Verified Document

Legal Transplants The Objective Of This Study Term Paper

¶ … Legal Transplants The objective of this study is to discuss and compare two legal transplants with reference to at least one African or Asian legal system. For the purpose of this work, Turkey and legal transplants will be examined.

The work of Orucu (2008) states that Chiba (1986) relates the "concept of legal pluralism…as an effective attack on the common sense of orthodox jurisprudence by rejecting the 'oneness of state law as law or university of western law." (p.1) Chiba is reported to proffer a model of official law "as always intersecting with unofficial law and legal postulates, and never existing in isolation." (Orucu, 2008, p.1) It is the expectation that the state laws will in cohesion with "society and its normative orders, and religion and worldviews…work together to achieve a balanced and sustainable legal order." (Orucu, 2008, p.1-2) However, according to Orucu "legal centralism reflects the ambition of the modern nation state for total legal control and by definition rejects polycentric law." (2008, p.2)

The work of Dai (2009) entitled "On Several Problems in Legal Transplantation" states that legal transplantation that exists between nations and national districts "usually means the digestive and absorptive process happened in legal article, legal principle, legal system, legal norm, legal concept and technology, legal idea." (p. 1) Dai states that legal transplantation is "a mutual processing including implantation of the law and explanation of the law." (2009, p.1)

Law may be derived from unusual and even unintended sources and such is the case in Scotland as George Joseph Bell's 'Principles of the Law of Scotland' is stated to have, while not being conceived as an authoritative work, but instead as a work for the information of students, has become principles established in Scotland's laws. (Reid, 2011, paraphrased) This concept is referred to in the work of Westbrook who states "The phrase "diffusion of law" evokes an essentially spatial imagination of social process -- the term tacitly imports a geography, in which law is...

Turkey
Turkey is described as a "unitary nation state, which is the source of law and the legitimizer of sources of law. This is a monolithic, centralized, territorial and top-down model of law, which may or may not allow competing sources of law to exist. When it does not, it is regarded as intolerant, undemocratic, even despotic and self-referential. When it does however, this can only be a weak version of legal pluralism where the monolithic, top-down source of law is receptive to other sources, and therefore regarded as more tolerant, democratic, multicultural and reflecting an open society. As pointed out, in the Western tradition, on the whole, the stronger version of legal pluralism, where levels of law of equal value co-exist in the same territorial or social space as overlapping orders, is not favored. The centralist forces of the unitary state do not live comfortably with so many rivals." (Orucu, 2008, p.3)

The Turkish legal system is reported to have since it was begun to change the ideas on social, political, ideology and religious systems that were encountered. (Orucu, 2008, paraphrased) According to the work of Orucu (2008) when ideas from two models under interpretation are combined and one of these depends on cultural, traditional and religious understnaidng and the other depending on the understanding of what is official law each can draw upon the other and create a "cultural conversation" that is wider in its understanding. (paraphrased) However, in the country of Turkey this type of cultural conversation is not allowed since no competition between official rules and cultural, traditional or religious understanding is allowed. In such instances of contradiction it is the court system that tries to create harmony. (Orucu, 2008, paraphrased)

The work of Oguz (2005) entitled "The Role of Comparative Law in the Development of Turkish Civil Law" states that the Turkish code is based on the "legal thoughts, ideals and perspectives of Switzerland, rather than just its legal code." (p.10)…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Dai, J. (2009) On Several Problems in Legal Transplantation. Journal of Politics and Law, Sept. 2009. Vol. 2, No. 3.

Gunderson, JL and Waelde, TW (1994) Legislative Reform In Transition Economies: Western Transplants -- a Short-Cut to Social Market Economy Status? ICQL 1994, 43(2), 347-378.

Oguz, A. (2005) The Role of Comparative Law in the Development of Turkish Civil Law. Pace International Law Review. 1 Sept 2005. Article 9. Vol. 17, Issue 2. Fall 2008.

Orucu, E. (2008) Judicial Navigation As Official Law Meets Culture in Turkey. Int J.L.C. 2008, 4(1), 35-61.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Terri on February 25, 1990, Terri Schiavo
Words: 2064 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Terri On February 25, 1990, Terri Schiavo suffered from severe brain injury. She could no longer do anything for herself and was without an attorney. Her husband named Michael Schiavo was her legal guardian. Due to brain damage, Ms. Schiavo did not have the ability to swallow and was feed through a feeding tube. During that same year, she entered into a persistent vegetative state (PVS). As years passed, Mr.

District of Columbia V. Heller District of
Words: 4967 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

District of Columbia v. Heller District of Columbia vs. Heller, 554 U.S. 570 (2008) represents the U.S. Supreme Court's single biggest intervention in Second Amendment jurisprudence. The case was one which had been deliberately manufactured by a small cadre of ideologues: the case was organized and funded from the first by Robert Levy, a Senior Fellow with the libertarian Cato Institute. In 2010, Levy would address his own achievements in getting

Barbas, M.P. Expanding Knowledge: From
Words: 1596 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

More than 98% of respondents had heard of the term "brain death," but only one-third (33.7%) believed that someone who was "brain dead" was legally dead. Using a utilitarian approach, organ donation does provide good for others; and, when managed appropriated, can provide a greater good for society at large. However, utilizing a population for organ harvesting, or changing the model so that organ donation is seen as a

Hospital Ethics to Do or
Words: 5897 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

The clinical trial team includes doctors, nurses, social workers, data entry technicians and other health care professionals (NWHRC 2005). They review a participant's health history and current medical intakes before the trial begins. They impart adequate information and instructions about the clinical trial, monitor each participant in the conduct of the trial and may contact the participant after the conduct of the trial. Clinical trials or researches may also be open-label,

Barriers to Corneal Donation
Words: 1244 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Corneal Donation within Hospitals and Medical Communities: Issues Surrounding Post Mortem Donations of Tissue Qualitative Study The purpose of this study is to identify barriers to corneal donation within hospitals and medical communities. A large body of research has focused on issues surrounding the post mortem donations of tissue. This research will take a different approach, examining what barriers exist within hospital and medical communities in an attempt to determine how

Morality and Ethics Over the
Words: 3959 Length: 11 Document Type: Research Paper

What both these issues show is how advances technology / medicine are changing the overall scope of the ethical debate within the medical and legal communities. Together all of these events have helped to shape the way various ethical standards for medicine would evolve. This is important because they would clearly define the most appropriate conduct for medical research and how to interact with patients in the health care industry.

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now