Verified Document

Leadership Vs. Management: Impact On Term Paper

Education leaders note barriers to effective leadership with are unique to the educational setting. Politics and bureaucracy, fear of litigation, teacher unions and school boards are all noted by superintendents and principals as elements which hamper organizational excellence (Finn, 2002). In the same survey, leaders also noted a lack of freedom to accomplish managerial tasks, like hiring and firing or even rewarding outstanding performers. A review of job descriptions posted for superintendent and principal jobs across the United States demonstrates the wide variety of skill required for these positions. Samplings of descriptions include "experience as a principal"; "earned doctorate from an accredited institution"; there also exist a long list of complex organization and managerial tasks which accompany these basic requirements. As a result, the number of individuals completing Ed D. degrees has increased significantly. Research completed in 2007 (Baker, Orr and Young, 2007) reported the number of programs offering educational leadership doctoral programs increased by 48% between 1993 and 2003.

How should leadership preparation be managed? Bottoms and O'Neill (2001) reported that leaders should be evaluated primarily by impact on student achievement.

Proponents of standardized testing would seem to agree. A review of the literature on the connection between leadership practices and school conditions (Leithwood, Louis, Anderson, & Wahlstrom, 2004) showed a higher rate of teacher satisfaction in schools which had adopted policies meant to improve school leadership via leadership preparation standards. The No Child Left behind Act (NCLB) calls for the placement of highly effective principals in high poverty rate schools, with effectiveness rated by means of principals meeting state leadership preparation requirements.

Teacher satisfaction also serves as a good indicator of leadership effectiveness, within the constraints of the leader's power. Teacher job satisfaction and the degree to which teachers are engaged with students are important quality indicators, and noted by Bossert, Dwyer et. Al (1982) as predictors of both organizational commitment and teacher...

Teacher well being, as it relates to the work environment, is impacted significantly by job satisfaction or conversely, burnout. Teacher empowerment, or the perception of empowerment, is also positively associated with improved job satisfaction and student achievement, and are directly related to distributed leadership as well as leadership effectiveness.
From the data reviewed for this paper, it would appear that managers are appointed while effective leaders are made. Some managers may exhibit traits that increase likelihood of effective leadership but it possible for any manager to achieve leadership status, when given appropriate education and guidance of leadership skills. The application of leadership tools to the school setting appears to be inevitable with new requirements and expectations of our schools in the 21st century

Reference

Kotter, JP, Force for Change: How Leadership Differs From Management, the Free Press, 1990.

Kotter, JP. "What Leaders Really Do," in J.T. Wren (Ed.), the Leaders Companion, the Free Press, 1995, pp. 114-123.

Goffee R, Jones R. (2000) Why should anyone be led by you? Harv Bus Rev 5; 62-70

Finn, CE. (2002) Bureaucracy and school leadership - policy research organization Public Agenda survey on finding strong leaders for schools. Reason. Accessed online at http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1568/is_1_34/ai_84841777

Baker, B., Orr, M.T., & Young, M.D. (2007). Academic Drift, Institutional Production and Professional Distribution of Graduate Degrees in Educational Administration.

Educational administration quarterly, 43(5).

A s, G., & O'Neill, K. (2001). Preparing a new breed of school principals: It's time for action. Atlanta: Southern Regional Education Board.

The Commission on No Child Left Behind (NCLB). (2007). Beyond NCLB: Fulfilling the Promise to Our Nation's Children. Aspen, CO: The Aspen Institute.

Bossert, S.T., Dwyer, D., Rowan, B., & Lee, G. (1982). The instructional management role of the principal. Educational Administration Quarterly, 18, 34-64.

Sources used in this document:
Reference

Kotter, JP, Force for Change: How Leadership Differs From Management, the Free Press, 1990.

Kotter, JP. "What Leaders Really Do," in J.T. Wren (Ed.), the Leaders Companion, the Free Press, 1995, pp. 114-123.

Goffee R, Jones R. (2000) Why should anyone be led by you? Harv Bus Rev 5; 62-70

Finn, CE. (2002) Bureaucracy and school leadership - policy research organization Public Agenda survey on finding strong leaders for schools. Reason. Accessed online at http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1568/is_1_34/ai_84841777
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Leadership Management Assessment of Transformational
Words: 906 Length: 3 Document Type: A-Level Coursework

Sixth, his service commitment is exceptional, as he has been known to work with many customers to solve problems and help them get to their goals as hospitals and healthcare providers. Seventh, he is exceptionally resourceful and willing to move beyond traditional boundaries to accomplish greater tasks than would have been possible otherwise. Eighth, his focus on rewards and recognition is well-known throughout the entire healthcare industry, as is

Leadership Management Literature Abounds With
Words: 1436 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Indeed, without these legitimacy criteria, a leader would not be able to influence followers to either change or progress towards organizational goals: "The acceptance of leadership from another person involves an implicit contract in which followers sacrifice some level of personal autonomy and pledge loyalty and effort to the leader.... The followers must be sure that the leader has the competency to lead effectively and the trustworthiness and loyalty

Leadership Management Effective Approaches Leadership Management...
Words: 1524 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Leadership Management Effective Approaches Leadership Management Different personalities practice different management styles, while different management styles are suited to different personalities. It is very important for a manager to make sure that their employees are motivated and their work rates are up to the mark. The employees of any organization need to be motivated in order to maintain a fair attendance at the office along with enough motivation that employees would

Educational Leadership Management Effectiveness Vs.
Words: 654 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

In that regard, a leader who gets things done through coercion as opposed to consensus could be regarded a successful but not an effective leader. Looked at from another perspective, successful leadership differs from effective leadership on the basis of emphasis. While emphasis in successful leadership is on power and position, the emphasis when it comes to effective leadership is often on the personal attributes of a leader. It

Shared Leadership Directly Impacts the
Words: 1205 Length: 4 Document Type: Thesis

The second leadership attribute analyzed in this paper is that of creating and sustaining a shared vision. Of all attributes of any leader this is one of the more challenging to continually achieve as it requires the continual focus on aligning the vision of the organization and the skills required to accomplish them with the unique skill sets of individuals and their talents (Kouzes, Posner, 2009). What a sustainable vision

Nursing Leadership, Management Theories, and
Words: 1506 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

When this happens, they will be effective in reaching out to different patients (from a host of backgrounds). This is the point that the underlying quality of care will improve. As a result, I have learned how to apply these concepts to real world health care environments. This will help in day-to-day practices by preparing me for the new challenges that will be faced on a continuing basis. Recommendations /

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now