu.edu/jkozlows/p%26r696.htm
Retrieved 30 December 2013 from http://cehdclass.gmu.edu/jkozlows/p%26r696.htm
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Auditor Standards Reforms
Words: 3206 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

Independence of Auditors The objective of this study is to consider the statement as follows: "Unquestionably, the HIH story is also one of auditor failure" and to research into the background of the HIH collapse in Australia insofar as it relates to the role of auditors and their liability. A report will be prepared with summaries of the most important documents concerning this issue of auditor independence after the HIH collapse,

Torts Negligence Miscellaneous
Words: 870 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Wendy Wanderer Most states have an 'attractive nuisance' clause, which stipulates that homeowners must ensure that their property does not contain 'attractive nuisances' that can encourage children to engage in dangerous behaviors. But an attractive nuisance is usually thought to be a swimming pool that is not fenced in vs. general rubbish. Prior to 2001 Ohio, Vermont, and Maryland were the only states without some version of the "attractive nuisance" doctrine"

Johnson Bank V. George Korbaken Company Johnson
Words: 2964 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Johnson Bank v. George Korbaken Company Johnson Bank v. George Korbakes Company Over the last several years, the role of the auditor has been continually evolving. This is because financial institutions are relying on the information they are provided with to help them make better choices in the long-term. However, there are times when these firms may not have accurate figures and erroneously report their findings. When this happens, there is a

Kpmg Served As the Independent Audit Firm
Words: 3494 Length: 11 Document Type: Essay

KPMG served as the independent audit firm of several of the largest subprime mortgage lenders. Identify the advantages and disadvantages of a heavy concentration of audit clients in one industry or sub-industry (40marks). KPMG did indeed serve as the independent audit firm of many of the most massive subprime mortgage lenders in the nation. There are concrete benefits and drawbacks to such strong relationships in on particular field. The most fundamental

Responsibility of Accountants
Words: 1744 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Accountants Responsibility Introduction to Accountant Responsibility Essentially, accountants have a responsibility a number of parties, with the major parties in this case being the government, clients and third parties. In today's capitalist society, the accounting profession is deemed to be a common and important feature. Discussing the responsibilities accountants have to the three parties identified above would, therefore, certainly be a prudent and logical move. Responsibility to Clients To begin with, accountants have a

Ligand Pharmaceuticals
Words: 1561 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

accounting standards and concepts violated by Ligand Pharmaceuticals, as well as the role of the PCAOB as a regulatory body. Standards for Accounting of Sales Returns The applicable standard includes FAS 48, which establishes standards for revenue recognition when the right of return exists. FAS 48, issued in 1981, specifies under what circumstances revenue is recognized on a sale in which a product may be returned. For a business that sells

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now