Ethical Frameworks: Case Scenario
This week’s case scenario involves Jenna, who has just been hired as a new recruiter at a large staffing agency. Her trainer advises her to tell candidates that the organization will get back to them within two weeks of an interview date. However, Jenna is concerned that the agency does not live up to this promise and rarely gets back to candidates. She feels that lying to candidates is unethical as she too would not like to be lied to.
The Kantian duty ethical framework applies best to the current scenario. Kantian ethics emphasizes the idea that all people have a duty to act in a certain way and are required to act in line with this duty even when acting so is not in their best interest (Schulzke, 2012). Kantian ethics is based on the categorical imperative, which requires individuals to act a certain way only if they would will that acting in that way becomes universal law (Budd & Scoville, 2005; Schulzke, 2012). The unethicality of the agency’s actions in the above case can be adequately explained using the three formulations of the categorical imperative.
The first formulation of the categorical imperative requires agents to do to others what they would want others to do to them (Budd & Scoville, 2005). As such, a moral agent is forbidden from lying if they would not wish that others lie to them. Jenna expresses that she would not like to be lied to if she were a candidate. As such, the decision to lie to candidates constitutes a violation of the first...…candidates that they will be contacted after two weeks only as a mere formality. However, this policy is not acceptable to some employees such as Jenna, who believe that lying is unethical. The agency’s policy thus violates the third formulation of the categorical imperative.
In summary, the Kantian duty framework applies adequately to the presented case scenario. The agency’s actions contravene the precepts of the categorical imperative and are considered unethical. Kantian ethics imposes upon the agency a duty to treat its candidates like it would like to be treated. It is imperative, therefore, that the agency’s recruiters keep their promise to contact candidates within two weeks of the interview date. Alternatively, they could advise candidates to consider themselves unsuccessful if they do not hear from the agency within two weeks of the interview date.…
References
Budd, J. W., & Scoville, J. G. (Eds.) (2015). The Ethics of Human Resources and Industrial Relations. Champaign, IL: Cornell University Press.
Geiger, I. (2015). How are the Different Formulas of the Categorical Imperative Related? Kantian Review, 20(3), 395-419.
Schulzke, M. (2012). Kant’s Categorical Imperative, the Value of Respect, and the Treatment of Women. Journal of Military Ethics, 11(1), 26-41.
In this light, the individual is given emphasis in the senses that, if one individual's life is compromised, say in order to find a cure for a disease; Kantian ethics would heavily oppose this approach. Utilitarianism, on the other hand would accept the measure. Both Kant's moral principles and his theory of human nature are designed only to add to our discontent with ourselves. For Kant, the task of philosophy
Kantian Ethical Analysis Introduction to Kantian Ethics. Kantian ethics may depart from what Kant wrote and thought. Kantian ethics can criticize and modify the theory that Kant put forward as well as sympathetically interpret or defend it. Kant's ethics are contained in Kant's own writings: the Groundwork, the Critique of Practical Reason, the Metaphysics of Morals, as well as others. Kantian ethics are the theory that Kant himself put forward, the fundamental
Because the imperative is something that stems from the rational will, adherence to it is really only adherence to the law that the will itself created. The will, that is, is acting as the will tells itself it has to. Due to the circular nature of the will's imperative to behave a certain way, obedience to the imperative is actually obedience to the self, and obeying moral law requires
Definition of an Ethical Framework An ethical framework that would be useful to me is one which I can use it to assess how to go about behaving in a given circumstance. The framework should be based on the virtue-ethics perspective. As Lutz (1996) points out, “Piaget and Kohlberg belong to the cognitive-developmental tradition of developmental psychology” in which the moral development of a child is decided through social interaction and
Morality How does the common morality define who is a moral agent? According to Gert et al. (2000), common morality defines a moral agent as an individual who fully understands what is necessitated, forbidden, allowed, and encouraged by moral rules and an individual who can sensibly conform to guidance and being judged by such moral rules. Write out a script for what you would tell them to help them grasp the basic
Legal/Ethical Framework Overview of the legal system: In Australia, each state is responsible for legislation under which child care services are licensed. Licensing provides a legal "floor" below which no service is permitted to operate, according to CCQA. These include structural factors related to space, range of equipment, number and ages of children, staff-to-child ratio, and qualifications of staff. All of these factors are what contribute to quality. Legislative Basis: A child care
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now