Verified Document

Myth Of The First Three Years Major Essay

¶ … Myth of the First Three Years Major Points of the Arguments made by Broude and Zero to Three

Broude presents arguments against the myth of the first three years by exposing some of the fallacies propagated by popular neuroscience. The first argument that she makes is that the stage of brain development is not the same as the stage of child development. She argues that the fact that the brain is developing connections rapidly should not be taken to imply that the connections are being formed as a result of rapid learning. She argues instead that the forming of connections among neurons is simply the stage-setting for learning to take place in later years of the lifespan. Her second major argument is that a number of traits are experience-expectant and not age dependent. The fact that most of these experiences are available to children during the first three years of their life is simply a coincidence and should not be interpreted as the cause of acquisition of those traits such as speech or hearing. Furthermore, a number of skills such as scholastic abilities can be developed at any stage in life, which negates the first three years myth. Similarly, certain experiences that are part of the cultural environment are also taken for granted and any learning derived from the cultural experiences is mistaken to be the result of biological developments. Broude's third argument is that subjecting children to artificially-enriched stimulating environments is unlikely to have the desired effect of producing super-learners because children have a tendency to block out more stimulation than they can handle.

Zero to Three presents some important points in defense of the myth of the first three years. They explain that the importance of the first three years should not be evaluated only with respect to the intellectual or cognitive development...

Instead, they assert that the first three years are critical to shaping the social and emotional side of the child. They argue that in order to achieve successful intellectual development, social and emotional well-being is crucial, which can only be successfully achieved during the window of opportunity of the first three years. They explain that traits such as trust, self-confidence, self-control, motivation and curiosity can be positively shaped during the first three years alone, and any deficiency during this period may not likely be compensated for in later years. Dowling (2009, p. 12) also states that confidence and trust are nurtured during the early years. Therefore, the first three years is a very crucial period, not in terms of intellectual learning, but for creating the capacity and desire to engage in learning in the later years.
Analysis of Line of Reasoning

Broude adopts an inductive line of reasoning by using logical arguments and reasoning to arrive at her conclusions. She starts with the premise that learning involves the ability to increase cognition and the acquisition of scholastic skills such as music or algebra. She then goes on to state the fact that during the first three years, growth in the number of neurons and their interconnections takes place, whereas in the latter years, the connections are pruned and may be reduced. She then states that learning does not occur when the interconnections are being formed but instead when the connections are being pruned. She explains that this is a life-long process as seen even in the case of people who lose the capacity of sight or hearing often gain additional sensitivity in a different sensory area. According to research, there is little evidence for establishing the link between synaptic densities and learning capacity (OECD 2007, p. 110). This occurs due to the plasticity of the brain cells which ensures learning even beyond the first three years. Wilson (2006, p. 31) also states that the brains remains plastic even in adulthood.

In contrast to Broude, Zero to Three adopts a deductive line of reasoning to arrive at their conclusions. They quote specific instances where early year's intervention has helped greatly to enhance the effectiveness of formal learning experiences in later years. For instance,…

Sources used in this document:
References

Dowling, M. (2009). Young children's personal, social and emotional development. Sage Publications.

OECD. (2007). Understanding the brain: The birth of a learning science. OECD Publishing.

Wilson, C. (2006). No on is too old to learn. iUniverse.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Mythology Is Defined As the
Words: 1379 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

..." The hymn also follows the general creation myth of Genesis, a staple in the Judeo mythology. Like the Genesis story, in the Hymn of Aton, the myth states that God is the one who gave speech, races, land and people. In essence, according to the hymn, the sun is the giver of all life, which makes sense as it is the sun's light that gives the means to sustaining

Three Strikes Law and Its Impact on the African-American Community...
Words: 3745 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Three Strikes Law on the African-American Community Three Strikes legislation, which imposes sentencing enhancement on repeat offenders, often culminating with mandatory life sentences for third-time offenders, has gained popularity throughout the United States. The legislation began in California, where two highly publicized murders committed by convicted felons prompted an outcry against allowing recidivists to return to the community. California did see a decrease in crime rates following its institution of

Mythology Overall, I Do Not
Words: 335 Length: 1 Document Type: Assessment

With respect to the mythology of the male gods, Zeus, Apollo, and Hephaestus seem to be a combination that matches the dynamism of their female goddess counterparts. These gods represent the good and the bad of males; they also represent the spectrum of power and balance of male energy. There is no one god or goddess myth that I feel fully represents the tension between male and female gods because

Mythology Political Issues Constitutional History: Beginnings and
Words: 3597 Length: 13 Document Type: Term Paper

Mythology Political Issues Constitutional History: Beginnings and Changes This paper will explore the historical basis for the Constitution of the United States and the changes that have occurred both gradually and radically during short history of the U.S. Constitution. This paper will also review the structure of local, state and federal government and make note of the changes that have occurred in rules and laws since the signing of this most important

Greek Mythology Identification a Heroic Greek Myths in a Modern Movie...
Words: 1318 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Greek and Roman Greek Mythology: Identification of Heroic Greek Myths in Modern Movies There are many effective and functional parallels in modern movies to ancient myths. They make us feel and think about many things. Modern movies that have been successful at the box office are inspired by Greek myths. We see common themes, characters and motifs of myth in the modern movies. The goal here is to identify the mythic elements

Business Major a Major in Business Management
Words: 1541 Length: 5 Document Type: Interview

Business Major A major in Business Management seems secure, and yet, it could be easily rendered an obsolete concentration. If Business Management were rendered obsolete, it would have adverse implications on the economy, on issues related to social justice, and on the ability for organizations to thrive. Especially during an economic recession, the need to develop future business leaders becomes apparent. Interviews with successful managers who were once students in an

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now