Verified Document

Metal Workers Employment Law Case Review One Essay

¶ … Metal Workers Employment Law Case Review One of the primary functions of the judiciary is to clearly define the parameters of legislative intent, as the passage of any law necessarily creates parties with a vested interest in bypassing or overturning the statute, and in the case of Local 28, Sheet Metal Workers v. EEOC 478 U.S. 421 (1986) the Supreme Court was again tasked with assessing the validity of a law via its method of application. This case of Sheet Metal Workers v. EEOC presented the high court with an opportunity to decisively delineate the remedies afforded to correct violations of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibited employers from discriminating on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. When the New York State Commission for Human Rights identified New York City's Local 28 Joint Apprenticeship Committee (JAC) as a gross violator of Title VII in its hiring practices, filing suit to obtain injunctive relief, the Second Circuit Court ruled in their favor, ordering the JAC to cease and desist racially discriminatory practices (1976). The Second Circuit Court determined that the "Sheet Metal Workers ... had formally excluded Negroes until 1946, and for the next twenty years no Negro became a member of the Local 28 in New York City" (Moreno, 1999) with unofficial exclusion being maintained through an apprenticeship system defined by nepotism and bigotry.

Despite the Second Circuit's decision, however, countless sessions of litigation followed during the following 18 years, as the Local 28 and its JAC obstinately...

When the Supreme Court finally heard the case in 1986, the JAC's appeal of the remedies ordered by the Second Circuit targeted section 706(g) of Title VII, which "invests broad equitable discretion in the federal courts to effectuate the 'make whole' objective of title VII (and) aims to make the victims of unlawful discrimination whole by restoring them so far as possible ... To a position where they would have been were it not for the unlawful discrimination" (Napolitano, 1987). According to the JAC's interpretation of the statutory language, "section 706(g) authorizes a district court to award preferential treatment only to actual victims of unlawful discrimination" (Brennan, 1986), despite the fact that the court had previously ruled in Griggs v. Duke Power Co. that the ostensible legal intention of Title VII was "to remove barriers that have operated in the past to favor an identifiable group of white employees over other employees" (1971). In deciding "whether the remedial provisions of Title VII ... empower a district court to order race-conscious relief that may benefit individuals who are not identified victims of unlawful discrimination" (Napolitano, 1987), the court's contentious 5-4 decision ultimately affirmed the Second Circuit's original imposition of a 29% nonwhite membership quota, and the $150,000 fine intended to provide funding for increased quality efforts within the Local 28's JAC program.
The decision rendered in the case of Sheet Metal Workers v.…

Sources used in this document:
References

142 U.S.C. § 2000e-2000e-17 (1982)

Griggs v. Duke Power Co., 401 U.S. 424, 429 (1971).

Moreno, P.D. (1999). From direct action to affirmative action: Fair employment law and policy in america 1933-1972. (3rd ed.). Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana State University Press.

Napolitano, S. (1987). Interpreting the legislative history of section 706(g) of title vii. Boston College Third World Law Journal, 7(2), 263-276. Retrieved from http://lawdigitalcommons.bc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1378&context=twlj
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Metal Health Mental Issue 2226 Mental Health
Words: 3481 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Metal Health Mental Issue 2226 Mental Health Researches indicate that poverty and mental illness are correlated with each other in a broader spectrum. This research paper is commissioned on the basis of two exhaustively researched hypotheses: H1 Poverty can cause mental illness and H2 Mental illness is subjected to poverty. Throughout this research paper, these two hypotheses have been investigated from scholarly academic resources. At the end of the proposed research it has

Apprenticeship Data Review
Words: 2050 Length: 8 Document Type: Data Analysis Chapter

Apprenticeship Data Review: UK, France and USA Why are apprenticeship contracts different now than in the past? There are differences in the average pay of French and English apprentices. Some of the difference is age, not just wage. Older students are denied training opportunities in the U.K., I respectfully submit. A new model may be in order for the English and the French -- the emerging American apprenticeship model. According to the

Educational Law How Lawful How
Words: 3482 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

Conservatives, on the other hand, have many passions and one of them is a color-blind government. Most of them believe that all policies of discrimination should be discarded. They view these policies as unwise, immoral and unconstitutional. Three conservative organizations submitted a collective brief to the Supreme Court on the Michigan cases. These organizations were the Center for Equal Opportunity, the Independent Women's Forum and the American Civil Rights

Post Apartheid South Africa Employment Trends
Words: 6873 Length: 18 Document Type: Research Paper

South Africa Labor Relations This report shall deign to cover the broad topic of employee and employer relations in the country of South Africa. While the overall subject of labor relations is an important and vital topic in all countries to some degree or another, South Africa is absolutely one of those countries that has a rich amount of conflict, discrimination, big questions and bigger answers than most other countries. Indeed,

Causes of Chronic Bronchitis in Workers This
Words: 3638 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Causes of Chronic Bronchitis in Workers This review shows the literature and research available in the issue of respiratory diseases and the various occupations. The review shows that there is a pressing need to evaluate and conduct research in the known areas like coal, cement, and pesticides, but alarmingly agriculture and other industries have also to be included. It is not only the factories that are hazardous. There are arguments to show

Project Management: Case Study in Managing a
Words: 14774 Length: 55 Document Type: Term Paper

Project Management: Case Study in Managing a Complex Shipyard Project in Singapore Background of Complex Shipyard Construction Project Company background Project Overview and Objective Work Process of Building Construction Issue Analysis in Shipyard Construction Project Management Literature Review of Project Management Issues in Scope Management Methodology of Scope Management Lessons Learned from Scope Management Issues in Cost Management Methodology of Cost Management Lessons Learned from Cost Management Issues in Human Resources Methodology of HR Management Lessons Learned from Human Resource Management Case Study in Managing a

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now