Verified Document

Misdiagnosing TBI As PTSD Research Proposal

PTSD as TBI Introduction

Post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and traumatic brain injury (TBI) bear similar appearances in terms of symptoms. However, treating the two issues requires completely different methods and interventions and therefore it is important to be able to tell the two problems apart. However, as the symptoms are sometimes indistinguishable a thorough and complete understanding of both is necessary so that a health care provider can make an appropriate determination as to which is which.

Background

PTSD emerged in the 1980s as an explanation for behavioral problems that it was then believed stemmed from some kind of external experience that harmed the psychological makeup of the individual. It was used to diagnose soldiers, for instance, who returned home from wars abroad and found it difficult to cope with civilian life. They often turned to drinking or to drugs or gambling or some other form of self-destructive behavior. For their symptoms they were given treatment—a combination of drugs and therapy.

This is different from TBI, as that is a brain injury which is caused by some trauma to the head. It is a physical condition that requires usually a physical intervention. PTSD on the other hand has been described as a catchall diagnosis that is not really valid for all patients who receive this diagnosis.

Defining PTSD and TBI

PTSD has been defined as “a disabling condition, resulting from exposure to traumatic events. Symptoms include intrusive re-experiencing of the trauma, avoidance of trauma-related stimuli, and alterations in cognition, mood, arousal, and reactivity” (Christova et al. 2695). The symptoms of TBI can be similar but can also include speech impairments, fatigue, fainting, nausea, and difficulty concentrating. Likewise, the methods of treatment differ. This is because PTSD relates to an earlier trauma that was suffered by the individual which has caused the person to suppress feelings or thought so as to not have to deal directly with the trauma. In many cases, the individual tries to self-medicate by using drugs or alcohol to help stifle the impulses and feelings that emanate from the PTSD and the underlying trauma that has never been adequately addressed by a professional care provider.

TBI on the other hand stems from a brain injury that alters the physical condition of the brain in some way, which impedes the...

In many cases TBI and PTSD are co-morbidities that occur in the patient together (Walter et al. 442). As the problem is a physical condition rather than a psychological, emotional or psychosocial condition, TBI treatment usually relies upon methods such as surgery, medication and therapy in order to address the issues that stem from the physical damage caused to the brain. In the case of TBI, the problem is a physical one that debilitates one’s ability to act, while PTSD is a psychological or emotional one that limits the individual’s ability to cope (Groves).
AIS Health and Stress states that PTSD actually stands for Poor Treatment from Slipshod Diagnoses (1). This tongue in cheek way of putting it comes from the fact that the AIS organization has found PTSD to be an easy way for doctors to diagnose a patient whom they don’t understand or have not taken the time to figure out: “Since the term first appeared in the American Psychiatric Association's 1980 DSMIII (Third edition of the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders) it is often assumed that PTSD is a new disorder. Its purpose was to describe a set of symptoms resulting from exposure to a traumatic event ‘considered to be outside the range of usual human experience’” (AIS Health and Stress 1). However, if doctors were eager to actually uncover the problems that the person has faced and has learned to probe to see whether other issues and variables might be impacting the patient (such as TBI for instance), the care giver would probably arrive at an alternate diagnosis—one that actually gets to the root o the problem and helps the patient to solve the issues that are plaguing him.

The Problem That Emerges

As AIS Health and Stress points out, the problem of too quickly labeling a disorder as a symptom of PTSD is that the patient may have a serious issue that is not getting treated because the patient is only receiving treatment for PTSD, which usually focuses on helping the patient to cope with some event or experience that has traumatized the person. This intervention can come by way of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) for instance or by way of cognitive processing therapy (CPT); however, as Groves shows, “no one treatment modality has been identified…

Sources used in this document:

Works Cited

AIS Health and Stress. “Why PTSD Stands for Poor Treatment from Slipshod Diagnoses. AIS Health and Stress, Feb 2013, 1-3.

Christova, Peka, et al. "Diagnosis of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) based on correlations of prewhitened fMRI data: outcomes and areas involved." Experimental Brain Research 233.9 (2015): 2695-2705.

Groves, Carla. "Exploring issues related to PTSD versus personality disorder diagnoses with military personnel." Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment 25.7 (2015): 731-745.

Walter, Kristen H., et al. "Comparing effectiveness of CPT to CPT?C among US veterans in an interdisciplinary residential PTSD/TBI treatment program." Journal of Traumatic Stress 27.4 (2014): 438-445.


Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Application of a Pedagogic Model to the Teaching of Technology to...
Words: 60754 Length: 230 Document Type: Dissertation

Pedagogic Model for Teaching of Technology to Special Education Students Almost thirty years ago, the American federal government passed an act mandating the availability of a free and appropriate public education for all handicapped children. In 1990, this act was updated and reformed as the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, which itself was reformed in 1997. At each step, the goal was to make education more equitable and more accessible to

Health Psychology Stress Coping and Well-Being Psychological Disorders...
Words: 931 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Psychological Disorders Word Count (excluding subheadings and questions): 836 First Assignment Option 1 - Perspectives on Psychological Disorder Medical Perspective: Webpage: http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/mental-illness/DS01104 The medical perspective on psychological disorders proposes that abnormal behavior can have a root physiological cause. Physiological causes of abnormal behavior include chemical imbalances or brain injuries. Changes in brain biochemistry can affect a mood and personality which can be seen as a symptom of mental disorder. Causes of brain chemistry changes include

Botox Injections Cosmetic and Medical Uses
Words: 2091 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Botox ® - What is it used for? Botox ® - Can anything bad happen? Botox ® - Looking toward the future. Botox ® - What is it? Botox, which is the trade name for botulinum toxin, is produced by a bacterium that has been identified for hundreds of years. Professor Emile Pierre van Ermengem, from Belguim, first identified the bacterium Bascillus botulinus in 1895 (DasGupta). From there, it was later renamed Clostridium botulinum,

Fibromyalgia One Might Consider Fibromyalgia to Be
Words: 6457 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

Fibromyalgia One might consider fibromyalgia to be one of the most confounding conditions around today. It is debilitating. It results in several quality of life issues. The confounding aspect of this condition is that it is difficult to diagnose. It is also difficult to treat. Most treatment modalities today recourse to treating one or more specific symptoms -- but there is no treatment that can comprehensively treat all the symptoms. (NIAMS,

Panic Disorder Counseling Panic Disorder
Words: 4240 Length: 16 Document Type: Term Paper

Apparent health can be generally positive or negative; in spite of how it links with the real health; it may be significant to comprehend its function in certain kinds of psychopathology. Negatively apparent health has been anticipated to symbolize a cognitive risk factor for panic disorder (PD), detached from elevated anxiety feeling. As a result, PD may be more likely to take place on a background of negative perceptions

Childhood Depression
Words: 4442 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

Childhood Depression Major depressive disorder, or MDD, may affect up to twenty percent of the adult population. The recognition of depression as a serious and common mental disorder has been vital in the identification and treatment of depression in adults. Leaps and bounds have been made in the field of depression research. The widespread recognition of the many possible causes of depression, including chemical imbalances with genetic or medical origins as

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now