Verified Document

Ms Jane V. Mr. Stubbornman. Essay

By refusing Ms Jane to breastfeed her infant, Mr. Stubbornman violated not only the Florida jurisdiction, but also the right of the infant to be nourished when he was in need. The security guard and the store, however, can justify their position in detaining Ms Jane initially, in order to determine whether there was any case of shoplifting. The defendants should refer to the Florida Statute of 811.022, which provides that "[a] peace officer, or a merchant, or a merchant's employee who has probably cause for believing that goods held for sale by the merchant have been unlawfully taken by a person and that he can recover them by taking the person into custody, may, for the purpose of attempting to effect such recovery, take the person into custody and detain him in a reasonable manner for reasonable length of time" (Jefferson Stores, Inc. v. Caudell, 1969). But whether the security guards acted in a reasonable manner and detained the suspect for a reasonable length of time should be decided by jury. And while the defendants can justify their initial detainment of Ms Jane to determine whether she had shoplifted, they have no justification for refusing her to breastfeed her infant son.

As a result of this experience, Ms Jane went through a psychological trauma and undergone a psychological and psychiatric treatment. It needs to be determined by the child's doctors if he has also experienced any trauma as a consequence of Mr. Stubbornman's actions....

In the meantime, Ms Jane should prevail in this case and Mr. Stubbornman and the Tel-Mart store must pay substantial compensation to cover Ms Jane's medical expenses and pay the family for moral damage inflicted upon them. If it is determined by doctors that the infant son also needs special treatment because of Mr. Stubbornman's refusal to allow Ms Jane to breastfeed him in a timely manner, Mr. Youknow should also demand that additional compensation be paid to pay for the infant's expenses. The Court of Florida should also reprimand the Tel-Mart store for inducing its security officials to detain customers unnecessarily.
References

Bryant v. Kansas City Rus. Co. 286 Mo. 342, 228 S.W. 472. Mo. 1921. February 19, 1921. Retrieved on February 27, 2011, from WestLaw.

Hughes v. McDonald. 133 Cal.App.2d 74, 283 P.2d 360 Cal.App. 1 Dist. 1955. May 18, 1955. Retrieved on February 27, 2011, from WestLaw.

Jefferson Stores, Inc. v. Caudell. 228 So.2d 99. Fla.App. 1969. November 18, 1969. Retrieved on February 27, 2011, from WestLaw.

Oosterhoudt v. Montgomery Ward & Co., Inc. 316 So.2d 582. Fla.App. 1975. July 1975. Retrieved on February 27, 2011, from WestLaw.

Schaeper v. J.M. Fields, Inc. 362 So.2d 350. Fla.App., 1978. August 11, 1978. Retrieved on February 27, 2011, from WestLaw.

Sughrue v. Bay State St. Ry. Co. 230 Mass. 363, 119 N.E. 660. Mass. 1918. May 25, 1918. Retrieved…

Sources used in this document:
References

Bryant v. Kansas City Rus. Co. 286 Mo. 342, 228 S.W. 472. Mo. 1921. February 19, 1921. Retrieved on February 27, 2011, from WestLaw.

Hughes v. McDonald. 133 Cal.App.2d 74, 283 P.2d 360 Cal.App. 1 Dist. 1955. May 18, 1955. Retrieved on February 27, 2011, from WestLaw.

Jefferson Stores, Inc. v. Caudell. 228 So.2d 99. Fla.App. 1969. November 18, 1969. Retrieved on February 27, 2011, from WestLaw.

Oosterhoudt v. Montgomery Ward & Co., Inc. 316 So.2d 582. Fla.App. 1975. July 1975. Retrieved on February 27, 2011, from WestLaw.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Shoplifting & Social Process Theory the Social
Words: 553 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Shoplifting & Social Process Theory The Social Process Theory argues that people commit crime based on social influences (McQuade, 2009). Social influences can be strong where shoplifting is concerned with peer pressure in delinquency or with family influences when family members are corrupt. Although the theory does not fully explain all acts of shoplifting, it does explain acts of shoplifting where delinquency and corrupt family members are concerned. Peer pressure causes stress

Preventing Shoplifting
Words: 543 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Shoplifting Detection and Deterrence Methods Perhaps the most common shoplifting deterrence technique is obvious surveillance. This may include either having cameras in the store screened by security personnel or covert observation of suspect shoppers. Simply the knowledge that shoppers are being watched can act as a deterrent. Store employees should be thoroughly briefed on how to prevent potential thefts. Store personnel should be briefed to keep track of suspicious items. Store

Restorative Justice Responding to Shoplifting
Words: 1605 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Restorative justice asks fundamentally different questions, and is based on a different set of assumptions, than the current criminal justice paradigm (Restorative Justice for Oakland Youth, n.d.). The most notable and important difference between the current criminal justice paradigm and the restorative justice paradigm is that restorative justice does not focus on the punishment and does not advocate a punitive criminal justice system. Instead, the restorative justice model is based

Analysis of Shop Lifting and Retail Security
Words: 1480 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Shoplifting is currently one among the most prevalent of non-violent offenses in the U.S.A. Shoplifting refers to stealing property put forward for sale. It is a costly issue - U.S. businesses and consumers lose billions every year to shoplifting. The former have to bear the burden of security-related costs and that of lost merchandise, while the latter have to pay a larger amount as retail prices as sellers pass on

Motion to Revoke Probation Comes
Words: 879 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Paper

When requested to leave the premises the defendant refused to do so and proceeded to assault the security officer by throwing a beverage at said officer and then, subsequently, slapping the same officer. The defendant was detained by the store security and arrested by the local police. Victim's Statement George Petrie, the chief security officer for Publix, states that his employer would like to see the defendant punished for his actions

Integrative Case the Case Involve M, a
Words: 1424 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Integrative Case The case involve M, a 35-year-old mother with three children from two fathers. He most recent boyfriend, the father of the youngest child, has beaten her twice, been arrested and jailed, but is about to be released. Despite a restraining order, Melissa is terrified. Her economic situation is dire -- she lives at an inexpensive motel, works part-time for under the table wages, and relies on WIC services. Most

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now