¶ … leadership style is one of the most important factors that determine cross functional teams' success. Research and practice in the field have revealed several types of leadership theories, such as trait, behavioral, situational contingency, participative, transactional, and transformational theories. Each of these leadership theories introduces several types of leadership styles, amongst which the most frequently met in private and public organizations are autocratic or authoritative leadership, democratic or participative styles, transformational leadership, and others (Ricketts, 2011). It is difficult to determine which of these leadership styles is the most efficient, as the need for a certain style depends on each situation. The table below compares and contrasts three key variables found in these theories.
Table 1. Leadership Theories Analysis
Key variable / theory
Trait theories
Behavioral theories
Situational contingency theories
Participative theories
Transactional theories
Transformational theories
Characteristics of leader
Cognitive abilities, social intelligence
Informing, clarifying, monitoring
Flexibility
Democratic
Task oriented
People oriented
Relationship with followers
Motivational
Motivating, recognizing, rewarding
Clarifying
Involves followers in different processes
Rewarding
Team building, motivating, cooperating
Decision making style
Problem solving
Planning, organizing, delegating
Problem solving
Delegating
Strategic thinking
Participative
Information source: Fleenor, J. (2006), Derue, S.et al. (2011), Seyranian, V. (2009).
In order to compare and contrast leadership theories, the selected key variables are: characteristics of the leader, because they dictate the leadership style, leaders' relationship with followers, because the success of each style depends on how this relationship develops, and leaders' decision making style because it is important to identify the styles in which leaders prefer a centralized decision making process, and those that require the participation of their followers (Coutts, 2011). These are key variables that determine the leadership style, and followers' response to it. However, there are numerous variables that can be analyzed in accordance with the studied context or situation in order to determine differences between leadership styles.
In order to exemplify the analysis presented in the table, the transformational leadership style is selected. The situation is represented by a cross functional team charged with improving service to key customers. The leadership style of the team's leader will be analyzed based on a process that has the following steps: identifying the necessities of the team's key customers, identifying the needs of team members, analyzing the leadership style in relationship with the activity of improving customer service.
Identification of key customers' necessities
This is an important step in the analysis process because it allows us to determine the direction towards which the leader's activities must be oriented. There are situations that require a task orientation and situations that require people orientation. Identifying customers' needs is mostly a task oriented activity. This is not something that a transformational leader excels at. However, there are several characteristics that allow a successful transformational leader to manage this situation as efficiently as a transactional leader, which is usually task oriented.
The transformational leader does not necessarily plan and organize this activity. He sets the goals and objectives that must be reached by his team. The leader establishes the strategic direction required in order to improve key customer service (Hall et al., 2013). The participative nature of this type of leader invites his team members to develop solutions that can be used in reaching the established objectives (Ingram, 2014). Although transformational leaders do not necessarily delegate most of their decision making process, they focus on a participative process where team members are encouraged to participate with ideas.
Identification of team member needs
This is another important step of the leadership analysis process. This is because in order to determine how transformational leaders develop strong relationship with their employees, it is important to determine what their needs are and whether the leader is able to satisfy them. This is in strong relationship with the "relationship with followers" key variable. The type of relationship established between the leader and his followers and how the leader manages this relationship determines employees' satisfaction level. Employee satisfaction is an important issue that determines companies' success.
In this case, this is a cross functional team. Cross functional teams are groups of people from different departments working together in order to reach certain objectives (Business Dictionary, 2014). The important issue that must be addressed in such cases is represented by the fact that the different professions of team members do not facilitate the communication process. In other words, team members do not speak the same language (Mind Tools, 2014). This is one of the areas where the importance of leadership can be easily observed.
The transformational leader can play the role of an interpreter...
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now