Verified Document

Moral Realism Vs. Moral Relativism Philosophers Have Essay

Moral Realism vs. Moral Relativism Philosophers have argued the merits or existence of moral realism and moral relativism for some time. Generally, the argument is designed as an either or proposition, where only one argument can be true. This is not necessarily true when one takes the time to explore what is meant by moral realism vs. moral relativism (Streitfeld). Essentially, moral realism is an objective view while moral realism is a subjective view (Streitfeld)

Moral realism holds that a thing is either right or it is wrong (Kim). Further, a moral realist would aver that there are never extenuating circumstances that would change whether or not a something is right or wrong (Kim). In other words, there are moral facts which govern us all, and regardless of what the social or cultural setting is, that fact can never waiver (Kim). It cannot waiver because it is a fact, not a subjective viewpoint (Kim). This is interesting to contemplate. For example, the moral realist would contend that if an individual encountered a situation where someone (say the individual's child) was being held captive and being tortured by a serial killer, and that individual had the means and opportunity to save the child by killing the serial killer, that action (killing the serial killer) would be morally wrong. Killing is killing and it is never morally right (Kim)

A moral realist would argue that killing being morally wrong is a moral fact that holds true for all individuals (Kim). On the other hand, it can also be a fact...

According to Kim, this distinguishes moral realism as a study of "What is." Kim states that the first example "not only describes an enduring condition of the world but also proscribes what ought to be the case (or what ought not to be the case) in terms of an individual's behavior."
The difficulty with the moral realists' position is that it claims that morality is objective Kim). If morality is objective, then why is it necessary to make subjective judgments regarding morality? How is one to define something as right or wrong without making a value statement (Kim)? If lying is always wrong, who determined this and on what basis (Kim)? "If moral objectivity is to be found within us, then it is not the same objectivity with which we began," (Kim). The notion here is that in order to be objective, a fact must exist outside of humans and not need a human to interpret it as a fact (Kim).

Moral relativists view morality quite differently. From the perspective of the moral relativist, killing the serial killer who is torturing and holding one's child captive would not be considered morally wrong. In fact, moral relativism would undoubtedly contend that this action is the morally right action. Thus, morality is not rigid and may change from wrong to right under varying circumstances, and it is therefore subjective (Kim).

Moreover, the moral relativist would argue that a moral judgment is only "true or false relative to some particular standpoint (for…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Kim, Shin. "Moral Realism." Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. N.p. 24 May 2006. Web.

02 Dec. 2012.

Streitfeld, Jason. "Sam Harris and the Moral Realism/Moral Relativism Myth." Specter of Reason. N.p. 19 May 2010. Web. 02 Dec. 2012.

Westacott, Emrys. "Moral Relativism." Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. N.p. 30 May
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Locke or Berkeley
Words: 1213 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Locke v. Berkeley The philosophers John Locke and George Berkeley offer stark contrasts on the issue of various matters. Locke's whose viewpoint can best be classified as based in relativism. He believed that all knowledge come from the senses. As every man's senses are unique, no two individuals will sense the same experience the same and, therefore, all knowledge is different in each individual. By extension, there is no such thing

Housing Support on Teenager Parents Housing Support
Words: 2160 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Housing Support on Teenager Parents Housing Support on Teenagers The Impacts of Housing Support on Teenagers Parent in United Kingdom UK leads Europe in teenage pregnancies in Western Europe with 35,966 conceptions in the under 18s in 2009. Majority of these unplanned pregnancies are the cause and consequence of social exclusion in UK. (UNICEF, 2001) There are 90K teenagers under 20 years and 8k under 16-year's pregnancies in England each year; it is

Truth One Cannot Simply Define
Words: 3618 Length: 9 Document Type: Essay

Two belief systems, then -- true believe, and justified true belief (Hauser, 1992). Humans, however, according to Pierce, turn justified true beliefs into true beliefs by converting them into axioms. Once we have proven something there is no need to prove it again, and we use the part that was proven before to further extend our study and the inquisition of knowledge. And so it becomes necessary to accept things

Idealism Is a Philosophy As
Words: 2702 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

As a teacher of the very young therefore, idealism in the sense of the attainment of higher values and aims has a special and positive significance in my profession and personal life. Dealing with very young minds places a particularly heavy burden on the teacher. The teacher has a responsibility to shape these minds. It is a truism but also a reality that the early years of education are often

Political Science Politics Can Very Well Be
Words: 2597 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Political Science Politics can very well be defined as the study of who gets what, when and how? The principal reason for such a definition is that politics conflicts between the demands for certain satisfaction and this conflict contributes to the major characteristic of every society. No society can meet all the people's wants, needs and desires. Resources cannot be distributed in accordance with the relatives bargaining power of its members.

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now