Verified Document

Justice Has Different Meanings In Term Paper

We can thus say with confidence that Thrasymachus was also a wise man of considerable sagacity. He knew that Socrates could move people with the power of his speech and was thus completely prepared to meet his barrage of arguments.

I do not think that Socrates won himself a friend or even an admirer in Thrasymachus because the latter looked significantly bored and uninterested. He even said that he was agreeing where he agreed only to make Socrates happy. It seems that Socrates was more interested in pleasing the others on the scene and winning his approval than he was in Thrasymachus because he had come to know very early in the discussion that Thrasymachus could not be convinced.

Socrates' arguments also lack strength if we study them closely. That is one major flaw of his dialogue with Thrasymachus and at times, we might even want to agree with him that Socrates was actually behaving like a bully. He was bullying people with his insistent arguments and logic into submission but Thrasymachus was not to be won. Thus Socrates had been unsuccessful in this case while Thrasymachus remains true to what he believed in.

Machiavelli's view on Justice in the Prince

The Prince is considered one of the most influential books of the medieval era. Written by Niccolo Machiavelli, the book extensively elaborates on the attributes of a ruler. Remember the ruler in Machiavelli is not a good or a bad ruler; he is simply a ruler as Machiavelli saw one. thus the traditional views of justice and fairness simply do not apply to him. Interestingly Machiavelli was so uninterested in the concept of justice that he chose to talk as little about it as possible. But when he did, he saw it as something condescending for a ruler. In Chapter 18 of his book, he writes:

In actions of all men, especially princes, where there is no recourse to...

A prince should only be concerned with conquering or maintaining a state, for the means will always be judged to be honorable and praiseworthy by each and every person, because the masses always follow appearances and the outcomes of affairs, and the world is nothing other than the masses. The few do not find a place wherever the masses are supported."
Machiavelli was of the view that justice was a sign of weakness and no true ruler could ever be successful with justice as one of his principles. He wrote: "From these causes it arose that Marcus [Aurelius], Pertinax, and Alexander, being all men of modest life, lovers of justice, enemies to cruelty, humane, and benignant, came to a sad end..." (Chapter 19)

Views of justice differ between ages and sages. When thinkers focus on the issue of justice, many related subjects such as compassion, social good etc. must also be considered. Machiavelli however was not bothered by traditional view of justice. He believed in presenting a realistic picture of a ruler who was often too powerful to be compassionate and too awe-inspiring. He was someone who believed in getting his commands enforced with force and by inducing fear. Justice was a lost concept in Machiavelli's book. But it has a significant place in Plato and Socrates' views. And thus they pay considerable attention to the subject. Confucius on the other hand was more concerned with justice that resulted in improvement of the social condition of mankind. His view of justice encompassed far more than just oneself though he was equally interested in a man's personal stand on justice and the resulting fair behavior.

References

Plato. Republic. (1994). Translated by Robin Waterfield; Oxford University Press. Oxford Nicolo Machiavelli. The Prince Written c. 1505, published 1515 translated by W.K. Marriott

Sources used in this document:
References

Plato. Republic. (1994). Translated by Robin Waterfield; Oxford University Press. Oxford Nicolo Machiavelli. The Prince Written c. 1505, published 1515 translated by W.K. Marriott
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Justice for All the Concept
Words: 1770 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

In this way, members of the public most in need of legal aid are provided with counsel that can help them achieve justice instead of losing their life savings on services that nevertheless results in failure. The IOLTA Comparability Rule therefore serves an important function in terms of legal justice that truly extends to all citizens of the country. In conclusion, it has been seen above, that the definition of

Justice Mean to Me What
Words: 1377 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

If the convicted criminal feels that his sentencing was not just and fair, he can 'appeal', and his case would be tried again, if necessary. (Justice and Prisons, how justice works) It must be remembered that in general, when a crime is committed, it can mean that there has been a violation of a local or a state or a federal law, and for which there was no real justification.

Justice and Security Free Balance in the
Words: 2493 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Justice and Security Free Balance in the Administration of Justice and Security Justice and Security policies have always been at the center of international politics, but their nature has changed due to the advent of nuclear weapons and their proliferation, economic interdependence, the end of the Cold War, environmental problems, technological advancements and vulnerabilities, as well as other material and cultural developments typically linked to globalization. This paper will talk about the

Justice As Retribution
Words: 3724 Length: 12 Document Type: Research Paper

Justice as Retribution Every individual in the globe has a perception towards crime, justice, criminals, and many other aspects in relation to criminals. On hearing the term "criminal," every individual reacts differently. There are those who feel that a criminal deserves to die, others feel they should rot in prison and many other divergent views. However, does it ever occur that a criminal can be a criminal, through a legal process

Justice One of the Most Consistent Problems
Words: 2891 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Justice One of the most consistent problems facing the criminal justice system is the influence of institutional culture on the administration of justice, both at the level of the police and the courts. While there are of course written guidelines and laws dictating the actions and decision-making process of both the police and the courts, in practice there is a substantial amount of leeway when it comes to dealing with specific

Justice in the Twentieth Century,
Words: 1694 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

What was particularly ironic was that soccer had always been a game for whites only: blacks were specifically not included. Of course, the movie had a happy ending when South Africa won the World Cup. But the World Cup didn't completely change South Africa. There is still high violence, prompted by economic conditions and a newly released set of citizens. A high percentage of residents also have Aids, another very

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now