Verified Document

Locke's Second Treatise Of Government Essay

"God gave the world to men in common" is a theme that supports the view that Locke would see property and something that should not be wasted, as waste deprives others. That survival is taken out of the equation tilts the moral balance towards Locke viewing much of the expropriation of land that occurs in South Florida as needless. There remains the question of spinoff benefits, and this is something that lies at the heart of much debate about land use today. While the proverbial Donald Trump may not need to expropriate that land in order to survive, there are going to be people who work on that land who do support themselves and their families. The landowner is not necessarily the beneficiary of that land's development. On the surface it seems self-evident that if jobs are created that the expropriation should be viewed as acceptable by Locke. However, it is worth considering that there are myriad ways to create jobs. The same development on a piece of vacant land in an area already developed would bring about the same benefits. Unlike in Locke's era, when land was directly connected to survival, modern day job creation often does not rely on development of any specific patch of land (mining industry excepted). Anything done on land in South Florida can be done just about anywhere in the region; expropriation from nature is not necessary. Additionally, even if the development never took place at all, anywhere, there are myriad ways of creating jobs. The development may be a low-hanging fruit that encourages developers and politicians to pursue it, but that does not mean it must be pursued or the future workers on that land will perish.

Thus, the merit of the development depends on its nature. In economics,...

The notion of perfect rationality is an assumption used to derive theories, and was never intended to be used outside of that context, but today we see it often misapplied to real world circumstances. Even if there is a high degree of rationality in market decisions, it is accepted that markets are correct in the long run, meaning that not every decision conveys an optimal allocation of resources, but that decisions will in the long run, over the course of years and thousands of decisions, be close to optimal.
Thus, it may well be that development reflects "the covetousness of the quarrelsome and the contentious." In the long-run, poor decisions will fail and good decisions will succeed. When the quarrelsome and contentious expropriate lands, they will sometimes do so for selfish reasons, or with bad ideas. While the market will, in the long run, weed out those ideas, this does not make a case for property development. Indeed, it makes the case against development, because bad ideas are waste of the type of which Locke would disapprove. Because the natural land cannot be returned to its original condition in the event that the development turns out to be a bad idea, Locke would at the very least want developers to be certain that their ideas are proven and rational before undertaking the expropriation. The merits of individual project ideas are up for debate, but it is worth knowing that in many cases developers no longer have an interest in the property by the time it is proven a failure.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

John Locke 'Second Treatise of
Words: 945 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

According to Locke man is born with a natural liberty that means he should be free from subordination to any "superior power on earth, and not to be under the will or legislative authority of man, but to have only the law of nature for his rule." (1632-1704) Man's liberty in society is such that should not be ruled by a legislative power but instead "by consent, in the commonwealth…what

Second Treatise of Government the
Words: 1158 Length: 4 Document Type: Journal

Marx's socialist concepts contributed a lot to the formation of socialist states. His ideas also led to the formation of labor unions and parties across the world. Karl Marx on Private Property and Communism Karl states that personal life and property rights have a connection. However, he denounces both and refers to them as bourgeois freedom. He claims that an individual that is not with the society solely works with his

Locke's Second Treatise of Government
Words: 1003 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Proposal

In addition, other just men may join in the attempt to destroy the unjust, while those on the unjust side -- who will not think of themselves as unjust and therefore will see that they have every right to defend themselves -- will then attempt to destroy their destroyers, as under the law of nature they have the right to defend themselves from destruction. Thus, men on both sides

Second Treatise of Government, by John Locke
Words: 1664 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Second Treatise of Government," by John Locke is a revolutionary philosophical work that directly opposed the idea of absolutism. Absolutism held that the best form of government was autocratic, and was based on both the belief in the Divine Right of Kings and the theory of natural law, as espoused by Thomas Hobbes in Leviathan. In the context of the absolutism of Louis XIV, and the political events surrounding Oliver

Locke and Property Locke's Second
Words: 1255 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

" Money can only be hoarded because it has no real use; it will not feed or cloth someone who is starving or cold. This implies that things like food and clothing, which have obvious and immediate intrinsic values, cannot be rightfully hoarded in most societies because this will cause injury to someone else. This places a severe limit on the power of money in Locke's construct; though it is deemed acceptable

Locke One of the Single
Words: 5073 Length: 19 Document Type: Term Paper

This body then has the right and duty, especially if elected to represent to build the laws and enforce the judgment of those laws, as a reflection of the will of the consensus. Locke, having developed a keen sense of a rather radical sense of the rights of the individual and the responsibility of the civil government began his work with the development of what it is that constructs the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now