Restorative Justice
The purpose of this article was to show that restorative justice is significantly more satisfying as compared to courts for both offenders and victims. This was achieved with a randomized experimental design known as Reintergrative Shaming Experiments RISE. This project is used to compare the effects of standard court processing with those of restorative justice intervention known as conferencing. In the article, the RISE data is used to examine whether conferences are equally beneficial for juvenile victims and adult victims as well (Gal, T & Moyal, 201).
The research method that was used in this article is a stratified randomized experimental design that was used to compare the outcomes of court and conference cases that were held in Canberra, Australia between 1995 and 2000. Shoplifting, drinking, property crimes and violent crimes were assigned within each other randomly to the Restorative Justice Conferences or traditional courts using a computer program. There was the use of a two-factor analysis of covariance ANCOVA for analysis of the data that was found.
The key findings of the article suggest that whereas RJ made adults more satisfied as compared to courts, conference juvenile victims were less satisfied compared to court juvenile victims. The two-factor ANCOVA showed that for all the victims conferences were more satisfying as compared to courts. Furthermore, harm that is more serious is linked to decreased process satisfaction for all victims. A qualitative analysis has been used to identify adult domination and insensitivity when it comes to the special needs of youths as recurring themes (Gal, T & Moyal, 201).
One of the limitations of the study was the fact that there was a small number of young victims that were involved in the RISE study as well as an unbalanced comparison group of the adult victims. Another limitation...
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now