Verified Document

Narrative Family Therapy A Critique Research Proposal

He gives a brief history of the birth of family centered therapy in the 1950's and again compliment Minuchin and his team and credits them for being a major part of this new dawn in psychotherapy. He also agrees with Minuchin that many of the newer "technologies and ad hoc practices," (1998, p. 416) have de-centered the family from center stage in many ways. However he disagrees that post modernism and social constructiveism are to blame. In fact Sluzki believes that many of the techniques of these genres, "include the family as a central contributor in the never ending process of reality construction." (1998, p. 417) He does agree with Minuchin that the shift towards more individual viewpoints may certainly be counterproductive to family therapy on many levels and feels likewise that political centered therapy is not constructive as a whole. In " A Question of Perspective," author Karl Tomm begins by citing two new trends in family therapy, bringing to light the introduction of cultural beliefs and practices and the introduction of individual life stories. Tomm states that Minuchin feels these two trends have diminished the value of the family unit as the "primary unit for assessment" (1998, p. 409) Tomm on the one hand agrees that these two trends have made an impact on family therapy that decentralizes the family as the primary locus for evaluative therapy. However, he does not necessarily view this as being so detrimental to the therapy as Minuchin does. In fact he believes that Minuchin has misinterpreted the viewpoints of both social contructivism and postmodernism in a rather narrow and self-serving view. Here again the author promotes the value of "the self" in any therapeutic context, although he re-imagines this self as, "being constituted of an internalized...

411), thereby creating an more inclusive archetype for gamily therapy, which he feels, as does this writer, the Minuchin has overlooked.
Muchin retorted in "Retelling, Reimagining and Re-Searching: A Continuing Conversation." To these authors as well as the overall response from the therapist community, to his stance, which he felt was quite misunderstood. He feels that the authors are making universal and theoretical points rather than dealing with particulars and reality as he sees it. He notes, and not without some agreement from this writer, that Anderson, Combs and Freedmans' idea of a fluid self that can change and adapt to situations is not what he has seen in his practice. Rather he has come up against very rigid and inflexible issues that take months or years to understand. However, that he choice to continually ignore the self in many respects as well as the cultural diversity present in many families is certainly anathema to good family therapy practice.

References

Anderson, A. (1999.) "Reimagining Family therapy: Reflections on Mincuin's Invisible Family." Journal or Marital and Family Therapy. 24(1) pp. 1-8

Combs, G. & Freedman, J. (1998) "Telling and Retellings." Journal or Marital and Family Therapy. 24(4). Pp. 405-408

Minuchin, S. (1998) "Where is the Family in Narrative Family therapy." Journal or Marital and Family Therapy. 24(4), pp. 397 =403

Minchuin, S. (1999). "Retelling, Reimagining and Re-Searching: A Continuing Conversation." Journal or Marital and Family Therapy. 24(1) pp. 9-14

Sluzki, C.E. (1998) "In Search of the Lost Family: A Footnote to Minuchin's Essay." Journal or Marital and Family Therapy. 24(4),…

Sources used in this document:
References

Anderson, A. (1999.) "Reimagining Family therapy: Reflections on Mincuin's Invisible Family." Journal or Marital and Family Therapy. 24(1) pp. 1-8

Combs, G. & Freedman, J. (1998) "Telling and Retellings." Journal or Marital and Family Therapy. 24(4). Pp. 405-408

Minuchin, S. (1998) "Where is the Family in Narrative Family therapy." Journal or Marital and Family Therapy. 24(4), pp. 397 =403

Minchuin, S. (1999). "Retelling, Reimagining and Re-Searching: A Continuing Conversation." Journal or Marital and Family Therapy. 24(1) pp. 9-14
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Feminist Therapy and Postmodern Approaches
Words: 1662 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

A teen might be asked to tell their own story from the point-of-view of other people they know, looking at themselves from other viewpoints. These clients are freed to invent stories and play parts in that serve the purpose of providing a framework of meaning and direction for themselves. The stories are never singled out as "true" or "false," but a recognition that truth is complex and no one

Psychology Counseling
Words: 1479 Length: 4 Document Type: Thesis

However, they should also know what aspects of they reveal are confidential. An adolescent should know if he or she says that he 'hates his parents' that the therapist does not have a responsibility to 'tattle' to the client's parent, even if the parent is paying for the session 2b. Discuss 2 counseling situations where duty to warn would be necessary. What would be the ethical issues involved: If the

Effect of Forgiveness on Health
Words: 28998 Length: 105 Document Type: Thesis

Forgiveness on human health. In its simplest form, the purpose of the study is to evaluate human psychological stress that might constitute a risk factor for heart disease. Further, the study will also evaluate the impact of forgiveness on heart disease. However, such a simple dissertation clearly demands further definition. What, exactly, do we signify when we speak of heart disease? What is properly considered as forgiveness? What impact does

Jones Stanton L. And Richard
Words: 859 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

" (1) Fearing its potential competition with Biblical modalities of understanding, some Christian patients may initially fear, even consciously avoid the modern practice of psychotherapy, seeing it as a mere scientific reductionism of the uniqueness of the human animal. Or, conversely, some may uncritically embrace counseling it as a better way of understanding the mind than the biology of the natural sciences, especially approaches as person-centered theory and transactional analysis. However,

Abuse of Older Adults Abuse
Words: 2330 Length: 7 Document Type: Literature Review

Even with under reporting, approximately 5% of elder women are likely abused to the point where they seek medical attention at least annually. These women are often well-known in their communities, so when they come into the emergency room with some story of malady, they know everyone will want to about what happened. In some cases, the trend is becoming more supportive, though. As educational programs transend economic barriers;

Comparing and Contrasting the Key Personality Theories and Theorists...
Words: 6049 Length: 15 Document Type: Essay

Personality Theories in Psychology To the layperson, the term personality is a generic descriptor for an individual's traits. However, personality has a more specific meaning to psychologists. According to Dan McAdams, "Personality psychology is the scientific study of the whole person" (McAdams, 2006, p.12, para.1). While different psychologists and their theories have become well-known enough to be referenced in casual conversation, there is still some confusion among laypeople about personality

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now