Verified Document

Loop High Rise Fire Term Paper

Fire Safety Six people died and several more were severely injured in the 2003 Chicago Loop high rise fire, at the Cook County Administrative Building. Around 2,500 government employees work in the building, which was built in the 1960s and bought by the county in 1996. Officials now believe that many of the fire's casualties could have been prevented had the building fire safety codes been up-to-date and had proper protocols for evacuation been followed by the Chicago Fire Department. Although the building did have an official fire evacuation plan, it was not followed, and although evacuation drills were conducted four times a year, the evacuation procedure was chaotic and disorganized. Conflicts of interest related to political ties between the mayor's office and the building management company may be partially responsible for the building's inadequate safety features such as its lack of a sprinkler system. In addition to the building's safety flaws, miscommunication between building management and the fire department regarding evacuation procedure protocol was a primary cause for the fiasco.

The main problems with the building's safety features include the automatic locking of stairwell doors with no override system; the lack of pressurized stairwells; and the lack of a sprinkler system. The stairwell doors are designed to lock from the inside to prevent intruders. However, in the case of a fire, the automatic locks become a serious hazard preventing persons trapped inside to find safety. Buildings with similar security locks should be installed with a remote override system. All six of the building's casualties were persons trapped in the stairwell.

The lack of pressurized stairwells also contributed to the accumulation of smoke within the stairwells causing many of the victims' deaths and smoke inhalation injuries. A pressurized system would have allowed for the trigger of ventilation systems that would also have whisked smoke away from the area...

Without the pressurization system in place, smoke billows up through the stairwells, suffocating all in its path. In the future, citywide fire safety codes should require for pressurization systems in stairwells as well as for lock override systems.
When the building was renovated, city officials did not demand that a sprinkler system be installed in the building. A sprinkler system may have saved lives and may have minimized smoke-related injuries and deaths. The lack of a sprinkler system proved to be a major flaw in the building's 1996 renovation plans. There is speculation as to whether the lack of a sprinkler system was partly due to the political tie between the building management and real estate development companies and the county office, which waved the requirements for the sprinkler system due to the age of the building. The city has issued contradictory safety regulations for buildings, giving more leeway to buildings built before 1975. Although installing sprinkler systems is initially costly, they save lives: no deaths have been reported in buildings with sprinkler systems in place. Therefore, upgrades to a building's safety codes are ultimately cost-effective.

Moreover, there is some question as to whether the building's fire alarm system was adequate. The building was also not equipped with heat sensors or other more sophisticated alarm systems. No employee reported hearing an alarm, only announcements over the building's public address system. The announcements that were given were inconsistent, not given according to proper protocols issued either by the building's own safety code or by the local fire department. When victims trapped in the stairwells phoned emergency 911, they were given a range of contradictory advice and information. The fire fighters should have taken over the public address system in order to provide those trapped inside with clear, sensible evacuation advice.

The problems related to…

Sources used in this document:
Fire safety officials arrived in good time, but even their evacuation and fire fighting protocols were not followed. For example, Captain Michael Gubricky elected to fight the fire from the southeast stairwell, which was the building's smoke tower. The smoke tower is in place mainly to offer an evacuation route because of the increased ventilation. The Captain's decision was unwarranted, given that the smoke tower is supposed to be used as an evacuation route and only as a last resort for fighting the fire. Fighting the fire from the smoke tower was not only dangerous, it diverted fire fighting attention that needed to be given to the persons trapped in the building's other stairwells. Some of the victims reported that firefighters did not listen when they were told that people were trapped in other stairwells. Firefighters failed to search the southeast stairwell, not believing that anyone was trapped there. In general, evacuation procedures were chaotic.

The role of fire safety codes is to provide a clear-cut set of rules and guidelines in case of emergencies such as this. The fire safety code becomes irrelevant if it is not followed or when its guidelines conflict with the procedures practiced by the fire department. For example, only those persons located dangerously close to the fire should have been evacuated in this case; in the future, no orders should be given for a full evacuation unless the fire department itself orders one. Building tenants should known which stairwell is the smoke tower.

Furthermore, building fire safety codes should reflect the local precinct's protocols for safety and evacuation. The security officers in the building should be thoroughly briefed on the proper protocol. Drills should be regular and consistent as well. Furthermore, the fire department should make it a priority to take over the building's public address system so that evacuation orders are clear too. Fire safety officials should work with building managers regularly to ensure that codes are met, that the building is safe, and that security officers and tenants alike are familiar with the basics of fire safety. The city of Chicago and all other cities should consider diverting funds to the renovation of pre-1975 buildings. Above all there is no excuse for the lack of override system for the stairwell doors, one feature that could have alone prevented the six deaths.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Shell and Heat Tube Exchangers:
Words: 6360 Length: 25 Document Type: Research Paper

(Wolverine Tube Heat Transfer Data Book, 2009) Basic components of Shell and Tube Heat Exchangers include the following basic components although there is a plethora of existing specific features used in design of the Shell and Heat Tube Exchanger. The components specifically are: (1) Tubes -- "...the basic component of the shell and tube exchanger, providing the heat transfer surface between one fluid flowing inside the tube and the other fluid

Management and Decision Sciences From
Words: 25680 Length: 90 Document Type: Thesis

76). As automation increasingly assumes the more mundane and routine aspects of work of all types, Drucker was visionary in his assessment of how decisions would be made in the years to come. "In the future," said Drucker, "it was possible that all employment would be managerial in nature, and we would then have progressed from a society of labor to a society of management" (Witzel, p. 76). The

Philosophy Induction
Words: 3486 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

Hume's Problem Of Induction David Hume is known as one of the foremost skeptics and humanists of his time, who exalted in mankind's ability to transform the world through science. Somewhat ironically, then, one of his most far-reaching philosophical contributions was to phrase the problem of induction which today is often thought to deny scientific knowledge. Just a couple chapters of a single book, Hume posed a question which has yet

Why Fossil Fuel Is Preferably to Nuclear Fuel
Words: 3705 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

Business Nuclear power, under current conditions, is characterized by much lower regular emissions compared to energy from fossil fuel burning. But, it poses its own unique hazards, of which the most notable is risk of industrial accidents (e.g. Chernobyl) that have acute, long-term repercussions over huge areas. There are also security risks presented by vast inventories of materials that have the potential of being utilized as nuclear weapons; fossil fuels pose

Gangsters
Words: 9610 Length: 30 Document Type: Term Paper

The 1990s also saw innovative interpretation of law enforcement's role in the perpetuation of organized crime. One of the most notable examples is L.A. Confidential (1997), in which corruption has reached so deep into the Los Angeles police department that two seemingly unrelated criminal investigations both lead to the police chief. The genre also proved its adaptability and continued appeal with Heat (1995) and Carlito's Way (1993); both films starred

Water Legislation Origins of Environmental
Words: 11427 Length: 37 Document Type: Dissertation

The Leblanc alkali production processes were especially pernicious, but they followed along the lines of previous industrial processes. In other words, the first British environmental legislation was a response not so much to a qualitative change in industrial processes and their environmental impact but more to a quantitative increase in sources of pollution that had up to that point been (if only barely) tolerable. Legislation Arising From Public Anger At the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now