Verified Document

Mixed Methods Research Study. Each Of The Annotated Bibliography

¶ … mixed methods research study. Each of the three studies must have been published in a peer-reviewed journal. Analysis of a Qualitative Research Report: Problem statement:

What is the problem the study was conducted to address?

Many schools have not adopted new electronic-era media literacies into their core curricula, but understanding these new, evolving literacies is critical to understanding how students learn today, especially with regard to low-income students, for several reasons (Turner, 2011, p. 614).

Why is the problem an important one for someone in your discipline to study?

The ability to use multi-media communication technologies will increase in importance the more those technologies are deployed in education. The more technology proliferates in education, the more students will need skills to critically analyze such texts for validity and applicability. If those students will be the workforce of the next generation, the workers we manage will need critical multi-media literacy skills in order to separate authoritative text from say advertising or politically biased messaging in the workforce and daily life.

Study purpose: 1.). what is the purpose of the study?

Turner responds to a 2003 prediction by Kress that understanding a "shift to screen-based image literacy" (Kress, 2003, quoted in Turner, 2011, p. 613) would entail a concurrent shift in pedagogical research.

Research question:

1.). What is the research question?

Turner breaks his inquiry into multi-media production "in the development of information and communications technology literacies" (Turner, 2011, p. 614) into three questions, namely what specific skills students developed, how acquiring multi-media skills increased students' abilities "to interpret and produce texts" (Turner, 2011, p. 614), and how students' understandings of information and cummications technology literacies change per different contexts.

2.). Is the question stated broadly enough for a qualitative study? Why or why not?

The questions are...

Each question is open-ended, asking 'what' or 'how' questions without limitation as to how many answers or ranking of those answers, for example. Had these been asked 'which of the skills' or 'what is the best skill,' those questions would be more amenable to quantitative research due to the comparison for dominance within their respective groups, for example.
Study design:

1.). What qualitative design is used?

Taylor employed pre- and post-test subject (student) and proctor (educator) interview, where the test condition was a multi-media production class; participant observation, researcher selection on basis of interest (gender, race and ethnicity); answers were open-coded for "repeating, emergent themes that helped answer my three research questions" (Turner, 2011, p. 616); pre- and post-test Likert-type scale response analysis for specific skill attainment and technology mode. The last would approach quantitative analysis except that the responses were based on self-report rather than specific objectives determined within constrained test conditions, i.e. unobservable test conditions may have confounded students' responses before and after treatment.

2.). In what way is the chosen design an appropriate one for this study?

This design is appropriate because of the expense involved in treating a large number of such test participants, the subjectivity of response, and the subjectivity of terms of definition, i.e. Turner's (2011) "emergent themes" (616), which would be possible but difficult to restrict semantically for a large, heterogenous sample. Having students perform skills presentation of which constituted test conditions, was appropriate to identify whether they had indeed obtained the conditions the test sought to impose or not. This study could be performed quantitatively given extensive prior definition of the categories, say through standardized testing, and a larger budget.

Subjects and setting:

1.). How were the study subjects obtained?

The 30 students who began the program…

Sources used in this document:
The data collection procedures were approprate to the design to a high degree, some more than others. How high? Very high for the first and moderately or less-than-very high for the second and third. Why? Data collection was 'very appropriate,' i.e. 'more than moderately appropriate' (where appropriate is undefined / subjective) for the first question because question 1 asked 'what skills' did the actual students develop, (Taylor, 2011, p. 614) which is different than asking 'how does' students' literacy change, which implies that these subjects are representative of the group 'all such students,' which they clearly are not a large enough sample size to represent, probably. Therefore data collection was enough to answer the first but not the second or third questions conclusively. These criteria are subjective and undefined as per unstated increments of "degree."

3.). What steps were taken to protect the rights of subjects? Were they adequate? Why or why not?

Subjects and in fact all participants' names were changed for the final report. Since students were learning skills that would presumably enhance their ability to analyze media texts, it seems
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Mixed Methods Research the Nature
Words: 619 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Variables that could increase the likelihood of insider threat can be certain personality traits or satisfaction levels revealed by employee questionnaires. If an employee, for example, believes that he or she is not receiving the full benefits merited by his or her service level or skill set within the company, it can be determined as more likely for this type of employee to act less ethically than those with

Mixed Methods Research and Pros and Cons
Words: 959 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Although more time consuming and costly, mixed-methods research can also be more fruitful than either qualitative or quantitative methods alone. Mixed methods combine qualitative and quantitative in ways that are suitable for answering a complex set of research questions. Because the researcher can use more than one research design in the same study, mixed methods can “answer a broader range of research questions,” (Center for Innovation for Research and Teaching,

Mixed Methods Research Simply Taking Half a
Words: 580 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

mixed methods research simply taking half a quantitative plan and half of a qualitative plan and putting them together?" And an articulation of the challenges to using a mixed methods strategy of inquiry. To what extent is mixed methods research simply taking half a quantitative plan and half of a qualitative plan and putting them together? Mixed methods approaches blend aspects of both quantitative and qualitative research designs in their construction.

Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods Research
Words: 1384 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Mixed Methods Research Two important aspects of qualitative research relates to the role of the researcher and the manner in which knowledge is viewed. These two aspects fundamentally distinguish qualitative research from quantitative research (Creswell, 2014). In qualitative research, the researcher seeks to cultivate a closer relationship with the subject(s). This means that the researcher focuses on a single or a small number of subjects, and utilises designs that allow closer

Fielding, N. 2010 . Mixed Methods Research. International
Words: 927 Length: 3 Document Type: Annotated Bibliography

Fielding, N. (2010). Mixed Methods Research. International Journal of Social Research, 13 (2), 127 -- 138. In the field of criminal justice and security management, there are a wide variety of techniques used to understand the best approaches for interacting with stakeholders. Fielding (2010) determined that the mixed method approach is the most effective. This is because it is examining different aspects of the problem and conducting a separate study to

Backwards Looking Data and Mixed Methods Research
Words: 701 Length: 2 Document Type: Methodology Chapter

Aligning Methodology to Research QuestionsProblem StatementThe problem to be studied is the decline in elementary students\\\' reading scores when they reach 4th-5th grade and the possible link to the school and classroom climate. Evidence of the existence of the problem at this elementary school is based on current and previous reading scores. There is an alarming drop in the students\\\' achievement and diagnostic reading scores. Data shows that at least

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now