Verified Document

Mechanical Engineering And Engineering Essay

Ferguson's Argument and Evidence In Eugene Ferguson Engineering and the Mind's Eye, he makes the case that the existing privileging of science and math over the nonverbal and visual in engineering education is mutually a dangerous practice and a historical abnormality. By applying a well-demonstrated chronicle of engineering strategy, Ferguson claims that not all engineering complications can be resolved by analysis in mathematical; short of the ability to envisage machines, environment, and the structures. He goes on to explain the fact that engineers, a lot of the time, make poor judgment calls. These weak calls lead to crushing disappointments in nuclear power plants, bridges, refrigerators, and other machinery. The book holds a generous variety of old drawings and sketches and presents well-chosen themes, as well as a foretaste into the history of engineering, from its earlier stages to its status, scattered with the essential part played by the mind's eye. Ferguson highlights the exclusive nature of engineering design, specifically that it is not a science, nevertheless instead of art that produces many helpful items. Ferguson stressed that the ancients, regardless of having neither computers nor calculus, often carried out extraordinary complexity in their designs. We, with our display of current logical tools, quite often attain remarkable foolishness in ours.

Ferguson made the point that design as "invention instigates things to come into being from thoughts, makes the world follow to view; while science, by springing ideas from watching, makes the statement "form follows function" false. He also argued that design has two main principal purposes. One of those purposes is to show the designers how the concepts look on paper. Ferguson debates that they display to the workers was important because it was visual. He believed that the designs were are all founded on reasonable judgments.

Furthermore, Ferguson concludes that this has always been and will always be the case that the privileging of science and math over the nonverbal and visual in engineering education would become more and more. The design aspect of engineering, however, receives less recognition than does its scientific nature. The design is a process that necessarily is infested with uncertainties because one can never fully predict its outcomes. However, the path taken by the design process is predictable even though modern tools like computer-aided design programs are used. This is the way Ferguson thought.

Ferguson's stresses on the visual. He believes that it is linked to a greater worry with engineering's loss of that holistic, experiential real-world experience on which the field was initially founded. Therefore, his history of engineering highlights its subjective character before the clear focus. He also uses history to make his point. Ferguson talks about how engineers in the Renaissance, applied drawing techniques that were effective. Again, this showed how the visual was important. He also used drawing methods to visualize and therefore think through Scientific Revolution breakthroughs such as human anatomy and planetary motion. Also, other things like perspective drawing procedures (developed by Renaissance statisticians) facilitated project by making representations more exact. During the 18th and 19th centuries, drawing techniques that were formalized like the application of models, and the creation of visual systems for engineering computation -- descriptive statistics, nomography, slide rules, and indicator diagrams -- reserved visual thinking at the lead of engineering practice and design.

When WWII ended, engineering education moved away from what was an open-ended art and in the direction of sound, natural science. Suddenly shop courses were swapped with theories of mechanics, heat transfer, thermodynamics; students have slight collaboration with the real world; those that are graduating engineers have a tough time designing answers for real-world difficulties.

Eugene Ferguson proves...

He contends that a structure of engineering education that disregards nonverbal thinking will create engineers who are seriously ignorant of the many behaviors in which the real world fluctuates from the exact replicas constructed in the minds of those in the academic.
Eugene Ferguson also looks at the course of engineering design. Ferguson, who has been successively a professional museum curator, a mechanical engineer, and an instructor of the history of technology, utilizes instances fluctuating from the progress of the American ax to the downfall of the Hartford Coliseum. Also, the functioning of the Hubble space telescope to show the customs where visual thinking enhances engineering and the traditions in which engineering that depends on exclusively on technical cleverness can go amiss. Ferguson finishes his account by debating that engineering instruction since 1945 has been distorted in the direction of analytical methods. By the way, are recognized as being the simplest to appraise and teach as mentioned earlier in the essay.

All over, Ferguson's core argument is that the personal, connection to real-world problems through representation and visual thinking, is extremely significant to engineers' capability to design solutions that are effective. Also, that engineering's systematic turn to theoretical objectivity has had terrible effects on the utility and safety of engineering projects. Even though his stress is more on the visual side, it naturally leads Ferguson to abandon larger systems of power in some of his illustrations. I suppose that what he's getting at is nurturing creativity instead of the visual as such. His argument for creative and subjectivity, real-world thinking in engineering inevitably sound incredibly logical to me.

Part II: Assess and Explore the Applicability of Ferguson's ideas to other Engineering Realms.

Corporations are turning out to be more and more analytical of new graduate engineers. The criticism is not that the new graduates are not smart students. It is not even that their scientific training is not satisfactory; but that these graduates are not aware how to use this exercise. They lack the wisdom when it comes down to them applying it to real engineering complications. Eugene Ferguson in the Mind's Eye agrees on Engineering. He believes that university programs are not getting what they need. He stresses that they are missing the real core of engineering. Programs highlight the technical features of the discipline -- analysis, analysis, computer simulation, and mathematical description. However, ignore a myriad of other characteristics that are vital for effective engineering projects.

Ferguson argued that elite engineering schools are more and more turning out students more acquainted with arithmetic than machinery: graduates, mentioned to me a decade ago, we can't, make anything that anyone needs anymore.' Ferguson goes on to mention that this is about as harsh as you can be in talking about an engineer."

Ferguson would agree with R. A. Buchanan article, The Diaspora of British Engineering, who explores how engineering was at the top of its game during the imperialism era. The fact that the separation of British engineering in the era before 1830 was merely comparative should serve to prompt us that there were allowances, and some of these were imperative to be worth citing as signs of the directions that British engineering infiltration would embark on.…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Brown, John K. 1999. "When Machines Became Gray and Drawings Black and White: William Sellers and the Rationalization of Mechanical Engineering." IA. The Journal of the Society for Industrial Archeology 25 (2): 29-54.

Buchanan, R. A. 1986. "The Diaspora of British Engineering." Technology and Culture 27 (3): 501-524.

Burke, John G. 1966. "Bursting Boilers and the Federal Power." Technology and Culture 7 (1): 1-23.

Hounshell, David A. 1980. "Edison and the Pure Science Ideal in 19th-Century America." Science 207 (4431): 612-617.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Ethics in Mechanical Engineering Ethical
Words: 1132 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

This definition implies that organizational commitment is essentially a conscious, value-based process." From this perspective, Bob should not have any ethical conflicts with his job if he is to be considered committed to it. Yet at the same time, someone who has no moral problem with helping to produce weapons that cause such pain and mass destruction may not be of the moral character to be trusted with such a

Mobile Mechanical Engineering Position in
Words: 943 Length: 3 Document Type: Thesis

For these customers, an electric Rolls-Royce would be ideal" (qtd. In Squatriglia, par. 5). The Rolls-Royce name is synonymous with excellence; it is good to know that they are extending that excellence to a more socially and environmentally conscious plateau, rather than restng on the laurels of luxury that the brand has built during the century of its existence. This tradition of excellence is the main reason I would like

Engineering Statement of Purpose
Words: 449 Length: 2 Document Type: Admission Essay

Personal StatementWhen I was a child I would wonder about the stars I observed in the night sky. Unlike some children, I was not content to simply regard the stars as beautiful pinpoints of light or to listen to my parents relate myths of how the constellations came to be. I was driven to learn more, to watch scientific programs about the universe, and to start to read about the

Engineering Curriculum Content Engineering Curriculum Acquiring Engineering...
Words: 1055 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Engineering Curriculum Content Engineering curriculum Acquiring Engineering education is essential in training good quality engineer who afterwards becomes equipped to take up challenging task and responsibility as they undertake their duty. As one who is bestowed with responsibilities of administering an institution with limited resources and assigned to take part in revising the engineering curriculum that can accommodate more number of graduates, it is important to have necessary curriculum contents. As time passed

Engineering Code of Ethics Asme.
Words: 1053 Length: 4 Document Type: Annotated Bibliography

S. standards on foreign companies. Cascio, W.F. "Decency Means More than 'Always Low Prices': A Comparison of Costco to Wal-Mart's Sam's Club." Academy of Management Perspectives (August 2006). Accessed 18 June 2012 from: http://www.ou.edu/russell/UGcomp/Cascio.pdf This source is an article that appeared in the professional Journal, Academy of Management Perspectives. It provides a comparison of Wal-Mart and Costco from the perspective of their respective ethical approaches to various issues. Generally, the author contrasts the manner

Engineering Design Project -- Mousetrap
Words: 627 Length: 2 Document Type: Book Report

The second approach was accepted. Manufacturing, Assembly, and Implementation of Selected Design During preliminary testing, it was determined that the main engineering problems would be: (1) limiting the force of the mechanism, and (2) determining the best way to attach an appropriate weight so that the release point would allow energy to be converted into forward propulsion as efficiently as possible. In that regard, string with attached metal hooks was used

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now