Verified Document

Legal Recommendations Term Paper

However, Doherty took the themes of these books as further evidence of Adams' wrong doing, although Adams himself never admitted to anything about being part of the Black Blocs or believing in anarchist ideologies. The only thing Adams sad was that he was an environmentalist, which is why he had been collecting the glass Coca Cola bottles in order to recycle them later when he found an acceptable recycling location. Additionally, Officer Doherty found medication on Adams person as well. This medication was prescribed to Thomas Adams, a fact which Doherty should have seen as an obvious red flag that he was dealing with a minor with behavioral and emotional issues, which should have led him to be even more sensitive in his actions towards Adams. Yet, Officer Doherty seemed to only see this as further reason that Adams was guilty. This leads into the second charge against Adams, the carrying a concealed weapon. The supposed weapon here is the glass bottles Doherty discovered in the back pack. All the bottles were Coca Cola bottles, and Adams had given a reasonable understandable explanation for why he would have them. Officer Doherty did not find any rocks on Adams person, which was another reason to suspect that he would not have been affiliated with the Black Blocs, who had also been seen gathering rocks to assault police officers with. It is not a crime to carry glass bottles in a bag, and thus this is clearly not enough evidence to show that Adams was carrying a concealed weapon. Again, because the search was illegal, this evidence should ultimately be dismissed anyways.

Finally, there is the motion to dismiss all statements based on juvenile status. Adams is only fifteen. Yet, he did not have an ID to show Officer Doherty to clarify his exact age. This could have been problematic if it was not for the fact that Officer Doherty himself stated that he noticed Adams was just a tall, lanky teen upon first encountering...

Officer Doherty even told him that he "wasn't going to hurt him," indicating that Officer Doherty clearly understood Adams was a minor and not a legal adult. There are complications regarding minors and their ability to understand their rights. In many instances, minors do not fully understand their Miranda Rights, thus even when they are read their rights, they may still make incriminating statements against themselves. Still, Officer Doherty did not inform Adams' of his rights until after he was placed in custody. Thus, Officer Doherty took advantage of Adams' ignorance, especially in regards to the search of Adams' backpack. Officer Doherty asked Adams if he could search his backpack, but Adams remained silent. Rather than calling the incident in and getting a proper warrant or parental permission to search the backpack in the full letter of the law, Officer Doherty went ahead and searched the backpack anyways. As previously stated, this was a violation of Adams' Sixth Amendment rights, which protect him against illegal search and seizure. Still, Adams did not know this because of his minor status, and thus tried to offer up an explanation, still thinking that he would be let go. An adult would have known better than to speak after Officer Doherty had violated his rights and to wait for his legal representation to make the next move. However, because Adams was a minor, he did not have that forethought. Adams was scared and just trying to leave the area to go home. Thus, in this panicked state, he talked to Officer Doherty and only further incriminated himself. Officer Doherty should have known better than to press a child. He should have taken him into custody and read his Miranda Rights right away, informing Adams of his right to remain silent.
References

Calvin, Elizabeth. (2006). Juvenile Defender Delinquency Notebook. Advocacy Training Guide. Web. http://www.njdc.info/pdf/delinquency_notebook.pdf

Sources used in this document:
References

Calvin, Elizabeth. (2006). Juvenile Defender Delinquency Notebook. Advocacy Training Guide. Web. http://www.njdc.info/pdf/delinquency_notebook.pdf
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Legal Structure and Management of a National Level Sporting Organization...
Words: 2976 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Legal Structure and Management of a National Level Sporting Organisation Sports activities in the world today are becoming more popular and are attracting huge crowd. This is one of the reasons that have made sponsors to come in so as to help such clubs that are not able to support themselves financially. Through sponsoring, the sponsor is able to market and advertise its products within the stadium where the club is

Legal Research, Writing, & Analysis
Words: 1611 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

This chapter is completed with further information on a legal analysis in chapter 12, which discusses the organization of the results of the research. The Honigsberg Grid is amply described as a useful instrument in such an organization. Chapter 13 presents directions as to how a memorandum of law should be written, as well as some of its most important characteristics, notably the fact that this needs to be an

Legal Employment Scenario Employment Law
Words: 1318 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Proposal

To the precedent of Paula's case, a prominent case, which exemplified the sometimes institutionalized presence of inappropriate sexuality in the workplace, came to light when "eight women and one man were fired from a North Mankato (MN) women's shelter because (allegedly) they refused to fit into the sexually charged atmosphere created by a few staff members." (Lang, 1) the clarity of motives for their collective dismissal aligned the decision

Legal Issue in the Professional
Words: 317 Length: 1 Document Type: Thesis

In that regard, the dean could avoid an outright refusal and still satisfy her ethical obligation (and without creating potential liability) by advising Ms. Hall that any letter of recommendation would necessarily reference both her academic performance and also the objective factual circumstances precipitating her withdrawal from NBSU. The alternative of providing the requested recommendation letter without any reference to the accusations could potentially result in liability for NBSU should Ms.

Legal Ethical Environment Type the Document Title
Words: 751 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

Legal Ethical Environment [Type the document title] Over the last several years, the mining industry has faced similar challenges. Part of the reason for this is because of the increase in demand for a host of different raw materials. In the case of Rio Tinto and BHP Billiton, they are facing similar challenges from various safety issues. Below we will examine how both companies are addressing this underlying problem. (Goodman, 2004) Identify two

Legal Aspects of Professional Psychology
Words: 1541 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Legal Aspects of Professional Psychology All psychologists are required to follow the ethical guidelines found in the 2002 Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct of the American Psychological Association (APA), commonly known as the Ethics Code. Other important ethical guidelines are found in the 2007 Competing Development Achievement Levels (DALs) of the National Council of Schools and Programs in Professional Psychology (NCSPP) and the Assessment of Competing Benchmarks Work

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now