Verified Document

Middle East My Enemy's Enemy Term Paper

At the beginning of the book, the young man is humiliated and tortured by the Western appearing and speaking judicial committee. Then, further demonstrating the levels of control and command over their citizens, the committee attempt to impinge upon the ways that young man thinks. He is told that he must write about the 20th century's most important achievement and the greatest Arab figure, to demonstrate his loyalty to the state. Although one would think that there could be no correct answer to the open-ended questions posed by The Committee, clearly there is, in their eyes, as when he makes a choice that could damage their reputation, they track him down to 'correct' his selection. The young man's choice, that of a doctor who is famous for his works of global outreach and philanthropy, shows that the apparently noxious ideology of globalization has already penetrated even his consciousness. The reason the doctor is seen as evil in the book is because he is an international figure, and globalization is deemed to be harmful. The committee is afraid that if the young man selects this doctor, the regime's true ideology will be revealed, and the Westernized control of the Middle East will make itself known to the general population. The ideology of the supposed diversification of interests of modern economic life masks the real, controlling presence of the West that is manifest even on the Carter buses that run through the streets. This demonstrates that the nation is in the grips of a consumption ideology that only results the people consuming things against their own true nation's interests. Rather than Coca-Cola, Ibrahim suggests, better to drink in the ideology of true anti-capitalist nationalism.

The tone of the work suggests that the author...

The Middle East is seen as too fragile and impinged upon by Western interests in the past to truly become part of the global community without being literally consumed by American interests.
If this view persists, it is quite likely that Gelvin's despairing assertion that there can be little hope that the future of the Middle East will look different from the present will become a reality.

Ibrahim's book helps the reader understand how many persons of the Middle East resist the influence of the West, and why pro-Islamic militant groups still have an attraction, even for wealthy or middle class, educated residents of the Middle Eastern region. However, the emotional texture of The Committee, if not the symbolic logic, suggests that the writer Ibrahim views totalitarianism of any kind with some amount of fear, even though he views the West as the greater threat than Islamic militancy. Ibrahim's his use of Kafka's The Trial shows that much as the author despises Coca-Cola, he does not view the entire intellectual legacy of the West as evil. There are, in the individual, if not corporate expression of the arts, perhaps some hopes for greater toleration between the West and the Middle East, although such hopes, after reading both Ibrahim and Gelvin's works, seem few and far between.

Works Cited

Gelvin, James. The Modern Middle East: A History. New York: Oxford University Press, 2004.

Ibrahim, The Modern Middle East: A History, Oxford University Press, 2004. The Committee. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press, 2001.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Gelvin, James. The Modern Middle East: A History. New York: Oxford University Press, 2004.

Ibrahim, The Modern Middle East: A History, Oxford University Press, 2004. The Committee. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press, 2001.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Middle East -- a Region
Words: 1125 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Since the breakup of the Soviet Union, Russia has also become a major distributor world of oil, in addition to the Middle East. Although its policies can no longer be predicted as reliably as during the Cold War, its interests are not always commensurate with any one actor, and it is now a volatile presence in international affairs that the United States must take into consideration when making policies. The

Middle East the Crisis in
Words: 312 Length: 1 Document Type: Essay

Theological differences are the least important issue facing Jews and Muslims. The Palestinians rightfully believe that the British stole their homelands from them after the Second World War, and that both the United Kingdom and the Untied States unabashedly support Israel. The Israelis, on the other hand, point to the recurring incidences of terrorism that plague the country and prevent peace. When both sides focus on the past instead of

Middle East Conflict
Words: 1271 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Middle East Conflict As an Israeli citizen, I often find myself awestruck at our present situation. The needs and desires of people in my country are not unlike those of most people. We desire to live and work in safety; we want have peace with those around us; but we also want to maintain our traditions and our heritage as we see fit. Israel has again and again suffered attacks because

Middle East Background Information of
Words: 1503 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

This has caused a divide in Iran, where traditionalists want to save the old religious and moral values, while many people want to bring more changes to Iran, like democracy and true free elections. This has created a rift in the country, and has caused unrest and even hatred of western values. That is one of the things that has caused Muslim fundamentalists in Iran (and elsewhere in the

Middle East Simulations From the
Words: 2028 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

There are a few who have been or are now involved with groups that are seeking conciliation.. The positive similarity of many of these individuals is that they would like to see a productive end to the situation, even if it means compromise. There is no possibility of peace in the Middle East unless people from all backgrounds, who are the most affected, are part of the dialogue. The nations,

Middle East, Counter-Terrorism and What
Words: 3163 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

They are also dangerous to the United States because of the United States policy of having open doors and welcoming many different cultures and traditions to its lands. For this reason the three groups believe the United States works closely with those that they wish to eradicate. In addition the groups can easily infiltrate the nation and set up terrorist plans in this country because of the freedom of travel

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now