Nationalism and Anthony Smith's anti-primordialism in his view of modern Asiatic history and the construction of what is 'Asia'
Nationalism and what makes a nation a cohesive and functioning unit has been one of the essential questions of modern political philosophy, particularly in Asia today, where in India, China, Tibet, Japan, Vietnam, and Korea, a plurality of different regional and religious identities fight to dominate particular national territories. Anthony D. Smith is one of most important contemporary scholars of nationalism and is the author of many books on the subject including such classics as his 1986 The Ethnic Origins of Nations, a book of supreme relevance in particular for the region, given the frequent rhetorical role of ethnic identity in a people's claim to territory and nationhood.
According to Smith, the idea of essential ethnic origins of nations has caused some scholars to assume nationalism and nations as preexisting entities, simply waiting for recognition and validation from outside governing bodies, such as the United Nations, as well as the neighboring nation-states. But the thrust of modern history has suggested that nationality is fundamentally more complex, and even the idea of what is 'Asia' and 'Asiatic' is polymorphous and in flux, rather than something complete to be grasped by in its totality, with law, religion, or ideological constructions.
Ideologies who identify themselves as nationalists, perennialists, modernists and post-modernists have very different interpretations of the role of what constructs a nation, and how the past history of peoples can and should affect the present visions of national identity. But it is primarily in "the manner in which they have viewed the place of ethnic history has largely determined their understanding of nations and nationalism today." (Smith, 1994, 18) Starkly defined nationalists stress that the role of the past is clear and unproblematic. For example, Vietnam was always extant, and simply passed into hands of French and American extraction by virtue of unjust historical circumstances. However, in the nationalist view, the nation of Vietnam itself was always there, as if it was part of some natural or truer world order, "even when it was submerged in the hearts of its members" in the military din and conflicts of a colonial past history.
Thus, "the task of the nationalist is simply to remind his or her compatriots of their glorious past, so that they can recreate and relive those glories" that existed before colonialism. (Smith, 1994, 18) But although nationalism may have its roots in anti-colonialism and have a positive contribution to make to a sense of national cohesion, Smith contends such pure nationalism must become a larger part of a global ideology if, for example, post-colonial national structures such as Vietnam are to become part of the international web and economic and political fabric of nations.
For perennialist or primordial scholars as well, according to Smith, the notion of the nation-state is also immemorial, or unchanging, although national forms may change and particular nationally defined borders may dissolve, but the identity of a nation is unchanging. Those scholars who have seen an essential Chinese identity, in a huge conglomeration of regional identities thus pursue a quixotic quest in their endeavor to fix nationhood in such a perennial, or unchanging fashion. Rather, Smith contends that the nation exists only in human, collective minds, and the nation is not part of any natural order, for a citizen can ultimately choose his or her nation, unlike a racial or ethnic classification, and even later generations can build something new on their ancient ethnic foundations. A new nation, such as modern Japan, however homogeneous, is still more ethnically diverse than in has been in the past, despite a past history of isolationism, and notions of what is Japanese have shifted, even amongst those who share the same unbroken ethnic heritage as their ancestors.
Furthermore, religion also suggests a more complex notion of nationhood -- for religion as in the Indian and Pakistan conflict has come...
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now