Verified Document

Mcgregor Theory X And Y Douglas Mcgregor Term Paper

Mcgregor Theory X and Y Douglas McGregor came up with two contrasting theories in 1960 that he called Theory X and theory Y for lack of a more suitable title. These two theories have had a profound impact on management studies as they tend to focus on managerial approaches which are grounded in certain beliefs and attitude towards the employees.

These two theories should not be confused as being the two extremes of the same spectrum because they are inherently different as they focus on two different managerial styles that emerge from two different organizational structures and cultures. On the surface the differences are stark and clear and when we go beneath the surface, we can dig out the reasons for these differences.

Theory X is not very positive in nature. It tends to see employees as lazy beings who would want to avoid work every chance they get. This theory ignores the concept of self-actualization and self-motivation and instead tends to see employees as beings that need to be managed and controlled or else no work would get done. A manager who uses this...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

He would structure work in a way that would make it easier for employees to follow the directions and get the task done. Everything would be centralized and delegation of work would remain with the manager so no one else has a say in how work is distributed and structured.
In his classic piece on management "Human side of Enterprise," McGregor clearly explained what these two theories were about and how were they different and what are the beliefs that create such managerial practices. He says that in Theory X, management wants to control everyone because it believes that an average man would want to work "little as possible," he prefers not to take on responsibility and tends to be a follower in most situations. He is seen as "self-centered, indifferent to organizational needs" and basically "gullible."

Theory Y

Theory Y on the other hand suggests that man likes to engage in mental and physical activities that he can align with…

Sources used in this document:
This approach is preferred by McGregor while the conventional approach no longer works in the globalized environment today. It is not suitable for a workplace that is dispersed and no longer centralized. With people connecting with each other remotely and teams working in dispersed geographical locations, it is no longer possible to control every employee or use sticks to guide them I the right direction. Instead this is the time when it is best to hire the most motivated employees, give them directions and believe in their capabilities to carry out the task independently. Thus Theory Y is more popular in organizations today than Theory X

REFERENCE

McGregor, Douglas. Human side of Enterprise. Retrieved online April 11th 2011 from
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now