Verified Document

Logistics Reversed Essay

Reverse Logistics There were no case studies presented in Chapter 3. The author cites a few, and provides one- or two-sentence descriptions, but nowhere in Chapter 3 does the author illustrate a complete case study from which conclusions about reverse logistics methodology can be drawn. Instead, Chapter 3 was a review of case studies, wherein the author utilized studies found in academic journals, rejecting what is actually being done by people with money in the game in reverse logistics. This methodology has its merits -- the author is correct that academic case studies will follow a fairly similar format that is reliable and theoretically free from bias. The author also found that academic case studies are sufficient in number to draw conclusions. For example, the author cited under IT for reverse logistics four case studies for "customer," two for "manufacturing" and three for "distribution." While I disagree that it makes sense to rule out real world case studies, on the obvious premise that reverse logistics is a real world field, not a hypothetical one, the author appears to have gathered enough data from the available academic case studies to make some conclusions about reverse logistics.

This creates some problems when attempting to evaluate a case study. For example, on p.100, under Section 3.7.1, the author notes a case study on Canada Post by Duhaime, but there is only a single sentence of material, describing the general situation. What we would need is to have information about what Canada Post is actually doing with respect to this situation, in order to evaluate how well Canada Post is performing its reverse logistics....

The author does not provide this.
Where this creates issue is that the author has not provided any insight or knowledge in their paper, at least through the first three chapters. Given the length of the paper, there is hope yet. But mentioning that case studies exist adds nothing to the understanding of reverse logistics -- value would be added by selecting only a small handful of case studies, providing full information walking the reader from start to finish, and then noting how this case study contributes to the overall body of knowledge. Instead, the author has provided an annotated bibliography, without any further analysis of the case study material, how such material contributes to the field of study, or what can be learned by a student by understanding the scenario that the case study presents.

The author has in previous chapters outlined a basic methodological framework for understanding reverse logistics cases. This should have been applied to the cases by the author. It is possible that further in the tome this would have occurred. But the instructions posit that there are cases in Chapter 3, and this is incorrect. This makes it rather difficult to provide an analysis of a case, with there not being a case to begin with. The irony here is that the author specifically cites that cases are better than "mere examples" (p.81), because they provide more detail. While this is true, the author then name-drops 60 cases, providing no real detail on any of them.

Now, should a case study have been provided, it would have been possible to analyze the methodology used in the case study. Arguably, the…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Logistics and Globalization: Logistics
Words: 1929 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Logistics: Logistics and Globalization Fierce competition has driven business entities to focus and invest in logistics networks, also referred to as supply chains. Advancement in transportation and telecommunication technologies has played a crucial role in propelling this growth right from the tactical, through to the operational level. A logistics network is made up of retail outlets, warehouses, suppliers, raw materials, work-in-progress stock, finished products, and distribution centers. To this end, logistics

Reverse Logistics and Software Development
Words: 616 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Technology in Reverse Logistics Reverse logistics has developed to become one of the most important elements in supply chain management because of its benefits. As a result, reverse logistics has become a concept and process that manufacturers and retailers cannot ignore. Given the advantages of reverse logistics in the supply chain, manufacturers and retailers have enhanced investments in technology to enhance their reverse logistics systems. These huge investments in technology to

Link Between Secondary Markets and Reverse Logistics
Words: 2246 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Reverse Logistics Trends and Practices Reverse logistics is a concept that has attracted considerable attention in the recent past because of the new interest in its processes. The increased interests in reverse logistics occur regardless of the little information regarding the size and extent of reverse logistics processes and activities. As the interests on reverse logistics have grown, the concept and its processes have been characterized by the emergence of new

How Is Reverse Logistics Important in the Food and Beverage Industry...
Words: 1293 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Reverse Logistics LOGISTICS The implementation of sustainable rules and regulations as well as constraints in the markets across the world, have compelled international industries, in this case, the food and beverage industry, to establish reverse logistics, which is the backflow management of the supply chain system. Reverse logistics encompasses the waste management of products and merchandises in the backward supply chain. There has been a gap or limitation in research studies on

Logistics Causes of Logistics Problems Companies Like
Words: 1534 Length: 5 Document Type: Case Study

Logistics Causes of Logistics Problems Companies like Bradstar are not alone; many companies today experience logistics complications, the causes of which include growing supply chains, increasing demand for the products Bradstar provides to their customers, and an inefficient delivery system. Bradstar provides rush delivery which is not organized in a fashion that provides customers with guaranteed product delivery. There is no system of checks in balances in place to ensure customers get

Logistics Supply Chain Management Scm :
Words: 4395 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

From the year 1991, environmental considerations have come to be an important standard with regard to Nestle's renovation and innovation of packages and that of the packaging materials. Reduction with regard to the amount of packages and packaging materials which are required for a product and at the same time making conditions for protecting safety and quality is an ongoing important primary objective and priority. Nestle's 'No Waste at Work'

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now