Journal Article Critique: How do mindfulness and compassion programs improve mental health and well-being? The role of attentional processing of emotional information by Roca et al. ()
Summary:
Today, depression and anxiety are widespread and the need for the benefits that can accrue to properly administered mindfulness and compassion programs has never been more critical. Mindfulness and compassion programs take a skills-building approach to cultivating inner resources key to mental health and well-being that are increasing in popularity due to their proven efficacy. Though both mindfulness and compassion interventions show psychological benefits, their mechanisms may differ. To distinguish these factors more accurately, the broad research question of this study was to determine if structured mindfulness and compassion training alter distribution of attentional resources to emotional information, relative to a non-intervention control group. The authors examined these issues by hypothesizing that: 1) the practice of both mindfulness and compassion meditation would improve the distribution of attentional resources towards emotional information; 2) attentional changes would significantly mediate the positive outcomes of the programs; and 3) attentional changes would be a key component of the emotional regulation processes predicting psychological distress and well-being improvements (2). The general research design was naturalistic and the psychological constructs used were relevant for this purpose which were succinctly operationalized as self-reported measures of psychological distress, emotion regulation, and well-being (2). The authors point out that the research to date demonstrates meditation-linked attention changes towards emotional information mediate gains in wellbeing and distress reduction; however, they also note that the majority of studies to date have only scrutinized mindfulness mechanisms with respect to these variables of interest. Therefore, the authors emphasize the need to explore alternative practices such as compassion, timely comparisons between differing meditative techniques. Based on the results of their study, the authors conclude that meditation may promote more flexible and balanced attention to emotional information by individual suffering from a wide range of mental health disorders, which may be a key to what they describe as the transdiagnostic mechanism that underly its proven benefits on emotional distress and well-being (8). Given the increasing prevalence of mental health disorders in the United States, these findings have significant implications for all mental healthcare practitioners.
Critique:
To their credit, the studys overall goal was to determine if structured mindfulness and compassion training...
…important addition to the growing body of knowledge concerning these types of interventions which may be unfamiliar to some mental health practitioners.Taken together, the claims concerning some of the key mechanisms the mediate the beneficial effects of mindfulness and meditation programs are supported by the statistical results that emerged from the study and the four above-stated hypotheses were confirmed, but the highly focused nature of their research design limits any alternative interpretations, a constraint that further highlights the need for the addition of other constructs to this calculus. Finally, and again because this was a novel study, there were no discernible contradictions with previous research identified. In addition, the authors emphasize that the research design and participant recruitment process were approved by the university ethics committee before recruitment commenced and there was no evidence of any kind of bias on the part of the researchers, and they confirm there was no competing financial interests or personal relationships that would have affected the study in any way whatsoever.
Works Cited
Roca, P., Vazquez, C., Diez, G., & McNally, R. J. (2023). How do mindfulness and compassion programs improve mental health and well-being? The role of attentional processing of…
It is in the nursing homes job description, that the nursing staff employed should be certified, and be able to perform a number of tasks in order to better understand the patient. This includes an assessment of the patient's mental status and thought process, an understanding of the patient's health concerns, ailments and other physical issues, with an open discussion between the nurse and the patient of anything troubling
Mental Health Service Reimbursement How have changes in reimbursement and medications been a major driver in these policy and treatment changes? As a Chief Nursing Officer, one must be at once informed of the practical, day-to-day challenges of nursing in the field and of the administrative realities shaping the occupation. With respect to the latter, it is important to understand the implications of insurance, Medicare and coverage terms and conditions. These frequently
Mental Health Policies and Legislation It is not humane nor is it dignified to allow any living person to live in a florid psychosis; this would be a cruel and odd punishment. In the Australian medical practice, the health laws and regulations dictate that, doing the legal thing in the course of duty is not sufficient, but rather the professional must do what is morally right. In definition, recovery is the
In the future, this will improve quality and it will reduce the total number of uninsured. This is when productivity and the standard of living will improve by proactively addressing these issues while they are small. Alternatives To deal with any potential challenges left behind from the Affordable Care Act requires looking at alternatives which can be augmented with the law. The various options that are available include: Enacting provisions that apply
Mental Health Policy A healthy body keeps a healthy mind is a universal proverb applicable to people of all times. Mental illness not only harms the person himself but also the ones who are closely associated with him. The number of mentally ill people is increasing across the globe and there is serious need to devise an effective policy to control this situation. An abusive, compelling and dominating behavior in a dating
Mental Health Policy Issues in Mental Health and Impact Mental healthcare is an area of care that has been neglected by policy makers and by the medical community at some point in its history. Examining how the mentally ill have been treated throughout history demonstrates that opinions have changed and people treatment has followed how the general public viewed mental health. At times reformers would make conditions better, but these always seemed
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now