Conflict Theory in Film
Introduction
Conflict theory is a sociological perspective that emphasizes the role of power and inequality in shaping social relations and structures. As Ritzer (2011) points out, conflict theory was an attempt to bridge the gap between Marxism and sociological theoryand it served as a response to the structural functionalism (p. 215). While there are similarities between conflict theory and structural functionalism, the former is a kind of inversion of the latter, or as Ritzer (2011) puts it, a kind of structural functionalism turned on its head (p. 265). According to conflict theory, society is divided into different groups with competing interests, and conflicts arise from the unequal distribution of resources and power (Tajfel & Turner, 2006). Those with power and influence seek to marginalize and oppress those without power; the goal of those with power is to maintain power; the goal of those without power is to push back and take power. To put it simply, society, interpreted through this lens, is seen as a game of tug of war, with a dominant power and an underdog at odds. (In this sense, conflict theory could be described as a precursor to game theory). Ultimately, however, conflict theory posits that conflicts are not resolved through compromise or negotiation, but through struggle and often through violence. Real world examples could range from the American Revolutionary War, the Civil War, the Civil Rights Movement, and so on. This paper will use conflict theory to examine the film Fight Club and show how the theory applies.
The Film
In the movie Fight Club, there are many examples of conflict theory in action. The main character, played by Edward Norton, is a nameless young man who is disillusioned with his life and his job. He suffers considerably as he is unable to sleep, feels emotionally disconnected from the world, lives an unfulfilling life working a corporate job that devalues human life and cynically puts profits before people. He unconsciously or instinctively feels that he is trapped in a society that values material possessions and conformity over individuality and freedom (and although he cannot express this feeling in words at the outset of the film, it does become more apparent to him as time goes on). Through his involvement with his foil/alter-ego Tyler Durden (played by Brad Pitt), the nameless hero (nicknamed Jack in the credits) becomes part of a group of men (the titular fight club) who end up violently rejecting the norms and values of the elitist, corporatist consumer culture and seek to establish a new society based on their own values. In one sense, they believe they are reclaiming their masculinity in a society that promotes emasculation. In another sense, they are lashing out against their perceived oppressors. And in still yet another sense they are face a conflict within themselves that is also bigger than themselves: as Durden remarks at one point, Our great wars a spiritual war (Fincher, 1999).
Essentially, however, at the heart of the conflict in Fight Club is the tension between the haves and have-nots. The fight club grows across the nation, with underground clubs being spawned at bars and other places in city after city as the hero of the film literally takes flight after flight to promote his vision for the future of working class men everywhere. The members of this growing club are mostly working-class men who feel oppressed by the wealthy elite. They see the consumer culture as a tool used by the rich to control the masses and maintain their power. By rejecting consumerism and embracing violence, they hope to create a new society in which everyone is equal and free. Durden preaches anti-consumerist messages to the members of the club: You are not your khaki pants. You are not special. You are the all-singing, all-dancing crap of the world (Fincher, 1999). At another point in the film, the nameless narrator blackmails his corporate boss into allowing him to work remotely in perpetuity by keeping silent about all the nasty secrets he has learned over the course of his tenure at...
…members of Fight Club are predominantly working-class men who are rebelling against the middle-class values and lifestyle that they see as oppressive and restrictive. Tyler represents a figure of resistance against the dominant ideology of consumerism and conformity, and his creation of Fight Club is a way of reclaiming power and control for the working class.The basic assumptions of conflict theory are that society is characterized by conflict, domination, and exploitation, and that social change occurs through the struggle between different groups for control over resources and power. The underlying argument of conflict theory is that social inequality and power imbalances are inherent features of society, and that they can only be addressed through radical social change (Ritzer, 2011).
Through the lens of conflict theory, Fight Club can be seen as a critique of the dominant ideology of consumerism and conformity, and as a rebellion against the social order that perpetuates social inequality and power imbalances. The members of Fight Club are united in their frustration and anger at the system that has denied them opportunities and relegated them to the margins of society. Tyler represents a figure of resistance against the dominant ideology of consumerism and conformity, and his creation of Fight Club is a way of reclaiming power and control for the working class.
In conclusion, Fight Club can be analyzed through the lens of conflict theory, which emphasizes the role of power and inequality in shaping social relations and structures. The movie portrays a world in which the struggle for power and equality can become violent and destructive, and it raises important questions about the nature of social conflict and the role of violence in bringing about social change. Applying conflict theory to the film Fight Club provides a deeper understanding of the social and cultural forces that shape the characters and their actions. It highlights the role of power, social inequality, and class struggle in shaping social relations, and emphasizes the need for radical social change in order to address the inherent inequalities and imbalances of power that…
References
Fincher, D. (1999). Fight club. 20th Century Fox.
Ritzer, G. (2011). Sociological theory. McGraw-Hill.
Tajfel, H., & Turner, J. C. (2004). The social identity theory of intergroup behavior. In Politicalpsychology (pp. 276-293). Psychology Press.
He is just as surreal as Palahniuk's Tyler Durden, and yet he is not freeing any hero from consumerist enslavement but -- on the other hand -- burying the reader behind a false and deluded masculine mythology -- namely, that a masculine hero is virile not because he "knows himself" and seeks virtue but because he knows how to drive fast cars, win at cards, be physically fit and
Fight Club The 1999 feature movie, Fight Club, directed by David Fincher and starring Brad Pitt and Edward Norton seemed as if the entire film was dedicated to the phenomenon of antisocial behavior. This exploration into the mind of an apparently normal man demonstrated the significance and the trials of an individual dealing with the pressures of society. The purpose of this essay is to explain antisocial behavior as it is
It is also important to note that major offenses within the fight club are punished through castration, as if to imply that the punished person is no longer a man and therefore no longer worthy of being part of the violent organization. The roles of women in Fight Club are extremely limited. Marla Singer is the only female character in the film. She shares qualities that are present in "Durden,"
Project Mayhem on the other hand focuses outwardly towards society, rather than the members of the organization. The secrecy of Project Mayhem has evolved to being a secret even from its own members, and particularly from the protagonist, suggested by its first and repeated rule "You do not ask questions." This also suggests that Project Mayhem is a far more sinister entity than its predecessor, in that the rules no
They lived in a derelict building with the other white males they recruited -- the army they recruited. They created their own world where everything was masculine and they plotted against the capitalists in order to redefine their masculinity. They continued to engage in violent acts which grew more and more destructive. Through these, they were able to gain back their power, the power they have lost through the
Fight Club" and the creation of a false urban masculinity in cinematic and real life One of the most interesting aspects of the narrative art is seen in the unpredictable ways in which individuals are apt to embrace filmic narration and cinematic narrative techniques and to transfer them into the narrative texture of their own lives. Also reflected in this phenomenon is the fact that viewers can develop ways of
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now