Verified Document

Justice To Unlawfully Detained People Essay

Padilla v. Rumsfeld, Ex-Parte Quirin, and Hamdi v. Rumsfeld Facts

Padilla vs. Rumsfeld

The synopsis of this case indicates a fact that Padilla, in the first place, did not have any reason to access a lawyer because he had been deemed a national security concern. Being an enemy combatant, Padilla did not have any jurisdiction whatsoever to be founded on the terms of an appeal as done to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals (McPhee, 2006). As seen from the arguments promoted by Bush's depiction of Padilla as an enemy combatant, the court had not authority to hear the case since Padilla was supposed to be kept in the South Carolina. In the meantime, the right and possible defendant should have been a South Carolina Warden and not the Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld (Hafetz, 2011).

Ex-Parte Quirin

The case involved eight men who were American citizens. The eight were deemed as unlawful combatants. They were subject to capture for which they were detained as prisoners of war. They acted as spies. Evidently, they were subject to arrest and punishment amidst trial, done by the military tribunals. Their acts had declared their belligerency as unlawful. They were somewhat taken as prisoners of...

There should have been no controversy in the action and decision taken by the court over the eight. The controversy fueled by the president's actions should have been a leeway to offering justice to the possible victims who were to suffer the consequences of the actions by the eight people (McPhee, 2006).
Hamdi v. Rumsfeld

The government might be thought to have violated Hamdi's Fifth Amendment right when he was held indefinitely without being granted a chance to face the attorney. This was based particularly on the Executive Branch exemplification that Hamdi was an enemy combatant. He was deemed to have been an enemy combatant because he fought against the United States of America. With the presence of the plurality, it was hard for the accused to be given the right to argue his case through a decision maker. Perhaps, Hamdi had the right to challenge the court ruling that had deemed him as an enemy combatant. This issue was controversial from the start. It was clear that after being detained Hamdi, should have been given his right to access and argue his case through an attorney (Hafetz, 2011).

Quirin does not any justices…

Sources used in this document:
References

Hafetz, J. (2011). Habeas Corpus after 9/11: Confronting America's New Global Detention System. New York: New York University Press.

Lokaneeta, J. (2011). Transnational Torture: Law, Violence, and State Power in The United States And India. New York: New York Univ. Press.

McPhee, R.D. (2006). The Treatment Of Prisoners: Legal, Moral Or Criminal? New York: Nova Science Publishers.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Extraordinary Rendition Refers to the
Words: 4875 Length: 13 Document Type: Research Paper

They point out that if a suspected terrorist gets on a plane and gets off at a place like Copenhagen or Toronto and demands asylum, even if he is not granted asylum, he's pretty much got a safe haven to operate in because he can' be deported or extradited back to where ever he came from. They believe that such lenient 'European' laws create a huge gap in security,

Political Science Japanese Internment
Words: 5176 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

internment camps for the Japanese that were set up and implemented by president Franklin D. Roosevelt. The writer explores the history leading up to the decision and the decision itself. There were six sources used to complete this paper. When Japan attacked Pearl Harbor the American public was outraged and stunned. American citizens had lived with a false sense of security for many years that the soil of the United

Immigration - Drawing the Line
Words: 7210 Length: 25 Document Type: Term Paper

There is no question, however, that immigration issues will remain in the forefront of our national policy debates. Deportation Factors and Crimes Involving Moral Turpitude Research indicates that since the late 1980s, Congress had been tightening the substantive provisions of the immigration laws, to make it far less likely that a convicted criminal alien can find a way to be relieved of expulsion. For many years the basic statutory pattern was

History of Habeas Corpus
Words: 6204 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

history of Habeas Corpus. There are twelve references used for this paper. There have been a number of laws that have survived the test of time and continue to influence the legal world. It is important to look at the history of Habeas Corpus and the role it plays in the law today. The Start of Habeas Corpus Habeas corpus was first introduced in England in 1215 when the Magna Carta was

International Law V Torture in
Words: 7379 Length: 25 Document Type: Thesis

S. Congress 2006). Under a military commission's procedures and rules of evidence, the accused may present evidence, cross examine witnesses against him, and respond to evidence presented against him; attend all the sessions of the trial; and have the rights to counsel and self-representation. The bill does not grant him the right to see all the evidence against him to establish his guilt or innocence. It authorizes the Secretary to

Terry Vs. Ohio: Police Officer
Words: 1773 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

The officer stopped and searched the three men, and recovered arms from two of them. Terry was found guilty of having covered arms and was send to prison for three years. Is the investigation and confiscation of Terry and other men against the Fourth Amendment? The Court in an 8-to-1 decision held that the investigation done by the officer was sensible under the Fourth Amendments and that the arms

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now