Verified Document

Myths, Truths, And Lies In Term Paper

This foolishness becomes emblematic of the entire Vietnam experience -- situations are created to display violence and bravery that have tremendous significance to the soldiers, but serve no real purpose. Just as Rat mythologizes Kurt's willingness to face death, and uses the body of an animal to vent his fury as a kind of sacrifice, Kurt himself tried to live up to a foolish ideal of what it meant to be a solider. The lies, or the myths and symbols these individuals created about themselves almost have a stronger force than the truth. Rat believes really angry with Kurt's sister, not the war. Tim suggests that Rat is angry with Kurt's sister because she refused to believe Rat's version of her brother's character, not about how he died. At the end of the novel, Rat attempts to recapitulate Kurt's violence against himself with his tooth by blowing off his own foot with a gun, as if he wants a share of his friend's glory.

However, even this telling and the retellings of the stories about Rat and Kurt's self-maiming and furies are lies. Tim admits to the reader that like his fictional creation Rat, he is unable to tell civilians like his daughter the full truth of what transpired in Vietnam. Rat's anger against Kurt's civilian sister is really emblematic of Tim's own frustration and being unable to tell the story of the war, even though he is a writer. Tim is a fiction writer, and a writer tells tales. But although he actually fought in Vietnam, he still writes fiction, and cannot write purely as a soldier, but must be a storyteller, even of his own personal experience....

Tim admits he attributes stories to himself, like throwing a grenade at a Vietnamese man, that others committed, and stories that are true about his own experience he formulates into the lives of others. He does this because "I want you to feel what I felt. I want you to know why story-truth is truer sometimes than happening-truth." (179) In other words, sometimes a myth can convey truth more vividly than a biography or a real history.
Tim thus has a contradictory view of the value of myths about war. On one hand, The Things They Carried is a novel about Vietnam of power. It conveys an emotional, although not a literal truth about the Vietnam experience for the reader. But on the other hand, the reader leaves the book feeling somewhat unsatisfied, as it seems the author is implying that the rationale for the Vietnam War was based on the lies of American goodness, truth, freedom, and manhood. Characters are shown engaging in foolish acts of self-myth-telling like Kurt and Rat, that show the ridiculousness of being a brave man in the midst of an immoral jungle of people who do not understand why the Americans are there or what the Americans are fighting for and against. Ultimately, the novel, a work of fiction, makes the reader uncomfortable about reading about the Vietnam experience in fiction, even though it feels as though it is conveying a powerful truth about the experience of soldiers who cannot communicate their experiences, other than through violence and lies.

Works Cited

O'Brien Tim. The Things They Carried. New York: Broadway Books, 1999.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

O'Brien Tim. The Things They Carried. New York: Broadway Books, 1999.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Myths and Narratives My Great-Grandfather Was a
Words: 1130 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Myths and Narratives My great-grandfather was a school teacher in West Virginia. He taught in rural schools that were one-room school houses in what he called the "boondocks." He rode his horse between schools and parents of his students would put him up for the night. His storytelling, according to my father and grandfather, was so powerful that kids believed his myths even though he told them it was just a

Lies My Teacher Told Me
Words: 1178 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Lies My Teacher Told Me stresses how students can repeat the same social studies class three times and still be ignorant of American history. Today, U.S. young adults leave most history courses with the false belief that the subject is only a bunch of facts and dates, completely boring, irrelevant to their lives and out of touch with the real world. Especially if a student is Latino, African-American, Asian or

Myths - "The Other Side of Wonder"
Words: 1529 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Myths - "The Other Side of Wonder" Like the empty sky it has no boundaries, yet it is right in this place, ever profound and clear.2 So run the lines from Cheng Tao, describing signifying, identifying myths - always there explaining existence and every facet of life, explaining the reason behind every man's actions: So, myths. For what is a myth? Lillian Hornstein3 describes it best. "A myth is the traditional tale common to

Hero Myths
Words: 2674 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Epic of Gilgamesh In a time when natural disasters were the whims of the Gods, when hunger, disease, and death stalked ones life as surely as the wild beasts of the land, the epic poem of Gilgamesh found its way across the ancient landscape. It was unearthed as part of a library collected thousands of years before our time, yet "reflects an ancient range of human experience and emotion not

Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel. According
Words: 2905 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Therefore the commerce under analysis is not a mere relation of exchange, but is a relation in which two forces become actively involved. Since it is man who initiates the process then it results that man is free to act as he wishes and not determined in his actions. The fact that this process is initiated in times of hardship demonstrate the fact that will and freedom are not enough

Myth and Meaning
Words: 5953 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

Constructed Myths and Man's Purpose Since Nietzsche declared that God was dead, science and mankind have begun a twofold search. Nietzsche's declaration asserted that the need for God in the society's constructed identity no longer existed. The understanding of the times was that the scientific method could break down any problem into is components, and uncover both the purpose and the source of all of mankind's desires, tangible and intangible alike.

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now