Verified Document

Legal Issues Should Heimusic Be Thinking About  Case Study

¶ … legal issues should Heimusic be thinking about? Choice of Laws

Heimusic is a UK-based website, however it does not limit the use of its website to only UK citizens. The Heimusic website can be accessed by anyone in the world through the Internet and therefore the company may be subject to the rules and laws of many different countries. Heimusic should consider the legal implications of being subject to numerous jurisdictions and take action to implement user policies that will limit the laws governing its operations. A choice of laws provision in the websites terms and use will be provide some protection for Heimusic, but will not entirely eliminate the application of other countries laws. Heimusic should continue to consider the risks of liability from multiple jurisdictions because it is operating in a global market.

Heimusic faces the possibility of having to comply with multiple laws from its data collection activities. The company collects information about its users in a database and then licenses the use of the data to third parties. The users of the website must consent to the inclusion of their information in the database, but are enticed to do so through and offer of small discounts. Depending on how much detail is present in the actual terms of the consent given by users, Heimusic may be entering into consumer contracts with each of users for the use and licensing of their information. The formation of a contract requires an offer by a party, an acceptance on the offered terms, definite terms as to what the contract is for and adequate consideration (Ollek, 2009). There is an offer to consent to the use of the information from Heimusic to the user made in the login process. There is consideration for the use of the information by the giving of the discount from Heimusic to the user. There are terms regarding the use of the information, although these terms are not specified, which may create a contract. Lastly, there is acceptance by the user of the terms when they consent to the use of their information during in the logging in process. If a contract has been created, Heimusic should be concerned about the application of other countries laws to these activities.

The creation of a consumer contract may cause Heimusic to be subject to the consumer protection laws of the country where the user resides. The Rome I Regulation, which took effect in the UK on 17 December 2009, updates the rules determining which country's laws apply to a contract (Halton, 2010). This law provides that a consumer's local consumer law will apply where the seller either "pursues his commercial or professional activities" in the customer's country of habitual residence or "by any means, directs such activities to that country" (Halton, 2010). "Directing activities" towards a country could include activities such as offering a choice of languages on a website or providing prices in Euros for other EEA states (Halton, 2010). The parties to a consumer contract can choose the law that governs the contract but the consumer retains the benefit of any mandatory consumer law protections in their home country, provided certain conditions are met (Halton, 2010).

Since Heimusic is a consumer-based website, it should be concerned with the application of the Rome I Regulation in light of the possibility that it is forming consumer contracts with users. A website disclaimer would be a very good idea for Heimusic to limit liability, provide for a choice of law, and to set forth the terms that users must agree to in accessing and using the website (Davey, 2008).

B. Copyright Infringement

The most glaring copyright issue for Heimusic is the file swapping portion of its website that allows users to upload and download music files with software provided by Heimusic. File sharing was first brought into controversy by Internet giant Napster and the subsequent legal battles over its peer-to-peer (P2P) file sharing website. The Napster litigation began in December of 1999, when the five major recording industry companies -- BMG, Sony, EMI, Universal and Warner -- filed suit against Napster for copyright infringement (Sher, 2002). The Internet music-swapping or file sharing brought into the spotlight by the Napster litigation is now known the industry as the "digital distribution of music" (Sher, 2002). Numerous file sharing websites experienced similar lawsuits as the world's legal systems tried to deal with the flood of electronic media sharing. Gnutella, Madster/Aimster, Grokster, Morpheus, KazaA, FreeNet and numerous other peer-to-peer systems use different technological frameworks and present varying legal issues (Bower and Rimmer, 2005). As the law regarding...

Copyright infringement is not only illegal in most countries, but highly unethical for a business. If Heimusic is interested in maintaining an ethical reputation in its industry it should consider how its current system will be viewed by competitors and users alike.
Another area of copyright concern for Heimusic is its use of CD images and music clips on its website. The images and music may be copyrighted material belonging to the creator of the works. Copyrighting protects the author from plagiarism and illegal copying and reselling of the work (Jay313, 2008). In order to legally display images and allow users to listen to music on its website, Heimusic needs a license from the copyright owners (Pinset Mason, 2008a). The fact that only a portion of the song can be heard before the user must purchase it does not avoid copyright infringement claims. Copyright in a work is infringed if it is reproduced in any material form (Pinset Mason, 2008a). Copywriting in modern times can be confusing because even if a work does not say it is copyrighted it still could be (Jay313, 2008). If Heimusic has any concerns about the materials it is using on its website it should determine whether or not the material is copyrighted and obtain a license to use any copyrighted material from the copyright owner.

Heimusic's sale of advertising may also pose a copyright infringement risk. Heimusic allows advertisers to purchase advertising, however it does not monitor or otherwise limit the advertiser's use of materials and this could subject Heimusic to claims for copyright infringement. There may be other claims made by the use of this advertising which will be covered later.

Another copyright problem may exist with the hypertext links and thumbnail illustrations that Heimusic provides in its news search engine. Many of the disputes which have arisen related to news aggregation services involved sites 'scraping' the content of others, by extracting the data, reformatting it and making it available on their own web sites without permission (Pinset Mason, 2008a). Heimusic should determine if the software they are using is truly a search engine displaying websites as they were created or if the software reformats any of the information it takes from news websites.

C. Privacy and Data Collection

Heimusic's collection of personal data from users poses a privacy issue which could subject the company to penalties. In the UK, the Data Protection Act of 1998 ("DPA") requires that companies storing and using personal data adhere to certain requirements (Dotmailer, 2010). The data must be fair and lawfully processed; processed for limited purposes; adequate, relevant and not excessive; accurate; not kept for longer than necessary; processed in accordance with the data subjects rights; secure; and not transferred to countries without adequate protection (Dotmailer, 2010). Failure to comply with these guidelines can result in stiff penalties.

To adhere to the requirements of the DPA, Heimusic should have a privacy policy on its website which can be easily located by users. The privacy notice should explain to users that Heimusic collects data from their usage of its website and it should explain how Heimusic uses the data it collects. It would be a good practice for Heimusic to require users to acknowledge that they have reviewed the company's privacy policy prior to completing their registration. The privacy policy should also include information about how long the data will be maintained and provide a statement as to the security of the personal information provided. The security of credit card numbers, birth dates and personal identification information is particularly important to consumers as identify theft continues to grow.

Security is just one of the user rights issues Heimusic needs to be concerned about when collecting and using personal information. The actual use of the information collected must also adhere to the requirements of the DPA. For example, the DPA provides that users of the website may opt out of having their data used for direct marketing, which is one of the ways Heimusic uses the information in its database (Dotmailer, 2010). To protect against infringing on this consumer right, Heimusic should have an opt out choice…

Sources used in this document:
References

Baker, Jennifer, 2010. Facebook, Google Face Crackdown Over User Data. PCWorld, [online] Available at: <http://www.pcworld.com/article/209717/facebook_google_face_eu_crackdown_over_user_data.html?tk=mod_rel> [Accessed November 2010].

Bowry, Kathy & Rimmer, Matthew 2005, "Rip, Mix, Burn: The Politics of Peer to Peer and Copyright Law," Peer Reviewed Journal on the Internet [e-journal] FM Special Issue #1: Music and the Internet (4 July 2005) [Accessed November 2010].

Citizen Media Law Project, 2009. Immunity for Online Publishers Under the Communications Decency Act. [online] Available at:< http://www.citmedialaw.org/legal-guide/immunity-online-publishers-under-communications-decency-act> [Accessed November 2010].

Davy, Simon, 2008. Website disclaimers -- why have them and what should you include? Lasa knowledgebase [online] Available at:< http://www.ictknowledgebase.org.uk/websitedisclaimers> [Accessed November 2010].
Dotmailer, 2010. The Data Protection Act. [online] Available at: http://www.dotmailer.co.uk/email_marketing_resources/law/the_data_protection_act.aspx> [Accessed November 2010].
Goldman Eric 2010. LimeWire Smacked Down for Inducing Copyright Infringement -- Arista Records v. Lime Group. Technology & Marketing Law Blog, [blog] May 14, Available at: <http://blog.ericgoldman.org/archives/2010/05/limewire_smacke.htm> [Accessed November 2010].
Halton, John, 2010. United Kingdom: Regulating Contracts and Services. Mondaq [online] Available at: <http://www.mondaq.com/article.asp?articleid=93042> [Accessed November 2010].
Jay313, 2008. A short copyright law guildline. WebUpon [online] Available at [Accessed November 2010].
Larson, Aaron, 2003. Defamation, Libel and Slander Law. Expertlaw [online] Available at: [Accessed November 2010].
Ollek, Sucha, 2009. Essentials of a Contract. [online] Available at:< http://www.e-law.bc.ca/art_essential.html> [Accessed November 2010].
Pinset Mason Law Firm, 2008a. Intellectual property in websites: ownership and protection. Available at:< http://out-law.com/page-381> [Accessed November 2010].
Pinset Mason Law Firm, 2008b. Email marketing -- when to use opt-in and when to use opt-out. Available at:<http://www.out-law.com/page-5657> [Accessed November 2010].
Wilder, Clinton, 2001. The Ethics Of Data: As the debate over data privacy grows, many IT professionals who manage the information find themselves in the middle of the controversy. Informationweek.com [online] Available at:< http://www.informationweek.com/837/dataethics.htm;jsessionid=OS3FITWPPC3FRQE1GHOSKHWATMY32JVN> [Accessed November 2010].
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Legal Issues With Do Not
Words: 1948 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Analysis of Future Effects and How These Will Be Addressed Providing healthcare providers with the ethical training they need to make informed decisions during ethical dilemmas represents a useful starting point, but the exigencies of the human condition mean that people's desires change over time, but they will always need timely and accurate information about the alternatives that are available to them. People experiencing the rigors and stresses that are involved

Legal Issues in Hydraulic Fracturing
Words: 708 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

Legal Issues in Hydraulic Fracturing This study provides a comprehensive elaboration of the legal implications of hydraulic fracturing. Moreover, it reviews the environmental issues associated with the process of hydraulic fracturing. The role of hydraulic fracturing in the United States energy needs is also reviewed. Some of the environmental issues raised concerning the process include ground water contamination, chemical implications as well as air contamination. The legal issues handled include the

Legal Issues in Education Liability
Words: 763 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

The second case involves a third grader who was seriously injured (became quadriplegic) when he ran into the street after school and was hit by a car. His family argued that they had not been made aware of early release, and sued Pleasantville Public Schools (Jerkins v. Anderson a-49-06) for negligently "failing to carry out its duty to provide reasonable supervision," the NSBA explains. The upshot of the 2007 case

Legal Issues and Legal Structure
Words: 5046 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

LEGAL ISSUE, STRUCTURE, and ANALYSIS A. LEGAL ISSUES-LIMITED PARTNERSHIP. According to Black's Law Dictionary (1991), a limited partnership is a "type of partnership of one or more general partners who manage business and who are personally liable for partnership debts, and one or more limited partners, who contribute capital and share in profits but who take no part in running business and incur no liability with respect to partnership obligations beyond contribution"

Legal Management the Legal Issues
Words: 1230 Length: 4 Document Type: Book Review

those of the federal government. But the assessment delivered in the case of Granholm v. Heald actually seems to imply that this focus is misdirected. In a case where small wineries with limited means to obtain local distribution have attempted to broader their reach through catalogue and web-based sales, several states have invoked the language surrounding the repealing of prohibition (through the 21st Amendment) in order to oppose these

Legal Issues in Human Relations
Words: 1172 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

A person's religion is in almost all employment contexts an entirely private issue and asking a job candidate about her religion suggests that that religious affiliation is one of the criteria on which she is being assessed. Again, even if this is in fact not the case, the manager has opened up the process to the suggestion of religious bias. If, however, the person conducting the interview is the director

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now