Verified Document

Mexican Government Diaz, Villa And Zapata's Ideas Essay

Mexican Government Diaz, Villa and Zapata's Ideas of Government and the Individual:

Similarities and Dissimilarities

Government in many areas of the world has changed from one in which the people are the vassals of the government to one in which the government is the servant of the people. Individuals form societies because they have a selfish need for protection, and they form governments for that purpose. Unfortunately, those governments sometimes abuse their power and forget what the government is for. Mexico had three rulers in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries who epitomized divergent beliefs regarding the government and individual rights. This essay reflects the authoritarianism of Diaz, Villa and Zapata and how they dealt with the subject of individual rights.

Diaz

Porfirio Diaz had one of the longest reins as ruler of Mexico of any leader. Ostensibly he was the leader of a representative republic, but in reality he was a dictator who ruled the country with an iron fist. He believed that he was the "father of the nation" (43), and he treated his people as an authoritarian would. There are many examples of how Diaz ruled the people and what he actually thought of them. In one instance, his 80th birthday, Diaz invited dignitaries from around the world to a birthday celebration at his palace in Mexico City. The ambassadors were shown the innermost parts of the city that Diaz had sanitized of people, as well as grime, so that...

The poor meanwhile had been banished to the slums so that Diaz could look good in his whitewashed world (1, 2).
He was the epitome of the, seemingly, benevolent dictator who showed the world the good he did for his people while keeping the average citizen in abject poverty. The rights of individual citizens were wrapped up in what they could provide for the government and Diaz. He claimed the Mexican people as his children, but he was a very abusive father.

Villa

The problem with the government according to Pancho Villa is that it was all about Pancho Villa. He cared about the people only as far as he could use them. In comparing his style of leadership to Zapata's the book says "Villa had none of Zapata's mystical feeling about the soil or about the village as personality. He was more of a political opportunist, proactive where Zapata was reactive" (71). This meant that Villa was able to win the love of the people who fought for him because he needed them at the time, but in reality he believed that the peasants were scum the same as Diaz. There was really very little difference between Diaz and Villa. Both were opportunists who came from the poorest of the mestizos and rose to power through wheedling and strong-handed techniques.

As far as individual rights, he believed that the peons had none. It seemed that to him, they were a permanent working class who should have no higher ambition than that. He "went on…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

McLynn, Frank. Villa and Zapata: A History of the Mexican Revolution. New York: Carroll & Graf Publishers, 2000. Print.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Mexican Revolutions the Principal Causes
Words: 3199 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

Huerta was very successful in helping Madero defeat Orozco's rebellion, eventually driving Orozco into the United States. However, Madero did not show the type of respect or appreciation that Huerta was expecting for his victory. On the contrary, Madero asked Huerta to account for campaign money. It was this slight that inspired Huerta to work against Madero. Of course, that slight alone would probably not have been sufficient to inspire

Porofino Diaz Porfirio Diaz "Began As an
Words: 2315 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Porofino Diaz Porfirio Diaz "began as an activist against reaction and privilege and ended as a longtime dictator and staunch defender of the very forces he had once opposed," (Tuck). Indeed, Porfirio's life is characterized by a series of ironies. Porfirio was a Mestizo. His mother was a Native woman and his father was a working class Criollo (Mexican-born Spaniard). Some sources trace the Diaz family on both sides to Mestizo,

Pancho Villa's Raid on Columbus,
Words: 3299 Length: 10 Document Type: Thesis

"He saw the attacks as a strategy to embroil the U.S. with the Carranza government and therefore force his downfall." The American president took a great interest in the stories emerged about Villa and even sent special agents to investigate the matter. Delegate John Lind was part of this mission and his conclusions were that while Villa was an individual of high morals, "physical and mental efficiency," he was "cruel

Time Period Mexico
Words: 1345 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Revolutionary history of Mexico [...] revolutionary period/era in Mexican social development and describe the atmosphere of the period. The Mexican Revolution was a period of great upheaval in the society and government of Mexico. It was an attempt to equalize class and social status and bring modernization to the country. However, ultimately the Revolution failed, because Mexico remained as divided as ever after the Revolution -- partly because the

The Underdogs by Mariano Azuela
Words: 1229 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Mariano Azuela The Mexican Revolution has always been debated upon by historians, some labeling it as a "fiesta de balas" -- a party of bullets, with minimal political aims or ideologies. Others have not disregarded the revolution and noted that although most of the conflicts were centered in the provinces of the Mexican countryside, the revolutions' leaders were politically driven and adopted clear political ideologies. How does the novel The

Forgotten Yet Essential Soladaras in
Words: 3477 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

However, over the years, history book publishers have not followed suit and described the soladeras in a positive way. For instance, one of Casaola's most well-known photos is of a harried soldadera in a train station. The photograph's saturated colors make the scene deeply emotional and compelling, with a feeling of urgency and dynamic motion. The spontaneity of the picture and transparency of reality provide an historical accuracy and

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now