Verified Document

Market Effects Of Immigrant Labor Case Study

Remaining workers will get jobs at higher than equilibrium wage, the Supply curve shifts to the left, and wage and output stabilize until something else changes like input cost or legislation. Were firms able to hire workers at less than minimum wage, say like in Figure 4, where the cost of paying illegals including the enforcement cost results in lower demand for legal minimum wage workers, the result would be a total average cost between the two supply lines, increased outcome for the firm, at less than average minimum wage cost. The new Alabama law seems to attempt to drive off the black line "illegals" by mandating stiffer enforcement for services and privileges like business or auto licenses, Rawls (2011) explains. This creates an interesting distribution of costs if firms derive profit, but the cost of enforcement is being pushed onto others not employing illegals. If the black line in Figure 4 were closer to the gray "Legals" labor supply, there would be less incentive for firms to cheat. If the "Legals" labor supply was any higher to the left, i.e. wages were higher than minimum, and there were illegal workers, the result would be lower average wage for all of them but unemployment for the legal workers. Raising the cost of the black line in Figure 4 to the level of the gray line would get rid of any incentive to hire undocumented workers but instead Alabama has chosen to increase the burden of enforcement outside the firm. The result is a direct subsidy by all other businesses who want to get a license, or individuals who want to license a car (cutting into auto sales and thus theoretically raising price there), with that cost given directly to the owners of firms who hire illegal workers, in theory. The firms who break the law profit at the expense of the rest of the society, and deliver higher profits to their owners drawn off from all neighboring...

These workers lower the average cost of labor like the illegals do but without the additional cost of enforcement for other services and employers, if they are not allowed to consume those services without being a legal resident. Nor would these workers compete for longer term investments like homes or college loans, if they are not legal residents. These workers would directly compete for jobs with residents except that if their employing firms would not locate to Alabama given the existing labor costs, which seems to be a possible implication from the article, the result would be less demand by these employers for other inputs, goods and services. The deeper solution not mentioned in the article would be to get rid of the federal minimum wage, in which case Alabama residents could work for the original, below-minimum equilibrium wage, which would be lowered even still by the presence of illegal and legal nonresident workers. This would eliminate deadweight loss but would tend to deflate the entire local economy if workers had less earnings to spend on consumption goods.
Why there was any embarassment over asking guest workers for their proof of residence remains unexplained as well. If the new law is being enforced uniformly, then "everyday transactions" will entail this type of scrutiny for everyone. There should be no outcry about the state's Civil Rights history unless the laws are being enforced inconsistently.

References

Rawls,…

Sources used in this document:
References

Rawls, P. (2011). Ala. GOP leaders have 2nd thoughts on immigration. The Associated Press, 8

Dec. 2011. Financial News, Bloomberg Businessweek Retrieved from http://www.businessweek.com/ap/financialnews/D9RGJL8G1.htm
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Labor Unions in America: A Response to
Words: 1333 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Labor Unions in America: A response to Hard Work by Rick Fantasia and Kim Voss. According to the authors, why have labor unions struggled in the U.S. How does their explanation resonate with major contemporary perspectives in the field of social movements? What do the authors have to say in regard to the possibilities and limits of labor union revitalization in the U.S. How does their view resonate with the major

Labor Economics Population, Participation Rates,
Words: 2528 Length: 9 Document Type: Research Proposal

Source: McDonnel, B.M., Chapter 5, p. 130 Short-Run Demand for Labor: The Perfectly Competitive Seller Under the conditions imposed by the perfect seller, meaning that the market is characterized by perfect competition, the marginal revenue product equals the value of the marginal product. This then means that the labor supplies decreases. The situation is best revealed by the chart below, which presents how the VMP and MRP curves, with their decreasing marginal

Immigrants: Economic Impact on the
Words: 4771 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

During the years immigrants have proven a great talent in exact sciences and professions, i.e. information technology and engineering. They are hard working and more serious and manage to get ahead of the students born in the United States. Moreover, these are also the most important fields of business where brain-drain is mostly applied. Whole American IT companies function almost entirely on employees that have not been born in the

Effects of Immigrants on the UK Economy
Words: 1095 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Migration, Employment and UK Economy Point 1: Perception and Reality do not always align Duffy and Frere-Smith (2013) published their report on perception versus reality where immigration\'s impact on the UK labour market are concerned. The report highlighted several gaps between perception and reality, such as the composition of immigrants being largely asylum-seekers (most are students), and the fact that concerns about immigration have been rising recently. They also highlight that concerns

Effects of Kasp
Words: 6179 Length: 20 Document Type: Research Paper

Saudi For most of its existence, Saudi Arabia's economy has been driven by revenues from its massive oil fields. While this has allowed the country to have a healthy balance sheet, it has also discouraged investment in other areas. Other countries in the region have begun to realize that having an oil-dependent economy is not sustainable in the long run. Nations with burgeoning populations and limited resources tend to be unsustainable.

Labor Relations What Changes Are Needed for
Words: 3428 Length: 12 Document Type: Essay

Labor Relations What changes are needed for unions to maintain support from their membership, the community, and the employers? In order to maintain support from their membership, the community, and the employers, unions have decided to change the dynamics of organizing by changing the environment and conditions where organizing occurs. They have become conversant with the idea that when the employers decide to use the entire 'arsenal' at their disposal, it becomes

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now