Verified Document

Measuring IT Value The Progression Of How Essay

Measuring IT Value The progression of how enterprises measure information technologies' (IT) performance has been a progression from inward-centric metrics of performance to advanced analytics that capture contributions to strategic objectives. Chief Information Officers (CIOs) often measure their performance by cost reduction and system consolidation while Chief Executive Officers (CEOs) measure IT by the contribution to new business growth (Trkman, McCormack, de Oliveira, Ladeira, 2010). There are many strategic frameworks that enterprises use to map the contribution of IT, with the Porter value chain being the most prevalent (Porter, 1986). The intent of this analysis is to evaluate the most critical metrics that an enterprise can use to measure the effectiveness and efficiency of IT. These metrics also fuel the methods used to measure toe economic value of an IT department to a given enterprise as well. This aspect of measuring IT value will be defined in addition to evaluating the models used for measuring the economic vale of an IT department to a company. Finally there is a brief discussion of whether or not traditional financial ratios and measurements must be applied to measuring the value of IT or not. In reality these metrics are often only showing a part of the Return on Investment (ROI) of any IT investment. To get the complete picture of performance, enterprises needs to align their IT efficiency and effectiveness measures to specific strategy performance, and the Porter value chain is ideal for defining these interrelationships (Porter, 1986). Financial metrics only provide part of the insight into the ROI of IT needed.

Frameworks for Measuring IT Value

The frameworks that have been traditionally used to measure economic value of IT are no longer flexible enough to deal with the level of agility and complexity that enterprises are dealing with daily. These traditional frameworks including the Balanced Scorecard, Capability Maturity Framework, IT Costs vs. Benefits Analysis, and many others have been created primarily to measure IT's value in purely financial terms without looking at its strategic value (McShea,...

Each of these frameworks are also designed to take into account financial metrics that are easily defined and tracked, given the highly structured reporting systems supporting them. The metrics of IT efficiency, namely transaction accuracy, speed and scalability, along with inventory turns, managing of complex supply chain, sourcing and strategic systems performance, all quantified through relatively closed processes, miss the point (Columbus, 2008). The same holds true for those metrics that measure effectiveness, as the nature of these analytics is predicated on only those methodologies that can capture the most structured data. Measuring effectiveness with these limited methodologies that deal only with the most structured reporting processes only deliver 30% at best of all available performance data at best (McShea, 2006).
Given the constrained nature of analytics and metrics that are predicated only on the most measurable efficiency- and effectiveness-based methodologies in place in enterprises, it is not surprising their value is diminishing as uncertainty grows in the markets enterprises serve. CEOs are now demanding that the Balance Scorecard, IT costs vs. benefits analysis, and capability maturity frameworks have an element of customer-based data in them, at the very least, demand-driven insights and intelligence (Barrett, 2007).

The Transformation of IT Metrics

The traditional frameworks for measuring IT value including the Balanced Scorecard, IT costs vs. benefits, and capability maturing framework are today being modified to reflect IT's value to business strategies, not just cost reduction (McShea, 2006). This shift in how IT analytics and metrics are used is changing how enterprises organize and implement their communication and collaboration systems as well (Zhen, Jiang, Song, 2011).

Most significant is the change occurring in the cultures of organizations, with communication, collaboration and shared task ownership more prevalent than ever before. One of the best studies showing how the measurement of IT value can be used as a catalyst to create higher levels of communication…

Sources used in this document:
References

Barrett, J. (2007, November). Demand-Driven is an Operational Strategy. Industrial Management, 49(6), 14-19,5.

Columbus, L.. (2008, June). The Perfect Order Meets Customer Expectations. Supply & Demand Chain Executive, 9(4), 37-38.

Jeffrey H. Dyer, & Kentaro Nobeoka. (2000). Creating and managing a high-performance knowledge-sharing network: The Toyota case. Strategic Management Journal: Special Issue: Strategic Networks, 21(3), 345-367.

Debra Hofman (2004, September). The HIERARCHY of SUPPLY CHAIN METRICS. Supply Chain Management Review, 8(6), 28-37.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Measuring Gang-Related Crime Is an
Words: 5110 Length: 15 Document Type: Discussion Chapter

The authors do not state that public perceptions of severity should be discounted, but merely that these should not be over-emphasized, as was the case in previous literature. Another existing mode of measuring crime severity is that of economic models. Economic measures of costs may seem more objective, but given that they also involve speculative losses (such as lost productivity), they are not universally agreed upon. One widely-used model to

Transplant Medicine the Major Histocompatibility Complex MHC
Words: 1052 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Transplant Medicine The Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC) contains over 128 functional genes. This is the densest part of the human genome and is responsible for most autoimmune diseases. This region also determines vaccine responsiveness, adverse drug reactions, disease progression and transplant rejection. The MHC genes are multigenic with a high degree of allelic polymorphism. There are over 7,500 different alleles and over 5,458 expressed MHC antigens currently known. (DeFranco, Locksley &

Marketing Response There Are Several
Words: 3792 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

This is why those service providers to other businesses often stress customer results in the core industries they compete in. These customer successes show the depth of expertise in a given area. These success stories make services tangible to customers. Marketing strategies used to support this approach include the widespread use of video and interactive online materials to show the problems solved and results delivered with a service. The

Communication Management Plan Life Alive
Words: 1984 Length: 7 Document Type: Marketing Plan

Identify the designated spokesperson for Life Alive expansion program with the role of developing relationships with the target consumer population. Vehicle Target Description Purpose Frequency Owner Distribution Vehicle Internal/ External Comments Status Report All Stakeholders One page communication of the expansion plans, the progress and deliverables Weekly Heidi Email Internal Telephone All stakeholders Communication of meetings Daily Heidi telephone internal Face-to-face meetings All stakeholders Communication status reports, meetings for planning, implementing, evaluation, and monitoring On a fort night basis Heidi Face-to-face internal Mass media Consumers Communication of new products, food, and cafe locations daily Heidi Television, social media, company website, bill boards, word of

Kuiper Leda Supply Chain Defense
Words: 3070 Length: 9 Document Type: Thesis

falling into a functional rut. This is exemplified in the approach Kuiper Leda also takes with regard to optimizing lead times throughout the productions scheduling and fulfillment processes as well. In summary, Kuiper Leda has many of the foundational processes, systems and roles in place to enable an efficient demand-driven supply chain network (Barrett, 2007), including the ability to synchronize suppliers, inbound quality management and inspection, production scheduling, manufacturing, and

Effect of Forgiveness on Health
Words: 28998 Length: 105 Document Type: Thesis

Forgiveness on human health. In its simplest form, the purpose of the study is to evaluate human psychological stress that might constitute a risk factor for heart disease. Further, the study will also evaluate the impact of forgiveness on heart disease. However, such a simple dissertation clearly demands further definition. What, exactly, do we signify when we speak of heart disease? What is properly considered as forgiveness? What impact does

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now