Verified Document

Logical Mcinery, D.Q. 2005 . Being Book Review

Check our facts -- yes, it takes time, and one must rely on a basic understanding of sourcing (askyahoo.com vs. Questia research, for instance); understand your source material (bias, their own issues); what words are being used and why; how reasonable and effective is the interpretation? So, what does all that "homework do?" Well, according to McInerny, it "prepares" the mind for logic. Once the mind is ready, it is now time to put the principles into the logical matrix: relevancy, argumentation, rhetoric, comparisons, and reasoning. By utilizing this matrix, one avoids the trap of illogical thinking, and the premise that one needs someone "external" to provide answers to events, interpretations, and even the answer, to current and past events. It is our own, individual responsibility, to understand our world, and while the process may not be as quick as a "sound bite," it is certainly more satisfying.

Finally, by analyzing the patterns of illogical thinking, we can avoid being led down the "rosy" path and make the types of decisions so vital in a modern democracy. One very entertaining, yet poignant example, is the preponderance of using "so-called" experts to help us understand our world, what medicines to take, what candidates to support, even what food to eat. What do movie stars, with the exception of the dialog their screenwriters provide, know about arthritis prevention, diabetes, pain relief, international relations, or the newest bill before Congress. Imagine, if you will, that rather than Sally Field espousing the benefits of osteoporosis drug "Boniva," a professor of osteology from a major university talked about the long-term benefits of the drug in clinical trials. Would more people rush out and "ask their doctor" about Boniva?

That being said, while it is important that the bar be raised in school, the workplace, and indeed the populace regarding understanding how to form and analyze an argument, it is unrealistic to posit that everyone should analyze everything...

There are important distinctions -- disbelieving all your coworkers in favor of critiquing their argument is neither appropriate nor realistic. We can all appreciate Professor McInerny's wonderful vocabulary and turn of a phrase, but there are times for graphic novels just as there are times for philosophical diatribes. There are times to discuss our daily lives, and times to debate existential topics. but, if we want to hone and improve our language skills, attention to detail, logic, and ability to critically analyze what we read or hear -- this is a great guide. "It is impossible to have clear communication without clear thinking? How can I give you a clear idea of something if it is not first clear in my mind?" (14). Similarly, "there are argument that are comically inept and therefore deserving of laughter. But even in those cases it is better, rather than dismissing an argument with easy ridicule, to take the time to show how and why it fails as an argument" (123).
Thus, can one ever be content ever again with watching the nightly news? Can one ever listen to a political speech again without asking, "but what about?" -- McInerny doesn't promise that reading his book will provide instant gratification or happiness -- all he promises is that adopting some of the principles of logic, one will have a more robust understanding of the world, how it works, and whether or not we are receiving a reasonable semblance of truth from our disparate sources.

REFERENCES

"Most Young People Entering the U.S. Workforce Lack Critical Skills Essential

For Success." (October 2, 2006). Corporate Voices. Cited in:

http://www.cvworkingfamilies.org/node/153

"Why Does the World Get American Movies but America Doesn't Watch Their

Movies?" (2009). USA Information -- Promotion and News Center. Cited in:

http://us.promo.web.id/why-does-the-world-get-american-movies-but-america-doesnt-watch-other-countries-movie.htm

Sources used in this document:
REFERENCES

"Most Young People Entering the U.S. Workforce Lack Critical Skills Essential

For Success." (October 2, 2006). Corporate Voices. Cited in:

http://www.cvworkingfamilies.org/node/153

"Why Does the World Get American Movies but America Doesn't Watch Their
http://us.promo.web.id/why-does-the-world-get-american-movies-but-america-doesnt-watch-other-countries-movie.htm
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Allegory of the Cave
Words: 1128 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Allegory of the Cave: Plato: Truth and Art Allegory of the cave is one of the most interesting, enlightening and insightful example given by Plato in his book The Republic to explain such vague concepts as knowledge and truth. It appears in form of dialogues between Socrates and Glaucon and they touch upon various important concepts in connection with learning and discovery. Two very vital subjects discussed are art and truth.

Allegory of the Cave Can Be Summed
Words: 1141 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Allegory of the cave can be summed up in one single sentence. It symbolizes the place of perceptions in the pursuit of knowledge. Indeed, in a preamble to the actual relating of the allegory, Plato is involved in a discussion as to who can be considered a true philosophy. The discussion meanders around attempting to answer the following enigmas: Just because someone subscribes to a specific philosophy, does that make

Allegory of the Cave Plato's
Words: 993 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

The discrepancy between the ideal and the real and the difficulty of arriving at the truth through deduction and induction is something that everyone must grapple with who deals with the ethics of a profession, like accounting. "Prisoners may learn what a book is by their experience with shadows of books. But they would be mistaken if they thought that the word 'book' refers to something that any of them

Allegory of the Cave in
Words: 673 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

However, once the enchained individual is set free, we could assume that realizing his own potential could make him wiser than the person who originally helped him. Another interesting idea that Plato introduces through the allegory of the cave states that all of us can become "superior" through a process of training which evolves a lot of effort and dedication. I agree to the fact that all people can overcome

Allegory of the Cave by
Words: 1792 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Moreover, Bacon suggests that such false foundations, if passed in time, can only ruin the world. "The Four Idols" of Francis Bacon summarizes an observation of how humans form information in their minds; same subject discussed by Plato in his "The Allegory of the Cave." According to Bacon, there are things in wherein the truth is hard to bare, thus the human mind resorts to information that are available to

Allegory of the Cave Brings
Words: 1237 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

S. is on its way to chaos, anarchy and a national catastrophe. The pursuit of individual freedom without respect for authority will eventually lead to these consequences. What keeps U.S. strong and independent is that free enterprise and not the illusion of a contemporary democracy. A basic difficulty in American democracy is its attempt to mitigate all the aspects of negative human nature. Criminals are given equal rights as honorable

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now