Verified Document

Mob Mentality, The Wave, And Personal Responsibility Essay

Mob Mentality, The Wave, And Personal Responsibility Dennis Gansel's 2008 film The Wave is a dramatization of actual events that took place at Cubberley High School in Polo Alto, California, in the spring of 1967 (Johnston). The film explores the question of how the events surrounding the Holocaust, the mass extermination of 10 million Jews, Gypsies, homosexuals, and the mentally and physically infirm, was allowed to take place by the German people during the Second World War. The center of the inquiry is a high school history class where the teacher establishes a culture based on discipline, community and action. He calls the movement "the wave" and sets in motion a series of events highly reminiscent of Nazi Germany during the 1930s and early 1940s. While the film offers a reason for the Holocaust, an explanation of how this tragedy was allowed to happen, it is my belief this is not an excuse.

Mob mentality or herd mentality refers to the influence of an individual's peers to adopt certain behaviors they would not normally adapt because of prevailing conditions or beliefs. A 1995 article in the Harvard Law Review examines aspects of mob mentality defenses in light of the Reginald Denny verdict ("Feasiblity and Admissibility of Mob Mentality Defenses"). Denny was a truck driver who was pulled from his vehicle and savagely beaten by four black men during the 1992 Los Angeles riots. The incident...

The defendants' attorneys argued a case for unpremeditated assault. In the subsequent trial the jury was hung on all charges except a felony mayhem count against one defendant (Clark).
Discussion

The article in the Harvard Law Review notes that traditionally criminal law has treated crimes committed by groups as more blameworthy than those committed by persons acting alone. In fact, the criminal who acts in concert with others has in many jurisdictions committed two crimes, the crime itself plus conspiracy to commit said crime. However, in the Denny trial the argument for the defense was that their participation in group criminal behavior should render their actions less blame worthy. The argument is that persons who act as part of a group get caught up in the excitement of the mob and so do not make real meaningful choices about how to behave. They therefore should not be held fully accountable, or accountable at all for their criminal actions. This argument raises the possibility of undesirable social norms if group criminality is viewed as a defense instead of an offense. A successful mob mentality defense would further weaken the principle of personal responsibility ("Feasiblity and Admissibility of Mob Mentality Defenses").

The problem of this defense lies in the concept of free will. Let's look at it this…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Clark, Robin. "Defense Victory Ends Denny trial Juorors Acquitted on One Charge, Deadlocked on the Other. Officials Warned Against a "White Backlash." Philadelpia Inquirer, 21 October 1993. Web. 16 May 2013.

"Feasiblity and Admissibility of Mob Mentality Defenses." Harvard Law Review, Vol 108, Issue 5, March 1995: 1111-1126. EBSOC. Web. 16 May 2013.

Gansel, Dennis, dir. Die Welle. Constantin Films, 2008. Film.

Haskins, Ron. "The Sequence of Personal Responcibilty." The Brookings Institution, July 2009. Web. 16 May 2013.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Personal Responsibility
Words: 641 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

Personal responsibility is a hallmark of maturity. In college, we cease to blame other people such as our parents for our problems. We also have to learn how to manage our time wisely, and be disciplined. Our parents are no longer there to tell us when to study or what time to get up for soccer practice. The benefits of personal responsibility include the fact that we become more capable

Personal Responsibility Introduction-What Is Personal Responsibility ...
Words: 1253 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Personal Responsibility Introduction-What is Personal Responsibility? Personal responsibility, by definition, is all about how an individual takes up accountability for his/her actions and accepts the burdens and consequences that come along with them and agrees the fact that his/her actions leave an impact on everyone around him/her. Personal responsibility does not only help an individual learn to be perceptive of his/her responsibilities and but also focuses on his/her ability to deal with

Personal Responsibility Being a Student Is Very
Words: 1011 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Personal Responsibility Being a student is very difficult in the best of times but even more so today with all the external pressures associated with education including economics and sociological pressures. There are stresses all around students in college, everywhere they look. Students feel pressure to do well, to learn the material, to impress the teacher, to please their parents, to take care of themselves financially and sociologically. For many students,

Personal Responsibility Generally, Personal Responsibility
Words: 898 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

As a member of the college community, my plan for personal responsibility is to always comply with formal rules and codes of conduct and be sensitive to the rights and welfare of others and to act in ways that respect those rights even when it might be more convenient for me not to. Conclusion Personal responsibility means recognizing obligations and meeting all of the burdens of those obligations. Circumstances calling for

Personal Responsibility in College the
Words: 1260 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Another way of looking at it is that whenever there is not enough time to do everything one plans in college, the first casualty is academic responsibility. Typically, the first year of college is also the first experience that incoming students have ever been completely self-responsible (Lucier, 2008). Very often, with no parents or authority figures to answer to, college freshmen develop irresponsible habits. Magical thinking takes over and the

Personal Responsibility: A Reflection Anyone
Words: 700 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

The revelation that I needed to take more responsibility for my actions did not come all at once, but in fits and starts. I remember distinctly one day when I was tired from having begun my homework far too late the night before. I lay my head down on my desk and after a few moments was conscious of the teacher looking down at me. Much to my surprise, he

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now