Summary of Community Board Meeting
Introduction
Community boards are important forms of local governmentbut are they effective? The subject of this paper is Community Board 5. This paper examines three of this Boards community board sessions in Manhattan and then discusses them terms of issues, structure, participation, and effectiveness. Overall, it shows that the Board is involved in the democratic process but there are limitations to what it can achieve.
First Session
The first video I watched was of the PUBLIC HEARING and FULL BOARD Committee Meeting - Thursday Nov 9, 2023 on YouTube. The major topics and discussions of the meeting centered on asylum seekers in NYC and cannabis retailer permits. Camille Joseph, Chief of Staff to the Mayor, provided an update on asylum seekers in NYC, stating that over 13,000 asylum seekers have arrived, with a significant number in shelters. The board discussed various efforts to assist these individuals, including the establishment of legal clinics for asylum applications and work authorization. However, challenges such as the impact on the city's budget, hiring freezes, and strain on services were also highlighted. Strategies to aid asylum seekers, like case management, re-ticketing, and facilitating work authorization, were part of the conversation.
Public Concerns and Questions
The meeting opened up discussions around public concerns regarding the influx of asylum seekers. Questions were raised about their impact on Medicaid and the city's capacity to accommodate this new population. There were also concerns about the closure of hospitals and the growing need for more healthcare resources. The board and community members engaged in discussions about how the local community could support asylum seekers effectively.
Local Issues and Oppositions
Local issues, particularly regarding a liquor license application for Roadside Attraction on 47 West 20th Street, were a point of contention. Residents expressed strong opposition, citing concerns about noise, traffic, and the cumulative impact of having multiple liquor licenses in the area. Additionally, there was a discussion about the potential impact of a proposed off-Broadway show at the Limelight, focusing on issues related to noise and crowd management.
Cannabis Retailer Permits
The topic of cannabis retailer permits also garnered attention, with public comments focusing on their compliance with community guidelines. Concerns were raised about the proximity of these retailers to public places and parks, reflecting the community's apprehension about the integration of cannabis businesses into their neighborhoods.
Updates from Elected Officials and Representatives
The meeting also included updates from elected officials and their representatives. These updates covered a range of topics including public safety, healthcare initiatives, and upcoming community events. This segment provided insights into broader city initiatives and how they intersect with local community interests.
Observations and Analysis
Based on what was observed, it appears that the board is actively addressing significant issues like the influx of asylum seekers, balancing community needs with humanitarian responsibilities. There is a democratic process in place, with open discussions and public participation. Concerns about local issues like liquor licenses and cannabis retailer permits indicate active community engagement. The presence of elected officials' representatives shows integration with broader governmental processes. The meeting overall reflects a diverse range of topics, from immigration to local business concerns, indicating a multifaceted approach to community governance.
Constructive Criticism for the Board
The board is addressing major issues effectively, but there could be more focus on long-term solutions for recurring local concerns like liquor licenses and their impact on neighborhood quality of life. Plus, strategies for improving communication and collaboration with city agencies could further support the handling of complex issues like asylum seekers and healthcare resources.
Second Session
The second video I watched was of State Licenses and Permits Committee Meeting - Wednesday Nov 1, 2023 also on YouTube. This meeting focused mainly on cannabis retailer applications. The committee discussed the influx of cannabis retailer applications (around 75) and the challenges in reviewing them within a 30-day response period. They focused on time, place, and manner, using guidelines established by the Cannabis Task Force. Applications were categorized as either complying or not complying with guidelines based on proximity to schools, community facilities, houses of worship, parks, playgrounds, and residential...
…like asylum seekers and cannabis retailers indirectly touch on these dynamics, as they can impact diverse communities differently.Participation in Government and Democratization
One of the key strengths of the community board system is its ability to reflect a diverse range of opinions and needs. In a city as big as New York, communities consist of individuals from different backgrounds, each with their own needs and concerns. The community board is basically a melting pot for these varied viewpoints, and represents a forum where views can be expressed, debated, and considered. This is an inclusive approach helping so that decisions made at the local level are well-rounded and considerate of the multifaceted nature of the community.
However, the system is not without its challenges. Instances of NIMBY (Not In My Back Yard) attitudes can sometimes surface, where residents may oppose certain developments or changes within their neighborhood that they perceive as detrimental to their immediate environment, despite potential broader benefits. This attitude can lead to resistance against necessary developments or changes that are helpful for the city's overall growth and progress.
Despite these challenges, the community board system largely serves as a middle ground, and can balance local interests with bigger city needs. It plays a role in mediating between the immediate concerns of the local residents and the long-term strategies of the city. It is a balancing act, but one that is needed so that urban development and policy changes are both progressive and grounded in the realities and needs of the local communities.
Conclusion
The Community Board 5 meetings do show a commitment to addressing local issues while at the same time trying to consider broader implications. The process is not a simple one. There are enough challengestechnical, practical, social, and politicalto make it a daunting task. However, the Board appears to be striving to be inclusive and reflective of community needs. Is there room for improvement? Yes, there isbut overall, the Board is doing what is most likely its best to be a facilitator and a helpful role player…
Local Government and Tax Incentives Like federal and state governments, local governments offer tax incentives to businesses to help solve economic and/or environmental problems. Conduct an Internet search and find an example of a state or local government (perhaps your own) that offers an incentive to businesses and cite your resource(s). Describe the tax incentive you found, determine what economic problem(s) government is trying to solve by offering the incentive you
Local Government Around the world, different nations, which are enclosed by their own geographical boundaries, adhere to various different styles of government. Those styles may either be democratic or dictatorial. Within democratic styles of government, there are other different sub-styles such as direct democracies, representative democracies, bi cameral houses, unicameral houses etc. These governments are setup on both federal and provincial or state level along with a local government for
Florida state government is divided up into branches that each hold a precise and specific mandate. As with the federal government, Florida's state government consists of three branches -- the executive branch, the legislative branch, and the judicial branch. Each branch has its own special duties and responsibilities. Moreover, the state also has local government agencies that serve both general and special purposes (American Government, n.d.). This paper will discuss
Specifically, education is made accessible to all children by means of the public school system, which stretches across all states, cities and counties. Furthermore, the law requires all students to be enrolled in school once they reach a certain age, which could vary from state to state. The law does not allow any child to be prohibited from a school education (FatNewt, 2011). Although tertiary education is not free of charge,
II.Florida is a populated state that offers federal education programs, promotes equal education opportunity and under Section 1008.33 of Florida Statutes, offers State Board of Education that right to enforce public school improvement across the state via supports and interventions. There are also thirty early learning coalitions in Florida to provide early learning opportunities for students. The local government of Rhode Island recently implemented regulations to safeguard transgender students (RI,
Citizen trust in Local government performance in Botswana_ Meaning and content of trust has kept changing because of the changing points of reference. Trust in government used to refer to the belief that the government will not become autocratic (Bouckaert & de Walle, 2003). It currently refers to down to earth matters such as reliability of service delivery or the expectation that policy will correspond to an individual's wishes (Hofstede, 1980).
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now