Verified Document

Leadership Styles And Power Bases Of CO, Movie Review

¶ … leadership styles and power bases of CO, XO, Chief of the Boat (COB)? (Consider the full range of possible styles.) Cite specific behaviors and statements, with specific reference to the leadership literature. The CO's leadership style is very much ad hoc -- in terms of his contempt for what he sees as overly theoretical book knowledge, it is also firmly based on his own long experience. To some degree it recalls the fascinating research done by Malcolm Gladwell in his book Blink: Gladwell researches the possibility that snap decisions in many circumstances are more likely to be correct than laboriously researched and deliberated ones. Gladwell estimates that ten thousand hours of intense activity are required to gain real competency or fluency in an activity, and it is clear from the captain's age and the length of his command that he has seen many years of service and can now afford to make his decisions based on pure instinct. The Cob rather memorably sums up the CO's leadership abilities in his attempt to mollify the XO early in their conflict: "I think we have here is a difference in management styles. But as unpredictable as he is, there is a logic to it. He navigates by his own star, not many men can do that. Cob's rules of Navy leadership: One, you've got to look like you know what you're doing, Two, the men have got to believe you know what you're doing, and Three -- and most important -- everybody's got an opinion, but the captain's got to make a choice. You live and die with that. And that's where the Skipper's earned his stripes, Sir. I've seen it time and time again." In other words, Cog justifies the CO's initial high-handedness to...

This is why he controversially at the start of the film orders a weapons readiness drill even in the midst of a galley fire -- the incident that sets off his quarrel with the XO over their differing managerial styles.
The XO is depicted as being almost the polar opposite of the CO -- as another character tells the XO after his friction with the CO begins, the XO needs to remember how he looks to the CO "Annapolis…Harvard…Well-versed in theory," in other words lacking in the kind of practical experience that Malcolm Gladwell sees as requisite for actual expertise. (The XO gets precisely this kind of practical experience over the course of the film, after he has assumed command -- even to the point of making a wrenching life-or-death decision regarding three crew members who are sealed off and presumably drown in order to prevent the sub-from collapse.) In the latter half of the film, after the CO has been removed from command, he scornfully notes that he is reading the XO's personnel file while under house-arrest and "the closest he's been to combat has been in a classroom." But the XO's job is to provide nuance, and that is why -- with the particularly tricky question of partial orders received followed by combat-related radio silence -- he ultimately prevails against the CO's desire to follow the first fully-received order to fire. The CO's analysis of the XO overall is that he is too full of nuance and scruple:…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Leadership Style Inventory Leadership Crises Have Been
Words: 1729 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Leadership Style Inventory Leadership crises have been brewing since the past century. Evidently, the latest global economic lapses of financial markets raised a higher need for an effective leadership than it had been before. These crises led to a call for contemporary organizations to scrutinize or assess the leadership potential among their employees and new recruitments. Following the current changes in organizational rules and business games, as well as randomly emerging

Leadership Styles in the 21st
Words: 2982 Length: 11 Document Type: Term Paper

It has been suggested further that the transformational leadership is a special type of transactional leadership because both leaderships are goal oriented. The difference comes from the way methods used to motivate people and the goal sets (Hater & Bass, 1988). Thus, one model is based on the leader's power to inspire followers and the other is based on the leader's creativity regarding the reward system. The goals are

Leadership Styles Among Male and Female Principal and How Teachers...
Words: 14019 Length: 50 Document Type: Term Paper

Leadership Styles Among Male and Female Principal It is the intention of this research to study the leadership and cognitive styles of teachers and instructors of both genders within the educational system and their preference for types of leadership in a principal of that institution. The research will include teachers and educators from all levels of the educational system from grade school to high school. The study will also include teachers and

Leadership Analysis the Necessity of
Words: 1176 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Leaders that are experienced in a certain type of situations can manage them faster and more efficiently. Such experienced leaders have the advantage of having experienced similar situations before. Therefore, this means that these leaders know what the phases of the situation are and what outcomes they should expect to take place. In other words, they are aware of the actions and decisions they must make in order to efficiently

Leadership Style and Characteristics Affect
Words: 5990 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

Furthermore, there are a number of similarities and overlaps between such leadership theories that do not prevent their being characterized as transformational in nature. For example, "Most leaders behave in both transactional and transformational ways in different intensities and amounts; this is not an entirely either-or differentiation" (Miner, 2002 p. 743). One of the more interesting issues to emerge from the research is the need for transformational leaders to teach

Leadership for Addressing Absenteeism
Words: 1670 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

Supervisory Skills and ChallengesIntroductionAs a Shift Supervisor at Fast Fleet Shoes Manufacturing, I recognize a number of challenges that we face as an organization. The purpose of this paper is to outline the immediate, six-month, and one-year goals to address these challenges, using various supervisory techniques and concepts, as well as to provide an overview of the issues in a concise manner. First, I will present the overview, and following

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now