In fact, an entity with an infinite essence will, by definition, have infinite attributes.
Spinoza builds upon the idea of an infinite God by going further and stating that absolutely infinite substance is indivisible. This is because, if it were divisible, and if each part would retain the nature of the infinite substance, which would result in there being more than one substance of the same nature, which Spinoza has already demonstrated is impossible. Moreover, if this substance were divisible in a way that meant that each part did not retain the nature of infinite substance that would result in the absolutely infinite substance ceasing to be. Because that is impossible, Spinoza comes to the conclusion that there can be no other substance but God.
If there can be no other substance but God, then extension and thought, if they exist, are either attributes of God or modes following from the attributes of God. Recalling that a substance can be a bearer of multiple attributes without being divisible, because an attribute is an essential property of substance and can be conceived through itself, it becomes clear that substances can have different attributes. Moreover, Spinoza suggests that the reality of a being goes parallel with its attributes. Therefore, an infinite being will have infinite attributes.
Examining Spinoza's reasoning about God, one sees further similarities between Leibniz and Spinoza. Spinoza comes to the conclusion that God cannot be conceived not to exist because existence is involved in his essence. Spinoza relies upon the principle of sufficient reason to come to the conclusion that there is always a cause for existence/non-existence. The only thing that could cause either God's existence or non-existence would have to be God. Leibniz also uses the principle of sufficient reasoning, but he uses it in a different manner. According to Leibniz, God is logically perfect, and, because he does not need anything else for his existence, nothing can prevent his existence.
Having established the existence of God, Spinoza goes on to look at what God would be described. He finds that God, as an infinite substance, cannot be bound by a finite body, shape, size, or extension. However, because God is the only substance, there cannot be corporeal bodies separate from God and created by God. If there is an extension, then it must be one of God's attributes, and therefore be infinite as well. Spinoza actually uses these propositions to declare that transcendent creation is possible, by establishing that substance cannot be produced or created from nothing, because existence is involved in its essence. Therefore, Spinoza rejects the transcendentalist approach. According to him, the main idea behind the transcendentalist approach is that corporeal substance is both finite and divisible, making it separate from God, who is both infinite and indivisible.
It is important to realize that their different conceptions of God mean that the philosophers also view morality in a very different manner. According to Spinoza God is the efficient cause of everything. He believes that intellect and will do not pertain to the nature of God. Instead, everything flows from God's nature, and not as a result of intellect or will. Therefore, God is not subject to any laws extrinsic to his own nature, including laws of morality. This point-of-view is very different than Leibniz's view, which suggests that even God's actions are guided by an overarching morality. Spinoza believes that intellect does not pertain to God's nature. If it did, it would be radically different from man's intellect, because God's intellect would necessarily come before those things of which he had knowledge, since God is prior in causality to all objects. If God's intellect was to be part of his nature, then it would not only be the cause of his essences, but also of the existences of things.
Spinoza's most difficult aspect of dealing with dualism comes when looking at the existence of finite things in the universe, if all things in the universe are extensions of God, who is, by definition, infinite. Spinoza comes to the conclusion that everything is determined by God's nature to exist and to exist in a determinate way. For him, there are two sides of Nature. First, there is the active, productive aspect of the universe, God and his attributes, from which all else follows. This side of Nature and God are identical. The other part of the universe is that which is produced and sustained by the active aspect. According to Spinoza, things could not have been produced by God in any other...
Role of Courts in Curing Gender Disparity in Capital Punishment There is no question that there is gender disparity in the rate at which men and women are given the death penalty. As of January 1, 2010 there were 61 women on death row, which was 1.87% of the total death row population of about 3,261 persons (Death Penalty Information Center, 2010). Over the past 100 years, over 40 women have
Rationalist Philosophers Descartes: Explain one of Descartes' arguments in Meditation VI for substance dualism. Critically discuss one possible objection to the argument. Descartes was not a nihilist or solipsist who truly doubted the existence of anything outside his own mind, and only used skepticism to arrive at clear and distinct ideas. He has already proved his own existence as a thinking being, and that God exists, along with his physical body and objects
As experiments became more complex, however, especially noting embryonic development, scientists found that the process that occurs in vitro parallels the evolutionary process of nerve system complexity, and then becomes more qualitative in that not every aspect of thought can be explained by a simple combination of neurotransmitters (neuron coded molecules) or electrical events. While it is true that the electrical even between two cells allows for communication, the subtle
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now