Verified Document

Kierkegaard Vs. Camus In The Essay

If there were a concrete and appreciable version of each person, ready at any time to assess, then the concept of dread would have less terrible implications. The fact is, when penetrated by the nothing of pure possibility, the reach of this nothing is beyond almost all conception. There never really is an individual, just some ongoing process of change. The nothing alienates the individual further than from mere others and the world. The nothing of dread brings into its fold, the individual. The individual supports this nothing and yet must determine itself on such grounds. Whereas before, we had the Kierkegaardian maxim of individual as truth, we now have no grounds for determining anything. The actor has forgotten his/her lines and must now choose them every moment. As such, we must move onto a more concrete and grounded conception of the individual to explore the synthesis of Camus and Kierkegaard. Perhaps a synthesis already has purchase in the absurd. "The absurd depends as much on man as on the world…it is all that links them together."2 The absurd, as witnessed by the individual, affords a better vantage of human existence. The absurd links a creator of the nothing, to his/her respective nothing. Simply feeling absurd asserts the state of individuality. "Everything turns upon dread coming into view. Man is a synthesis…but a synthesis is unthinkable if the two are not united in a third factor."3 It is time to more fully uncover the meaning of these quotes. The individual has been defined as a synthesis of forces: mind and body. However, mind and body have no purchase without a grounding factor, in which the synthesis must take place. In the absurd, we find a complete synthesis of conscious being, witnessing the world as a feeling.

This grounding factor is world, both material and immaterial. The material world incorporates all objects. The immaterial world incorporates ideologies, and any other crowd-like doctrines of truth. Both of these worlds come to the individual as one, as "everything" once dread has come into view. So, in the act of realizing nothing, the pure possibility of further possibility, and so on, ad infinitum, there exists everything. This is the reason the crowd contains "untruth." Coming to what one believes is true, there exists an endless multitude of possibilities, each dependant on the individual and vice versa. So, any received truth, is necessarily an untruth; it brings everything into the nothing. The untruth of the crowd is the conclusion without the work, the decision without a decider. It bears none of the characteristics of an accomplishment, a courage.

Earlier, we saw that Kierkegaard equated fleeing into the crowd as "cowardice," and moving towards individuality as "courage." It is now more clear why this is so. To flee to the crowd is to take a possibility already established and accepted. One says goodbye to the nothing by accepting everything. There is no fear in it. To take one's own path, however, means to hazard oneself as a wager to the nothing, in which the possibility of further possibilities relies on each confrontation. Each decision is the decision to keep deciding. Worlds arise and fall in each confrontation. There is courage in each rise and fall.

Lastly, we return to the metaphor, provided by Camus, of life and world as stage, and individual as actor. Is this metaphor apt? Let us see. On a stage, all is preordained....

Each object, each act, and each character, has been determined in advance. The dialogue, likewise, preordained. Everything. There are no decisions to be made, only moments to recite. Outside of the stage and its objects, there is nothing, relative to the stage. The moments that open the play already betoken the end, and the end is known at the beginning. According to Camus, only when these things drop, do we encounter ourselves in a world of absurdity. The absurd results from an individual no longer finding apparent truth in his/her surroundings. The absurd is not an object, a place, or anything definable; it is an interaction. As said before, the stage metaphor suggests no room for decision. When the stage no longer exists, there is only the individual standing in its folded abyss. All decisions are now available. Dread reaches full accord with the individual. There is no truth other than the absence of untruth, and also, the recurring condition of dread.
The upshot of all this is the notion of will and responsibility as more elemental factors of human existence. Without will, there would be no dread, no concepts and no action. Without responsibility, this will would degenerate back into the crowd mentality. Situations are staged by the individual, and must then be navigated. So the metaphor of the stage folding is not entirely accurate. If one were to exist purely in dread, only then would the stage collapse. However, it is the prerogative of the individual to make choices, to see oneself as able and to know that after this moment, after this decision, there comes another that requires the very same ability. There exists in each individual's experience with the world, a recurrence of decision and action. Each decision finds itself on the stage of the world, and each world is then decided as a new stage. To maintain the state of dread would be as cowardly as fleeing to the crowd, for it wishes not to exists concretely. The manipulation of dread requires a responsible individual, who seeks to fully control their character and their lines. New scripts beget new stages.

Endnotes

Kierkegaard, Soren. "That Individual." Existentialism from Dostoevsky to Sartre: The Basic Writings of Existentialism. Trans. Walter Kaufman. New York. Meridian Books / World Publishing, 1956.

Kierkegaard, Soren.

Camus, Albert. The Myth of Sisyphus: And Other Essays. Alfred A. Knopf, 1955. Translated by Justin O'Brien.

Camus, Albert.

Kieregaard, Soren. "Dread and Freedom." Existentialism from Dostoevsky to Sartre: The Basic Writings of Existentialism. Trans. Walter Kaufman. New York. Meridian Books / World Publishing, 1956.

Camus, Albert.

Kierkegaard, Soren.

Camus, Albert.

Kierkegaard, Soren.

Works Cited

Camus, Albert. The Myth of Sisyphus: And Other Essays. Alfred A. Knopf, 1955.

Translated by Justin O'Brien.

Kieregaard, Soren. "Dread and Freedom." Existentialism from Dostoevsky to Sartre:

The Basic Writings of Existentialism. Trans. Walter Kaufman. New York.

Meridian Books / World Publishing, 1956.

Kierkegaard, Soren. "That Individual." Existentialism from Dostoevsky to Sartre:

The Basic Writings of Existentialism. Trans. Walter Kaufman. New York.

Meridian Books / World Publishing, 1956.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Camus, Albert. The Myth of Sisyphus: And Other Essays. Alfred A. Knopf, 1955.

Translated by Justin O'Brien.

Kieregaard, Soren. "Dread and Freedom." Existentialism from Dostoevsky to Sartre:

The Basic Writings of Existentialism. Trans. Walter Kaufman. New York.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Kierkegaard on Camus Albert Camus's
Words: 930 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

The implications of this concept are enormous and profound. Just as Kierkegaard reverses the Hegelian construct of the universal being over the individual, the inner is placed by Kierkegaard in a position of supremacy over the outer. It has already been shown that faith can make acts moral to the individual performing them even when universal ethics would condemn the same act. Universal ethics are an element of the outer,

Philosophy of Suicide Involves Two
Words: 1752 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

On the other hand, Schopenchauer argues that because happiness is fundamentally unobtainable, humans are faced with a life of disappointment, which thus leads to the disconnect that causes suicide. However, if both of these philosophers' theories on the cause of suicide were taken at face value, it would be surmised that every human would commit suicide and thus the extinction of the human race would be inevitable. Yet, this is

Nietzsche and Nihilism "The World
Words: 2271 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Foremost, though, is the Nietzschian concept that freedom is never free -- there are costs; personal, societal, and spiritual. To continue that sense of freedom, one must be constantly vigilant and in danger of losing that freedom, for the moment the individual gasps a sigh of relief and feels "free" from contemplating freedom, tyranny will ensue. He believed that it was the internal cost that contained value. This, however,

Philosophical Ideals and Contributions to
Words: 1443 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Identify the following ten terms or philosophers: (Be sure your answers contain details and sufficient information for college level work.) 1) Buddha 2) Freud 3) Plato 4) Relativism 5) Camus 6) Kierkegaard 7) What is your definition or morality? 8) Does God exist and intervene directly in our affairs? 9) What is the relationship between religion and reason? 10) What philosophical ideals are you developing as a result of your

Existentialism: A History Existentialism Is a Philosophical
Words: 2915 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

Existentialism: A History Existentialism is a philosophical school of thought that addresses the "problem of being" (Stanford Encyclopedia, 2010). Existentialist questions involve the nature of man in relation to the universe, the subjective nature of "I" versus the objective "we," the creation and measure of meaning in a world with no intrinsic meaning, standards of morality in the absence of Divine Law (God), and the creation and measure of success in

Teleological Suspensions & Jean-Paul Sartre This Is
Words: 863 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Teleological Suspensions & Jean-Paul Sartre This is a paper on the topic of "Teleological Suspensions" and Jean-Paul Sartre. ABRAHAM TO SACRIFICE OR NOT The story of Abraham and Isaac is known throughout the world. The question that many may ask: Why was Abraham willing to sacrifice Isaac? This was murder so how could God ask Abraham to sacrifice Isaac? What is the essence of Existentialism? Kiekegaard once stated, "The story of Abraham contains a

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now