Verified Document

Macro Politics Term Paper

¶ … Voting to Violence, Jack Snyder starkly poses some of the most vexing questions for foreign policy analysts during the 1990's. Why was this decade, despite the collapse of the totalitarian system of communism and an overall greater global potential for democratic involvement, marked by a worldwide increase in ethnic conflict and hatred in Europe and across the larger world? Why did this "the process of democratization" become seemingly "one of its own worst enemies," because of its populist nature of the democratic politics that seemed to point towards peace and freedom, rather than conflict. Why has the promise of democracy leading to a more stable worldwide peace seemingly inevitably become "clouded with the danger of war?" (Snyder 2000: 21)

In another section of Snyder's book, the author states that "the transition to democratic politics is meanwhile [still] creating fertile conditions for nationalism and ethnic conflict, which not only raises the costs of the transition but may also redirect popular participation into a lengthy antidemocratic detour." It has proved difficult for "advanced civic democracies," the writer Robert Dahl's term for successful and peaceful nations, to evolve from many new nations, even nations espousing democratic ideals, when those nations have arisen out of ethnic self-identification. (Dahl 2000) Snyder and Dahl's analysis force one to ask which conditions and characteristics of a representative democracy in a nation moving towards a new system of government are most and least likely to facilitate the stable, peaceful governance of a diverse political community, and why?

One of, though certainly not the only reason, for the escalation of ethnic conflict during the 1990's was that the regions had long been hotbeds of ethnic unrest. The Balkan region was famously known as the 'powder keg' of Europe before the onset of World War I. After the end of World War I, according to the principles of national self-determination that had become, in Woodrow Wilson's mind, inextricably linked with the principles of democracy, the map of Europe was redrawn. The old Empires were indeed carved up, but this privileged some ethnic groups...

During World War II, old ethnic rivalries, such as those between the Serbs and the Croats, the former whom were persecuted by the Nazis, the latter of whom became allied with German infiltrating powers because of a perceived cultural bond, were again triggered. After World War II, these ethnic ties were smothered because of the officially nationalist (really pro-Russian) communist ideology of the U.S.S.R. However, with the dissolution of the U.S.S.R., opposition to Russian ethnocentrism, communist economic inefficiency, and outright political repression became articulated through ethnic self-identification rather than through an advocacy of liberal rights and freedoms.
For instance, in the former USSR Republic of Estonia, the teaching of the native language of the region became one of the rallying cries of those who wished to seek more democratic local control of their nation, and finally to separate from the region. Because such ethnically-based policies were often the way these nations managed to define themselves as free of Soviet-based control, and because these policies were popular and easily transmutable on a grass-roots level, ethnic identity became the way one's democratic, i.e. non-Soviet identity was expressed.

The problem with an ethnic form of democracy, however, is that unlike a rights-based form of democracy, which in the democratic ideal officially considers all citizens merely as equal individuals, all possessing certain inalienable freedoms that cannot be impinged upon by the government, ethnic democracy is far more populist. It is more democratic in some respects, in that policies are defined by majority rule. In other words, if the majority of individuals in, for instance, Latvian, wish to speak Latvian and have their children taught in Latvian in school, why not make this the national language and not Russian? This may seem superficially sensible. However, by constructing a democratic identity within the region as inextricably linked with one's status as a Latvian, the very nature of one's identity as a good citizen becomes how Latvian one is, and also how…

Sources used in this document:
However, this valuation of the individual must be for all individuals for this world democratic peace to ensue. In other words, new democracies must be rights-based rather than purely populist and ethnically based, otherwise an 'us vs. them' ethnic ideology will lead to warfare. In an ethnic democracy, the security of one's ethnic state becomes based in the stamping out of all ethnic groups, groups who were historically, previously opposed to one's own ethnic identity. What is called upon is not a naive liberal faith in the value of a democracy, but an intelligent understanding of the complications of democracy, a belief in a rights-based system with a questioning eye upon simple ethnic majority populism. (Snyder 2000: 16-17)

Snyder and Dahl's analysis is so cogent because their words explain why democracy does not automatically produce a "democratic peace," only a rights-based "civic democracy" as distinguished from an "ethnic democracy" can do so. (Snyder 2000: 353) In contrast, ethnic democracies undermine a democratic peace because they "deactivate the mechanisms that keep relations between democracies peaceful," in other words for ethnically-based democratic movements and states, the individual's rights is only valued if that individual is part of a specific ethnic frame of reference. Rather than civic or rights-based and individualistic liberal democracies, when democracies evolve in an ethnic-based conflict, they are not more likely to be at peace with one another. Instead, contending rival ethnic democracies are more likely to be at war with one another, reviving ancient hatreds. They are additionally more likely to have a perceived stake in the ethnic conflicts of wars outside their borders.

Synder and Dahl's analysis should not be read as a simply validation of the United States liberal political system, after all the U.S. is hardly free of inter-ethnic conflicts of its own. Instead, their books are intended as warnings to makers of United States policy who may have been too quick in the past to support movements simply because they are democratic, without looking into the specific ethnic tensions of various regions and regional movements. Only through a specific understanding of different country's ancient histories, histories that often stretch far back beyond that of the United State's own conception, can a truly democratic and peaceful world be orchestrated by the stable democracies of the current world order.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Macro Analytical Approaches of Marx and Durkheim
Words: 1458 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Macro analytical approaches of Marx and Durkheim regarding democratic republics, freedom, & equality This paper looks at the question on how the macro analytical approaches that were discussed by Marx and Durkheim are applied to the attitudes of freedom and democratic republics and how it affects the equality of society. Bibliography cites four sources How might the macro-analytical theories advanced by Marx and Durkheim help us understand the causes and consequences of

Macro and Micro Environment in Management
Words: 1940 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Macro and Micro Environment in Management Planning is an important function of management. It is an act of formulating a program for a definitive course of action. The management defines a goal and puts forward its strategies to accomplish the objectives defined. STEPS IN THE PLANNING PROCESS For an organization to begin its planning, it needs to evaluate and assess whether it is ready. An organization need to realize where it is standing

Politics As Was Expected, the Republicans Took
Words: 2454 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Politics As was expected, the Republicans took the House and Senate in the 2014 mid-term elections, shifting the balance of power in the United States government. The election was viewed by many as a referendum on President Obama's policies. The President said it (Martosko, 2014), conservative talking heads said it (Krauthammer, 2014), and voters in exit polls said as much, too (Raedle, 2014). This argument makes for fine political rhetoric, this

Micro and Macro Global Analysis
Words: 774 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

CNN, referring to the decision by the Russian Federation to call to Moscow its ambassador for NATO, for consultations (http://edition.cnn.com/2014/04/03/world/europe/ukraine-crisis/). This comes as a measure against rising tensions, following Russia's actions in Ukraine and it decision to annex Crimea. Before starting a discussion as to how a strong governing structure would have handled a situation such as the one in Ukraine, a first comment needs to be made about the

International Competitiveness, Politics and Policy
Words: 1915 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

In my opinion, there is no excuse for them not accomplishing the objectives they have been created to attain. 6. Regarding the economic situation and the context of the current financial and economic crises, things are not as clear as they are about environmental issues. In my opinion, the policies that must be implemented in the following period of time should take into consideration economic stagnation, and not economic evolution. The

Electoral Politics As Detailed Quite Eloquently in
Words: 1039 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Electoral Politics As detailed quite eloquently in Chapter 15 of Haywood's text, having political power is not simply getting one's way in a crude and overt manner, like passing or pushing a bill through congress. Rather, power also involves the task of agenda-setting itself, putting an idea upon the national platform of discourse. The author additionally cites Bacharatz and Baratz as critical in defining not simply making yes or no the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now