When one throws the element of ethnicity into the mix, the process of diagnosis becomes even more difficult. Let us take, for instance the effect of religion on the diagnosis of a mental illness.
In some religions it is considered to be "normal" to experience visions, see ghosts, and talk to the dead. However, from a strict clinical standpoint, these things do not exist and therefore indicate a break from reality. There have certainly been people diagnosed with a serious mental illness for "hallucinating." However, it is much more difficult to determine when to label such a happening a "hallucination" or a "vision." For the person being diagnosed, the experience does not change. However, the label that is applied to the experience can mean the difference between the accepted norm and mental illness (Griffiths et al., 2006, 2).
There are differences in reactions to clinicians that are culturally based as well. For instance, in Asian cultures it is considered to be a lack of respect to disagree with a physician regarding certain symptoms or a diagnosis. Certain Middle Eastern and Asian cultures permit a certain degree of physical punishment in order to keep wives and children in line. The use of opium holds fewer societal consequences and is considered to be socially acceptable in countries such as Turkey and Pakistan. There are many more examples throughout the world where normal behavior in one culture is socially unacceptable in another.
Conclusion
This study focused on various factors that effect the decision to diagnose and label a person as mentally ill. As a health care professional one must be continually aware of the effects that our decisions have on the patient and the patient's family. Once the diagnosis of a mental illness is made and the person has that label, it will have an effect on them for the rest of their lives. They will always have that on their record, even after they have been successfully treated and have recovered there will still be some form of record that will have an impact on their lives. For example, employers and insurance carriers might access this information and use it as a part of their decision to employ or insure that person. Although being diagnosed with a mental illness no longer carries the stigma that it once did, there is still the feeling that a person that is diagnosed with a mental illness will be less reliable on the job than someone that has not been diagnosed with a mental illness.
As health care professionals, we must remain aware of how our own cultural biases might effect the decisions that we make on a daily basis. It is easy to say that one will make an impartial decision that is not based on biases, but this is an unrealistic expectation for anyone. We are a product of the society in which we live, our parent's upbringing and opinion, as well as recipients of the mass media and its exploitation of the mentally ill. Exposure to all of these elements, in addition to our base personality, help to shape us into the person that we are both professionally and personally. It is normal human nature to make judgments about the people and places that we encounter in our daily routines. However, one must be careful not to let personal opinions substitute for knowledge.
In consideration of all of these elements, the final analysis is that a health care professional must remember that their key role is to intervene in a manner that is in the best interest...
Mental Illness and Child Abuse The physical abuse of children was 'rediscovered' by physicians over fifty years ago. Since then, some observers have expressed concern at the continuing 'medicalisation' of what they consider to be essentially a social problem (Parton, 1985). A widely-held view emerged from the ensuing debate that child physical abuse and neglect occurred through an interaction between parents, children and their social environment. The model described parents with
Edwards challenges the extreme on the other end as well, i.e. that total wellness sis the only possible state of being labeled healthy. The scholar sites the World Health Organization's definition of wellness as complete mental and physical wellness as far too broad and encompassing and illegitimates the reality of human existence. (16. Edwards, CC2010, pp. 0090) Edwards ultimately argues that the challenges faced by both those who believe
Mental Illness The foremost question relating to mental illness concerns about its very existence - whether mental illness actually exists or not? According to Thomas Szasz, mental illness is a mere myth (Szasz, 1960) and does not exist, as illness can be defined only in terms of physical pathology and most mental disorders have no such demonstrable pathology. In a similar viewpoint, it was argued that biology was not relevant to
Null Hypothesis 2: The mentally ill are not particularly at risk of substance abuse or criminal activity. 4) Independent and Dependent Variables Independent variables that might influence the study focused on the mentally ill include other influencing factors such as support from family, friends, age, and the use of psychotropic drugs. Independent variables that can influence the study includes attitudes and stigmatization by professionals at institutions that house mentally ill inmates. This can
However many people displaying psychiatric symptoms were over represented in jail and there is no tangible evidence to prove that it is their mental illness that got them to jail. Indeed unless it can be shown that factors unique to serious mental illness are specifically associated with behavior leading to arrest and incarceration, the criminalization hypothesis ought to be reconsidered. It should put into consideration more powerful risk factors for
mental health field and the economy. The writer presents a hypothesis that the economic downturn can and does contribute to increased mental health issues. National economies fluctuate constantly. Sometimes the slump is short lived and other times the downturn lasts for years. The mental health of those who live in an area that is suffering from an economic downturn can fluctuate as well. Those who are caught in the throes
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now