Verified Document

Mind: Overview And Proposed Experiment Essay

40). It is particularly difficult to elicit responses regarding what a subject things 'another' feels. Thus cross-cultural definitions of a theory of mind are difficult to determine, given that the child's experience is culturally marked by languages and concepts from the start of life. Lillard contends that it is simply not tenuous to claim that the child has core understandings about other people that exist outside of culture, given the degree to which language, manners, rituals, and folk psychological understandings of others are shaped by cultural constraints. (Lillard 1998, p. 44). Specifically regarding her inquiry about 'folk' psychological understanding in cultures, Angelina Lillard refers to the apparent tendency in other cultures to attribute outside forces, like spirits or witches, as the source of differences in behavior rather than minds. "The crucial issue is how much of folk psychology is the encapsulated product of theorizing within the child and how...much is folk psychology like manners, resulting from culture's often capricious-seeming dictates, combined with the child's developmental level, and how much is it like Piagetian conservation?" (Lillard 1998, p. 44).

Differences in children's experience with schooling and language and their apparent effect on a theory of mind further support Lillard's notion, even if they do not 'prove' her contention (Gauvain 1998, p.40).

Some might counter that, although a theory of mind is not synonymous with intelligence, it could develop in consort with other intellectual activities, and much like intelligence is shaped by a variety of forces but there is still some innate 'mindful' quality. On the other hand, analogizing a theory of mind to intelligence may be even thornier, given whether there is a general cross-cultural definition of intelligence is itself in contention.

Critics of Lillard would no doubt point out that empathy and understanding the emotions of others is affected by biology -- teenagers may be more apt to see hostility in faces than their adult counterparts, for example. To specifically test the universality...

First, a cross-cultural selection of individuals from a variety, or two different (low or high-context, for example) cultural backgrounds should be pooled. The groups could include children below the age of three, regarded as the pre-'theory of mind' period, children from the three to five-year-old age group, and children from five to seven years of age. The children would be shown a cartoon, where a boy or girl hides a toy, and then the mother of the child comes into the room. The child would be prompted if the mother knows where the hidden toy may be. Then the child would be asked to hide a toy 'in real life' while the test examiner was not present. After the examiner entered the room, he or she would ask the child if he knew where the toy might be. A theory of mind necessitates the knowledge that certain aspects of knowledge are concealed to others, and can assemble the life history of the other individual.
Then, the data would be analyzed to see firstly if a theory of mind was present in both groups, and if there was any difference in degree or at what age this theory manifested itself. Sufficient cross-cultural discrepancies would suggest that certain aspects of the theory of mind are more culturally bound, while a strong coherence would suggest that a theory of mind is more developmentally based, rather than culturally constructed.

Works Cited

Cole, M. (2005). Culture in development. In M.H. Bornstein & M.E. Lamb (Eds.),

Developmental science: An advanced textbook (5th ed., pp. 45-101). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.

Gauvain, Mary. (1998) Culture, development, and Theory of Mind: Comment on Lillard.

Psychological Bulletin. 123. 1: 37-42.

Lillard, Angelina. (1998). Ethnopsychologies: Cultural variations in theories of mind.

Psychological Bulletin 1998. 123. 1: 3-32

Lillard, Angelina. (1998). Ethnopsychologies: Reply to Wellman (1998) and Gauvain (1998)

Psychological Bulletin 1998.…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Cole, M. (2005). Culture in development. In M.H. Bornstein & M.E. Lamb (Eds.),

Developmental science: An advanced textbook (5th ed., pp. 45-101). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.

Gauvain, Mary. (1998) Culture, development, and Theory of Mind: Comment on Lillard.

Psychological Bulletin. 123. 1: 37-42.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Mind Philosophy of Mind Knowledge
Words: 1708 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Consequently, physicalism or materialism is seen by some as a form of reductionism of the potential of human mind and consciousness. It is therefore a point-of-view that should be questioned in terms of the modern exploration of the complexity of human consciousness. References A Case for Physicalism about the Human Mind (the Great Debate). Retrieved from http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/andrew_melnyk/physicalism.html Jackson. F. (1986): 'What Mary Didn't Know'. Journal of Philosophy, 83. Knowledge Argument Against Physicalism [Internet Encyclopedia

Sensitive Mothering: A Theoretical Overview Although the
Words: 1351 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Sensitive mothering: A theoretical overview Although the nature vs. nurture controversy rages on, regarding the degree to which nurturing can influence childhood development, research does suggest that a particular parenting style is preferred: so-called 'sensitive mothering.' Sensitive mothering is defined as being "highly responsive and available" to a child's needs (Spinrad & Sifter 2011). Mothers who could pick up on their child's nonverbal signals "were more likely to have infants who

Block Scheduling JOHNSO62 the Use
Words: 3002 Length: 11 Document Type: Research Proposal

The exam though it's validity as a barometer for academic preparedness for higher learning is contested, is a means of examining the factors which have been shown to be directly related to the outcomes seen with this strategy. Block scheduling has been shown to correlate directly to mathematics, language, and critical thinking in terms of improving scores. Also, the application of this evaluative comparison across a variety of students

Wireless Broadband Technology
Words: 20344 Length: 50 Document Type: Term Paper

Wireless Broadband Technology Overview of Wireless technology Presently it is quite evident to come across functioning of a sort of wireless technology in the form of mobile phone, a Palm pilot, a smart phone etc. With the inception of fast connectivity in the sphere of commerce it is customary and useful to operate from central locations communicating with the remote branches, conducting conferences in remote places, discussing with every body at every

E-Iatrogenesis: Human-Machine Interface E-Iatrogenesis: Chapters
Words: 10355 Length: 30 Document Type: Capstone Project

, 2005). In addition, the workload on clinicians is often increased past the point of reasonable because it is too intrusive and time consuming to document patient encounters during clinic time (Grabenbauer, Skinner, and Windle, 2011). The amount of information that can accumulate in a patient's record from multiple sources can be daunting and lead to information overload. CDS alerts can be so common that clinicians begin to ignore them.

Clinical Psychology Bulimia Nervosa
Words: 5371 Length: 11 Document Type: Term Paper

Clinical Psychology / Bulimia Nervosa The beginnings of clinical psychology date back to the year 1492, and it has changed from the mere treatment of mental illness to an entire field of research and experimentation, which has helped those individuals who have been affected by any form of mental disorders, like for example, the eating disorders like bulimia nervosa and anorexia nervosa prevalent among adolescent and twenty-year-old women all over the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now