Verified Document

Library Filters Term Paper

Library Filters Why Libraries Must Not Use Software Filters to Censor Speech: One Person's Hate is Another Person's Political Philosophy

The French 17th century freethinking philosopher Voltaire said one of the most famous quotations in regards to the freedom of speech. He said that he would, though he disagreed with every word out of his colleague's mouth, defend to the death the man's right to say such terrible things. Perhaps the 21st definition of Voltaire's remark might be, 'though I disagree with every word upon you pet causes' local URL, I will defend to the death your right to point and click to this website on the Internet, lest my own right be similarly threatened.'

Recently, the idea of 'hate crimes' became codified in the American legal system, and thus the idea of similarly correlated 'hate speech' was formed. 'Hate speech' is usually defined as speech that attempts to create hatred against a group of individuals of a particular gender, race, religious, or ethnic group. This form of speech is increasingly the target of legislators and activists who wish to make it an object of legislation, banning this form of expression, analogizing it to libelous slurs, 'fighting words,' and general verbal harassment. In an effort to curtail hate speech, libraries have even tried to install filters to prevent individuals using public Internet access to examine the manifestos of groups that promote so-called hate speech.

Simply on a level of technological capabilities, this is problematic, given that groups that advocate hate might not be recognized currently, and might not be screened, and groups that do not advocate hate might be incorrectly identified in this...

Also, if an individual is conducting research upon, for instance, the American Nazi Party, he or she would be unable to examine the evils of this group, in their own words, and thus open his or her research up to charges of bias and inaccuracy.
Alan Dershowitz offers another, more rights-based reason to reject such software filters in libraries. He would state that any ban upon speech leaves the individual conducting the ban open to his or her own speech being banned or filtered. For instance, although banning anti-Black speech might seem laudable to one activist, another individual might deem the words of the Nation of Islam to be offensive and hateful against non-Blacks. Although Dershowitz, for instance, is a committed activist for Israel and the rights of American Jews to practice their religion in a free and open fashion. He is well aware of the fact that many individuals have erroneously attempted to besmirch Israel and its supporters with the charge of racism, most famously in the UN's allegation that racism was analogous to Zionism during the 1970's. This act is a clear indication that even if the majority definition of racism may encompass a particular ideology, the majority definition of racism is simply a snapshot of society at one particular point in time, it cannot be a long-lasting legal definition of what constitutes racism or hate.

Vicki Chang's essay on "Libraries, the Internet, and Freedom of Speech," offers a slightly different perspective on the issue, highlighting the public nature of libraries as an arena where individuals seek out knowledge. It…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Chiang, Vicki. "Libraries, the Internet, and Freedom of the Press."

Dershowitz, Alan. "What is Hate Speech?"

Hamilton, Alexander. "In Defense of the Freedom of the Press."
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Library Science
Words: 1769 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Fingertips Computers and Cataloging in the Modern Library The library has come a long way from the days of gigantic filing cabinets packed with typewritten cards. Of course, the librarian of yore got a good deal of exercise running down into the basement and racing past those long cabinets until at last she arrived at the correct drawer. Yet, the job wasn't finished there. More often than not, finding the proper

Congress Vs The Public Library
Words: 703 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

United States v. American Library Association, 539 U.S. 194 (2003) saw the U.S. Supreme Court rule that libraries as well as public schools are subject to the authority of U.S. Congress concerning installation of web filtering software as a result of receiving E-Rate discounts. These discounts are part of federal funding. Any public school or library receiving such funds must install this type of software. The ruling demonstrated installation of

Evidence-Based Practice Resource Filtered Unfiltered Clinical Practice...
Words: 1025 Length: 3 Document Type: Article Review

Evidence-Based Practice Resource Filtered Unfiltered Clinical Practice Guidelines (1) Authors combined several studies for efficacy Block, S.L. (2) Older data (over 10 years) and used only one research study. Kelley, et.al. (3) Credible and systematic; great review of literature McCracken (4) Older data (over 10 years) and used only one research study. No scholarly or academic research, materials is hearsay and anecdotal. Resource Primary Research Evidence Evidence-Guideline Evidence Summary Clinical Practice Guidelines (1) Inclusion of Primary Research Includes Guidelines for Best Practices Summarization of a number of sources, generalized but academic. Block,

New King Fahad National Library in Riyadh
Words: 6908 Length: 18 Document Type: Research Paper

New King Fahad National Library in Riyadh The rise of the electronic medium of media amongst the masses has become the main motive of decrease in the progress of printed tools and materials along with the decrease in using the academic materials. Each one of these new developments combined with the data of students visiting the library has laid down numerous claims on the entire abolishment of the standard structure of

Hybrid Library the Objective of
Words: 2438 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Proposal

G. "Remember to read this article before writing essay"; (7) the ability to save a list of search results to the personal area and also to edit a saved search; (8) Ability to add individual resources contained within search results to their personal area; (9) Personalized current awareness - searches that can be re-run automatically at a specified time; (10) the ability for the user to share their resource collections

Use of Content Filters on Internet in High School
Words: 14424 Length: 42 Document Type: Term Paper

Internet has grown exponentially since its first introduction to the public. The precursor to the Internet was the ARPANET. The Advanced Research Projects Agency (ARPA) of the Department of Defense (Carlitz and Zinga, 1997) and the National Science Foundation (NSF) were the primary creators of the ARPANET. Subsequently however, efforts from private entities and universities have helped develop the network infrastructure, as it exists today. "The goals of ARPA's

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now