Verified Document

Natural Law For Centuries The Dominant Philosophical Essay

Natural Law For centuries the dominant philosophical thought on the issue of natural law was dominated by the Catholic Church's theocracy (Gula, 1989). Natural law is the idea that law exists that is set by nature and that therefore it is universally validity (Cochrane, 1857). The first great philosopher to establish the early views on natural law was St. Augustine. St. Augustine's views on natural law were to develop over time into what is now called classic naturalism and were based on the concept that law cannot be fully articulated without some reference to moral notions (Augustine, 2005).

Augustine believed and argued that the laws of nature were dictated by God and therefore were superior to any other form of law. Such laws, as prescribed by God, were universal and timeless and that any man-made laws were valid if, and only if, they were in accordance with the laws of God. For St. Augustine, all laws, either man-made or God given, received all authority and legitimacy from God (Augustine, The City of God, 1994).

Simply stated, St. Augustine's natural law theory can be broken down into two essential elements: 1) there can be no legally binding standards that conflicts with the natural law; and 2) all valid laws derive their force and authority from the natural law. For Augustine, an unjust law was no law at all; however, he also believed that the coercive authority of the state arose as a result of man's tendency to sin. St. Augustine was the first Catholic philosophy to conceptualize the...

Obedience, therefore, was a Christian duty
Contrasting with St. Augustine's viewpoint is the neo-naturalism of modern day philosopher John Finnis. Finnis does not believe that St. Augustine's views provided an adequate justification for the existence of natural law. Finnis believed that St. Augustine and the classical natural law theorists were not concerned with providing a conceptual account of legal validity but were more concerned with explaining the moral force of law (Bix, 1995).

Finnis believes that the essential function of law is to provide a legal justification for the actions of the state. The state must have a method of enforcing its authority and the law provides this vehicle. Unlike St. Augustine who believed that an unjust law was no law, Finnis believes that an unjust law can still be legally valid without providing an adequate justification for the use of state coercive power. Without such justification the law would not necessarily be obligatory. For Finnis, an unjust law is legally binding but is not fully law (Finnis, 1980).

St. Augustine's philosophy of natural law was based heavily on his religious beliefs. Augustine rejected human reasoning as a source of intellectual understanding. Instead, he believed that all illumination and wisdom was divinely inspired. Augustine failed to make any distinction between theology and philosophy and the…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Augustine. (1994). The City of God. New York: The Modern Library.

Augustine. (2005). The Confessions of St. Augustine. Ada, MI: Revell.

Bix, B. (1995). Conceptual Questions and Jurisprudence. Legal Theory, 465-479.

Cochrane, C.N. (1857). Christianity and Classical Culture: A Study of Thought and Action from Augustus to Augustine. New York: Oxford University Press.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Law and Business When Glenn
Words: 5286 Length: 20 Document Type: Assessment

During this Diaspora, the African Slave Trade transferred 9-12 million people from one continent to another with major repercussions on cultural and political traditions in the New World. There have been a number of modern Diasporas based on the post-Cold War world in which huge populations of refugees migrated from conflict, especially from developing countries (Southeast Asia, China, Afghanistan, Iran, Latin America, South American, Rwanda, etc.). Part 1.2.1 - Civil

Motherwell Visual and Philosophical Connections
Words: 3066 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

This in another deceptively simple painting, which evokes the relationship between geese and nature in a few brush strokes. The background of is blank and bare, referring to the concept of nothingness, and the two geese are sketched in relation to a few lines which represent reeds. The work suggests a sense of great depth and space as well as the mystery of nature. Robert Motherwell Figure 1. Elegy to the Spanish

Vindication of the Rights of
Words: 12319 Length: 40 Document Type: Research Proposal

Ross (1988) notes the development of Romanticism in the late eighteenth century and indicates that it was essentially a masculine phenomenon: Romantic poetizing is not just what women cannot do because they are not expected to; it is also what some men do in order to reconfirm their capacity to influence the world in ways socio-historically determined as masculine. The categories of gender, both in their lives and in their

Secular Humanism the Rise and
Words: 20795 Length: 75 Document Type: Research Proposal

This work provided an intensive discussion historical forces that were to lead to modern humanism but also succeeds in placing these aspects into the context of the larger social, historical and political milieu. . Online sources and databases proved to be a valid and often insightful recourse area for this topic. Of particular note is a concise and well-written article by Stephen Weldon entitled Secular Humanism in the United States.

Catholic Church in Spain and the United States
Words: 19318 Length: 70 Document Type: Thesis

Catholic church and public policy have remarked that the members of American clergy in general, without even excepting those who do not admit religious liberty, are all in favour of civil freedom; but they do not support any particular political system. They keep aloof from parties, and from public affairs. In the United States religion exercises but little influence upon laws, and upon the details of public opinion; but it

Price Beauty 'For Though Beauty Is Seen
Words: 6265 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

Price Beauty? 'For though beauty is seen and confessed by all, yet, from the many fruitless attempts to account for the cause of its being so, enquiries on this head have almost been given up" William Hogarth, The Analysis of Beauty, (1753) Not very encouraging words, but if the great artist William Hogarth felt himself up to the task, we can attempt at least to follow his lead. That beauty is enigmatic

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now