Verified Document

Morality Of Hobbes And Calvin In Lord Of The Flies Essay

What is the Purpose of Morality?

Hobbes viewed morality as a form of social control, instituted by society to prevent every man from being against every man (p. 36). In other words, morality was a human construct. What Lord of the Flies shows is that nature represents two forcestwo dynamicstwo spirits: one seeks to be upright and to serve the common good; the other is self-centered and self-indulgent, obeying only the force and violence of impulse. These two forces have to work together if society wants to keep itself from tearing itself apart, so Pojmans argument goes. Indeed, in Goldings Lord of the Flies there is some struggle between the boys on the island, as the group splinters and a power play for authority commences. One boyRalphtries to adhere to the old world morality embodied by civil society as it was known back homehe tries to instill order and good governance with the conch and the need to keep the fire going. Jack on the other hand represents a different kind of spirit or force or lawone that is more interested in serving the self, the whimsical desire for instant satisfactionwhether it is pulling a prank on Piggy or abandoning the fire to satisfy a sudden desire to hunt for meat. Jack represents an animalistic sort of nature, a fallen nature, a depraved nature that respects nothing but force. Jack is constantly challenging Ralph and is quick to use violence when he feels threatened, charging Jack at one point with a spear, and later trying to hunt him down with his own followers. In the novel, Ralph represents common sense but also the...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

…source in Beelzebub (Satan) but rather only us, i.e., humans have a dark naturejust like Calvin said (p. 33). And this is where Pojman connects the novel to Hobbes: Hobbes contended that human beings act out of self-interest, and the true state of nature is insecurity (p. 35). This insecurity is demonstrated by the boys on the island and morality is [merely] a form of social control (p. 36). Obviously, this reading supports the idea that Lord of the Flies is antithetical to The Coral Island and its view of morality and human nature. However, where there is no power able to over-awe them all, states Hobbes, men will find only grief (p. 42). The author of The Coral Island simply suggests there is a good power over all, while Golding suggests it is more likely a bad…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Moral Realism Vs. Moral Relativism Philosophers Have
Words: 1021 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Moral Realism vs. Moral Relativism Philosophers have argued the merits or existence of moral realism and moral relativism for some time. Generally, the argument is designed as an either or proposition, where only one argument can be true. This is not necessarily true when one takes the time to explore what is meant by moral realism vs. moral relativism (Streitfeld). Essentially, moral realism is an objective view while moral realism is

Morality in America Morals Are Defined As
Words: 1068 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Paper

Morality in America Morals are defined as a set of principles of right action and behavior for the individual. The traditional morals of any given society are the set of moral principles by which the majority of its members have lived over a long time, a consensus which that society has reached on what is considered correct and decent behavior. It is the way one's society expectsone to behave, even if

Moral Sentiment Philosophy Morality to Human Sentiment
Words: 784 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Moral Sentiment Philosophy Morality to human sentiment is a unique kind of feeling. It comes about through a kind of perspective-taking that we encounter, via a practice of sympathetic imagination, sentiments belonging to individuals that have been affected by a given action or other evaluation objects. There are two main claims in which Hume's account of moral sentiments rest upon. Firstly, it holds that the source of our normative standards should be found

Moral Dilemmas
Words: 700 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

I would have been thinking about social norms and categorical imperatives in Kohlberg's system -- or about the social value of self-sacrifice in Gilligan's. Instead I made a moral choice that reflects moral maturity: a level of caring that Gilligan would define as postconventional. Whether consciously or not, I was determined to preserve the dignity and promote the well-being of both my friends. I took myself out of the picture.

Moral Philosophy
Words: 2861 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

Moral Philosophy Can desires and feelings be in accordance with or contrary to reason? Are they under the control of, or guided by, reason? Compare, contrast, and critically evaluate the answers of Aristotle and Hume to these questions and their arguments in support of those answers. David Hume is one of the most significant philosophers of the 18th Century. Hume is skeptical about moral truths, and he ascertains that ethics comes from

Moral Relativism Is a Point-Of-View,
Words: 1459 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Then morality is relative, not absolute (Kreeft) Weaknesses One weakness of moral relativism consists of the consequences of not having moral constraints (Kreeft 2003). Correct or good morality, if valid, should always have good consequences. Incorrect or bad morality should always have bad consequences. The fact is that all wrong or immoral acts and attitudes bring on "good" or pleasant feelings. Moral relativism has never produced people worthy of praise. It

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now