Verified Document

Moral And Emotional Responses To The Challenge Term Paper

Moral and Emotional Responses to the Challenge of Thrasymachus Might makes right. So suggests the character of Thrasymachus in Plato's "Republic." In other words, justice and morality is merely defined by who is stronger. The proper role of morality in both reason and the emotions is dependant simply upon what one wants to do, at that point in time, and how one can best achieve one's objective. In politics, the strongest person defines what is just and moral, because the strongest person will always rule according to the real world laws of the political jungle. Socrates, of course, offers the opposing view, that only the wisest should rule, the philosopher kings of the ideal state, who put subjective emotion aside and rule purely by objective reason. While Thrasymachus suggests that 'the world,' that is the material existence around us (including our emotions) should be the ultimate proving-ground of any moral system, Socrates suggests the contrary, namely that morality has an objective reality and existence beyond what we see around us.

A corollary to what Thrasymachus suggests might be that 'if it feels good, do it.' Namely, that if one's emotions give validation to one's power, dominance, and morality, than it must be good. Socrates, however, suggests that the material world is a poor moral determinant of right and wrong behavior, as the earthly world is itself merely an imperfect reflection of the truer life of the forms, rather than of 'real' objective goodness, morality, or justice, itself. Because of the...

Just as the body is less perfect than the soul, so the emotions are less perfect tools to use in making moral judgments. To be moral is to not serve one's emotional and personal self-interests, but to serve the objective principles of morality. Even, in the ideal Platonic kingdom, the philosopher kings who were fit to rule would be able to put aside their own interests and merely reign in the interests of the state. They would rule because of their innate rational superiority, superior to the lower orders, as the head was to the hands and lower bodily regions, superior as the earth is to the higher cosmic world of the perfect forms.
In contrast to Plato, however, Kant places slightly more trust in the instincts and emotions than does the Greek philosopher. Kant states that morality is a kind of dialogue between what the moral actors senses are emotionally correct, and what he or she knows to be correct. But like Socrates, Kant insists that there be no contingency upon the good of actions, that one cannot use worldly standards of what 'works' in the material world to validate moral goods. In other words, unlike Thrasymachus, who might say that because someone has been able to strong-arm his way to leadership, he has earned the moral right to kingship, Plato would respond that the leader has simply proven he is the physically fittest amongst men, or the most able to gain brutal supporters to enforce his reign of tyranny. The tyrant has…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Emotional Development
Words: 2627 Length: 9 Document Type: Essay

Emotional development is a critical aspect of human growth, encompassing the processes by which individuals learn to recognize, express, regulate, and understand their own emotions as well as those of others. From early childhood through adolescence and into adulthood, emotional development is a dynamic, complex journey integral to personal well-being and interpersonal success (Saarni, 1999). The roots of emotional development can be traced back to infancy, where basic emotional expressions such

Moral Education and Its Impact
Words: 4187 Length: 15 Document Type: Research Proposal

In this regard, Koehler and Seger (2005) emphasize that because resources are by definition scarce, peer bullying represents a threat to the entire learning process across the board because teachers and administrators must spend inordinate amounts of time in an attempt to control problematic behavior rather than invest it in delivering high quality educational services. In fact, some of the most common responses to peer bullying in recent years

Emotional Drivers Towards Swarovski's Brand
Words: 12508 Length: 38 Document Type: Literature Review

The luxury brands in this age of fierce and intense competition perceive and believe that the conventional methods of advertising and promotion are only an itinerary that creates the knowledge and awareness amongst the consumers. Nevertheless, targeted marketing (that represents the emotional driving force) is becoming the primary and fundamental aspect of concern that many of the brands are focusing in order to create emotional engagement with the consumers that

Ethics and Moral Guidelines Criminal Justice
Words: 1933 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

.....personal ethics derive from a combination of established codifications of moral conduct, such as those embedded in political documents or in religious scripture, but also from my personality, my upbringing, and my worldview. I tend towards a utilitarian point-of-view, in that I do believe that the consequences of actions are more important than worrying about whether an action is inherently right or wrong. I also believe that there are situational

Harris Morality Without God, Science
Words: 772 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Caring about any of these things may or may not be right or wrong, but it strikes me that if appealing to an unstated vision of "science" to justify the decision is the future of ethics, then both ethics and scientific inquiry are in dire straits. Clearly, Harris wants "knowledge to count" -- that is, to have practical meaning for human lives -- but he confesses that in order to

The Moral Landscape of Pre
Words: 6045 Length: 20 Document Type: Thesis

On the threshold of the Civil Rights movement, Baldwin would publish Notes of a Native Son. Though 1953's Go Tell It On The Mountain would be perhaps Baldwin's best known work, it is this explicitly referential dialogic follow-up to Wright's Native Son that would invoke some of the most compelling insights which Baldwin would have to offer on the subject of American racism. This is, indeed, a most effectively lucid examination from the perspective of a deeply

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now